CASE STUDY 4: THE BHOPAL GAS TRAGEDY The Union Carbide Corporation (UCC) is a chemical company...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
CASE STUDY 4: THE BHOPAL GAS TRAGEDY The Union Carbide Corporation (UCC) is a chemical company started in 1917. Since 1999 it has been a subsidiary of The Dow Chemical Company. In December 1984 a Union Carbide pesticide plant in the Indian city of Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh (central India) accidentally released 42 tonnes of toxic gas into the air, killing up to 2,000 people and allegedly leading to the cumulative total of 25,000 related deaths. This case study explores the safety measures adopted by the engineers when designing the chemical plant, and how it differed from similar plants operating in the US. It is often quoted as being one of the worst industrial disasters ever. To date, there is still a dispute as to how the accident occurred, but the main issue relates to the design of the plant, its safety measures and the lack of adherence to the adopted safety practices. 42 Discussion questions: ethical issues introduced by case study Should manufacturing safety standards be internationally the same, or could there ever be a situation when safety can be compromised to reduce running costs? In your discussion use the ethical theories (e.g. utilitarianism, rights and duty ethics) as a basis of your reasoning. You might consider balancing the need to secure work for developing nations against competitive bidding for new factories. Should nations be able to set their own safety standards according to the level of resources available to them? 2. Consider, for example, the RAE statement of four fundamental principles on engineering ethics introduced in chapter 1. On a scale of 1 to 10, rate the level of violation of each of the 4 principles by the engineers a) designing the Bhopal plant and b) responsible for maintaining safety equipment and regulations. 3. Do you believe that the US parent company, UCC, neglected a responsibility to guarantee safety to the people of Bhopal, or was this a matter for UCIL? Was UCC justified in defending themselves, stating that the accident was a result of sabotage by a disgruntled employee? 4. Has UCC paid its debt to the people of Bhopal? Is it fair that Warren Anderson is now classed as a fugitive by the Indian courts? CASE STUDY 4: THE BHOPAL GAS TRAGEDY The Union Carbide Corporation (UCC) is a chemical company started in 1917. Since 1999 it has been a subsidiary of The Dow Chemical Company. In December 1984 a Union Carbide pesticide plant in the Indian city of Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh (central India) accidentally released 42 tonnes of toxic gas into the air, killing up to 2,000 people and allegedly leading to the cumulative total of 25,000 related deaths. This case study explores the safety measures adopted by the engineers when designing the chemical plant, and how it differed from similar plants operating in the US. It is often quoted as being one of the worst industrial disasters ever. To date, there is still a dispute as to how the accident occurred, but the main issue relates to the design of the plant, its safety measures and the lack of adherence to the adopted safety practices. 42 Discussion questions: ethical issues introduced by case study Should manufacturing safety standards be internationally the same, or could there ever be a situation when safety can be compromised to reduce running costs? In your discussion use the ethical theories (e.g. utilitarianism, rights and duty ethics) as a basis of your reasoning. You might consider balancing the need to secure work for developing nations against competitive bidding for new factories. Should nations be able to set their own safety standards according to the level of resources available to them? 2. Consider, for example, the RAE statement of four fundamental principles on engineering ethics introduced in chapter 1. On a scale of 1 to 10, rate the level of violation of each of the 4 principles by the engineers a) designing the Bhopal plant and b) responsible for maintaining safety equipment and regulations. 3. Do you believe that the US parent company, UCC, neglected a responsibility to guarantee safety to the people of Bhopal, or was this a matter for UCIL? Was UCC justified in defending themselves, stating that the accident was a result of sabotage by a disgruntled employee? 4. Has UCC paid its debt to the people of Bhopal? Is it fair that Warren Anderson is now classed as a fugitive by the Indian courts?
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
1 The safety health and welfare of the public is the most important point in every code of ethics In ... View the full answer
Related Book For
The Legal Environment of Business
ISBN: 978-0538473996
11th Edition
Authors: Roger E Meiners, Al H. Ringleb, Frances L. Edwards
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
Nussbaum Inc. is a chemical company that is comprised of five independent divisions, located in three different countries. Divisional managers are evaluated based on divisional profitability. Home...
-
Union Carbide (now a subsidiary of Dow Chemical) decided to locate a new plant in a depressed area with high unemployment and chose a small town in West Virginia. It built a state-of-the-art plant...
-
Bhopal gas tragedy is a significant tragic event that has occurred in December 1984. Describing the event and the post-tragedy events, discuss the ethical aspects revolving around this incident. This...
-
The following data represent the square footage and rents (dollars per month) for apartments in the La Jolla area of San Diego, California. (a) Using a graphing utility, draw a scatter plot of the...
-
In discussing Figure, the text states that the private equilibrium output, Q1, is inefficient. By definition, inefficiency is supposed to mean that everyone could be better off with a different...
-
Calculate the elastic potential energy (Uk) of a spring with spring constant k = 50 N/m, displaced Ax = 10 cm from equilibrium.
-
Why are strategic technologies important to strategic planning?
-
Woofer Pet Foods produces a low-calorie dog food for overweight dogs. This product is made from beef products and grain. Each pound of beef costs $0.90, and each pound of grain costs $0.60. A pound...
-
Explain the differences between first-fit, best-fit, and worst-fit memory allocation strategies. What are the trade-offs in terms of memory fragmentation and allocation speed ?
-
Simtek projects year-end EBIT of $800M which is expected to grow at 5% annually, and capital expenditures will equal depreciation. Simtek has $4,590M of 6% perpetual debt trading at face value and no...
-
Consider the option of adding flexibility instead of adding or subtracting capacity. Flexibility allows Line B to be utilized for V8 engines (and allows Line A to be utilized for V6 engines)....
-
Suppose labors share of GDP is 70 percent and capitals is 30 percent, real GDP is growing at a rate of 4 percent a year, the labor force is growing at 2 percent, and the capital stock is growing at 3...
-
A wire-bonding process is said to be in control if the mean pull strength is 10 pounds. It is known that the pull-strength measurements are normally distributed with a standard deviation of 1.5...
-
Suppose a country has a real GDP equal to $1 billion today. If this economy grows at a rate of 4 percent a year, what will be the value of real GDP after five years?
-
A flat plate \(100 \mathrm{~cm}\) long and \(150 \mathrm{~cm}\) wide is held at a temperature of \(20^{\circ} \mathrm{C}\). The plate is immersed in an air stream at \(40^{\circ} \mathrm{C}\) and \(1...
-
Find the values of (a) \(F_{0.95}\) for 15 and 12 degrees of freedom; (b) \(F_{0.99}\) for 5 and 20 degrees of freedom.
-
Which practices best describe "transparency?" Group of answer choices Openness, accountability, and honesty define transparency. In a free society and democratic organizations, transparency is the...
-
Choose a company from the SEC EDGAR Web site for your Key Assignment to evaluate for the impact of convergence to IFRS. Review the financial reports and notes of the company you have chosen from the...
-
Pfennig sued Household Credit Services for violations of the Truth-in-Lending Act. She contended that she was extended credit but was then charged a fee of $29 a month when she went over the $2,000...
-
A land developer started a retirement village in an area known for its large cattle feedlots. Later, after much of the village was built and sold, the developer brought a nuisance action against the...
-
Forgie-Buccioni went into a grocery store for some items. He paid for various items and left the store. He realized he had bought the wrong kind of Drixoral, a cold medication, so left the other...
-
The Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995 and the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in Central Bank of Denver v. First Interstate Bank of Denver represent major victories in the profession's...
-
What are heuristics, and why are they of concern to auditors?
-
Identify and briefly describe the major files that are typically maintained separately from audit working papers.
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App