$1.$ Based on the material provided in the case: Medical Professionals For Informed Consent v$,$ Commissioner Of Health For The State Of New York And The New York State Department Of Health, et$.$al$.$

A$.$ What is the question before the court in this case? Students should phrase the issue of the case in the form of one or two brief statements $($e$.$g$.,$ the issue is whether or not a woman$$s right to privacy allows her to have an abortion$).$

B$.$ What legal theories and arguments did the plaintiffs present?$$ You must include relevant facts of the case to support the legal theories and arguments.

C$.$ What legal theories and arguments the defendants present?$$ You must include relevant facts of the case to support the legal theories and arguments.

D$.$ What legal theories and arguments does Judge Gerard Neri used to support his final determination?

E$.$ Do you agree with the position of the state Supreme Court judge?$$ Why?