Oracle Corporation initiated a tender offer for the shares of PeopleSoft, Inc., on June 6, 2003. The
Question:
Oracle Corporation initiated a tender offer for the shares of PeopleSoft, Inc., on June 6, 2003. The U.S. government, acting through the Antitrust Division of the Department of Justice, and the states of Connecticut, Hawaii, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, New York, North Dakota, Ohio, and Texas (collectively, the plaintiffs) brought suit on February 26, 2004, seeking to enjoin Oracle from acquiring, directly or indirectly, all or any part of the stock of PeopleSoft. Both Oracle and PeopleSoft license software applications that automate the overall data-processing functions of businesses and similar entities. These applications are called enterprise application software (EAS). Oracle and PeopleSoft both develop, produce, market, and service enterprise resource planning (ERP) system software, which integrates most of an entity's data across all or most of the entity's activities. ERP software includes programs for human relations management (HRM), financial management systems (FMS), customer relations management (CRM), supply chain management (SCM), product life cycle management, and business intelligence (BI), among many others. These are called the pillars. Although ERP encompasses many pillars, the plaintiffs asserted claims with respect to only two pillars: HRM and FMS. They defined the relevant product market as those HRM and FMS products able to meet the needs of large and complex enterprises with "high functional needs" and asserted that the only players in this market were Oracle, PeopleSoft, and SAP America. The plaintiffs also alleged that the relevant geographic market was confined to the United States. As a result, they argued that the proposed merger would constrict this highly concentrated oligopoly to a duopoly of SAP and a merged Oracle/PeopleSoft. Oracle contended that this market definition was legally and practicably too narrow for a number of reasons, including (1) "high function"HRM and FMS software does not exist and is only a label created by the plaintiffs; (2) there is just one market for all HRM and FMS/ERP products; (3) many firms besides the three compete in the larger HRM/FMS market; and (4) the geographic area of competition is worldwide or, at the very least, the United States and Europe. Is Oracle in violation of Section 7 of the Clayton Act? Explain. United States v. Oracle Corp., 331 F. Supp. 2d 1098 (N.D. Cal. 2004).
Corporation A Corporation is a legal form of business that is separate from its owner. In other words, a corporation is a business or organization formed by a group of people, and its right and liabilities separate from those of the individuals involved. It may...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Step by Step Answer:
Answer rating: 63% (11 reviews)
Oracle did not violate the Clayton Act because the plaintiffs could ...View the full answer
Answered By
Ashington Waweru
I am a lecturer, research writer and also a qualified financial analyst and accountant. I am qualified and articulate in many disciplines including English, Accounting, Finance, Quantitative spreadsheet analysis, Economics, and Statistics. I am an expert with sixteen years of experience in online industry-related work. I have a master's in business administration and a bachelor’s degree in education, accounting, and economics options.
I am a writer and proofreading expert with sixteen years of experience in online writing, proofreading, and text editing. I have vast knowledge and experience in writing techniques and styles such as APA, ASA, MLA, Chicago, Turabian, IEEE, and many others.
I am also an online blogger and research writer with sixteen years of writing and proofreading articles and reports. I have written many scripts and articles for blogs, and I also specialize in search engine
I have sixteen years of experience in Excel data entry, Excel data analysis, R-studio quantitative analysis, SPSS quantitative analysis, research writing, and proofreading articles and reports. I will deliver the highest quality online and offline Excel, R, SPSS, and other spreadsheet solutions within your operational deadlines. I have also compiled many original Excel quantitative and text spreadsheets which solve client’s problems in my research writing career.
I have extensive enterprise resource planning accounting, financial modeling, financial reporting, and company analysis: customer relationship management, enterprise resource planning, financial accounting projects, and corporate finance.
I am articulate in psychology, engineering, nursing, counseling, project management, accounting, finance, quantitative spreadsheet analysis, statistical and economic analysis, among many other industry fields and academic disciplines. I work to solve problems and provide accurate and credible solutions and research reports in all industries in the global economy.
I have taught and conducted masters and Ph.D. thesis research for specialists in Quantitative finance, Financial Accounting, Actuarial science, Macroeconomics, Microeconomics, Risk Management, Managerial Economics, Engineering Economics, Financial economics, Taxation and many other disciplines including water engineering, psychology, e-commerce, mechanical engineering, leadership and many others.
I have developed many courses on online websites like Teachable and Thinkific. I also developed an accounting reporting automation software project for Utafiti sacco located at ILRI Uthiru Kenya when I was working there in year 2001.
I am a mature, self-motivated worker who delivers high-quality, on-time reports which solve client’s problems accurately.
I have written many academic and professional industry research papers and tutored many clients from college to university undergraduate, master's and Ph.D. students, and corporate professionals. I anticipate your hiring me.
I know I will deliver the highest quality work you will find anywhere to award me your project work. Please note that I am looking for a long-term work relationship with you. I look forward to you delivering the best service to you.