Question: In the previous question you showed that sometimes there may be no policy that beats every other policy in a majority rule election and, as

In the previous question you showed that sometimes there may be no policy that beats every other policy in a majority rule election and, as a result, the agenda can determine the outcome. In the previous question, all of the policy choices on the agenda were as good as any other, but this is not always the case. Imagine that three voters, L, M, and R, are choosing among seven candidates. The preferences of the voters are given in the following table. Voter M, for example, likes Grumpy the best and Doc the least.

a. Imagine that we vote according to a given agenda starting with Happy vs. Dopey. Who wins? We will help you with this one. Voter L ranks Happy above Dopey, so voter L will vote for Happy. Voter M prefers Dopey to Happy, so voter M will vote for Dopey. Voter R ranks Dopey above Happy so voter R will vote for Dopey. So _____ wins.
b. Now take the winner from part a and match him against Grumpy. Who wins?
c. Now take the winner from part b and match him against Sneezy. Who wins?
d. Now take the winner from part c and match him against Sleepy. Who wins?
e. Now take the winner from part d and match him against Bashful. Who wins?
f. Finally take the winner from part e and match him against Doc. Who wins?
g. We have now run through the entire agenda so the winner from part f is the final winner. Here is the point. Look carefully at the preferences of the three voters. Compare the preferences of each voter for Happy (or Grumpy or Dopey) with the final winner. Fill in the blank: Majority rule has led to an outcome that _____ regards as worse than some other possible outcome. The answer to this question should shock you.

Preferences for President of Voters L, M, R Voter L Voter M Voter R 1st Choice Happy Gumpy Dopey 2nd Choice Sneezy Dopey Grumpy Happy Dopey Bashful Sleepy 6th Choice Snezy 3rd Choice 4th Choice 5th Choice Happy Sleepy Sneezy Grumpy Doc 7th Choice Sleepy Doc Bashful

Step by Step Solution

★★★★★

3.56 Rating (170 Votes )

There are 3 Steps involved in it

1 Expert Approved Answer

Step: 1 Unlock

a Dopey wins b Grumpy wins c Sneezy wins d Sleepy wins ... View full answer

Question Has Been Solved by an Expert!

Get step-by-step solutions from verified subject matter experts

Step: 2 Unlock

Step: 3 Unlock

Document Format (1 attachment)

651-B-E-M-E (2967).docx

120 KBs Word File

Students Have Also Explored These Related Economics Questions!

In the previous question, you were asked to illustrate why the mad cow disease announcement initially caused the U. S. equilibrium price of beef to fall and the quantity to rise. Show that if the...

In the previous question, you decide to pay off the car loan and invest the difference. Now you no longer have a $ 350 per month car payment. Suggest some ways you might use these additional funds.

In the previous question, suppose your holding period was five months instead of seven. What is your annualized return? What do you conclude in general about the length of your holding period and...

In the previous question, you showed that sometimes there may be no policy that beats every other policy in a majority rule election and, as a result, the agenda can determine the outcome. In the...

1.5. In the previous question, you showed that sometimes there may be no policy that beats every other policy in a majority rule election and, as a result, the agenda can determine the outcome. In...

In the previous question, you showed that some- times there may be no policy that beats every other policy in a majority rule election and, as a result, the agenda can determine the outcome. In the...

\f530US1 290 Unit: $U74 [10-23-01 13:25:52] PAGES PGT: OPLG OCTOBER TERM, 1999 Syllabus SANTA FE INDEPENDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT v. DOE, individually and as next friend for her minor children, et al....

Chapter Six Union Organizing Campaigns This chapter is the first of two chapters that examine how unions organize new bargaining units and how and why employers attempt to avoid being unionized....

One mole of n-butane is contained in a cylinder-piston system. The system undergoes an isothermal expansion at constant pressure until equilibrium is reached. The initial pressure is 10 bar, the...

In 10 years you are planning on retiring and buying a house in Oviedo, Florida. The house you are looking at currently costs $ 100,000 and is expected to increase in value each year at a rate of 5...

In 2 0 0 0 you were granted 6 0 0 is 0 s by your emploper with a stray price of $ 5 ? share. In 2 0 0 4 when the options vested, the company's stock was trading for $ 7 ? share. In 2 0 0 6 , you...

Explain various marketing orientation

Calculate the mass of an atom of (a) helium, (b) iron, and (c) lead. Give your answers in grams. The atomic masses of these atoms are 4.00 u, 55.9 u, and 207 u, respectively.

The paragraph preceding Example 1.1 in the text mentions that the atomic mass of aluminum is 27.0u = 27.0 x 1.66 x 10-27 kg. Example 1.1 says that 27.0u g of aluminum contains 6.02 x 1023 atoms. (a)...

On your wedding day your lover gives you a gold ring of mass 3.80 g. Fifty years later its mass is 3.35 g. On the average, how many atoms were abraded from the ring during each second of your...

Question 14 (1 point) Saved Determine whether the scatterplot shows little or no association, a negative association, a linear association, a moderately strong association, or a very strong...

On December 31, 2013, Burton, Inc. leased machinery with a fair value of $1,050,000 from Cey Rentals Co. The agreement is a six-year noncancelable lease requiring annual payments of $200,000...

Bank Analysis Step 1 Go to FDiC.gov Go to Resources and click on Data Tools Click on Go to Bank Find Suite Click on Run Financial Reports by Institution Step 2 On the left, under the Search for...