1. Develop an argument supporting the company's right to use pulleys from The Pulley Place.

2. Assume the role of Lodge 138's grievance committee chairperson. How would you try to convince an arbitrator that the company's action violated the collective bargaining agreement?

3. As an arbitrator, how would you rule? Why?

1. As the labor relations manager for the company, how would you argue a case supporting your client's actions?

2. Assume the role of Local 491 chief steward. How would you support your contention that the company violated the collective bargaining agreement?

3. As an arbitrator, how would you rule? Why?

1. As the City of Ditchburn personnel director, how would you present your case that the transfer of Jose Obradors did not violate the agreement?

2. As a local union official, how would you argue that the City's action regarding Jose Obradors' transfer violated the contract?

3. As an arbitrator, how would you rule? Why?