3. In January 2017, President Donald Trump issued an executive order to prevent visitors from seven...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
3. In January 2017, President Donald Trump issued an executive order to prevent visitors from seven predominantly Muslim countries categorized as having a heightened terror risk from entering the United States for a 90-day period. The state of Hawaii challenged the constitutionality of Trump's order in court. The president revoked his order but in September 2017 issued a similar, revised proclamation. Hawaii filed suit again and argued that the president did not have authority under Article II or from congressional statute to ban travelers from the listed countries. It also argued that the order was overbroad, and that, in targeting Muslims, it violated the establishment clause. Hawaii won its claim in the lower courts. The president appealed and the Supreme Court took the case, Trump v. Hawaii. The Supreme Court's first question was whether the courts had the authority to act on Hawaii's claim against the president's action. However, in its ruling, the Court looked past the initial question and found that President Trump's actions did not violate the president's constitutional or statutory authority, and the Court upheld the September 2017 proclamation limiting entry by the banned nationals. (A) Identify the legal concern that is common to both Trump v. Hawaii (2017) and Baker v. Carr (1962). (B) Based on the concern identified in part A, explain why the facts of Baker v. Carr led to a different holding than the holding in Hawaii v. Trump. (C) Explain how a presidential administration could use the decision in Hawaii v. Trump to further shape United States foreign policy. 3. In January 2017, President Donald Trump issued an executive order to prevent visitors from seven predominantly Muslim countries categorized as having a heightened terror risk from entering the United States for a 90-day period. The state of Hawaii challenged the constitutionality of Trump's order in court. The president revoked his order but in September 2017 issued a similar, revised proclamation. Hawaii filed suit again and argued that the president did not have authority under Article II or from congressional statute to ban travelers from the listed countries. It also argued that the order was overbroad, and that, in targeting Muslims, it violated the establishment clause. Hawaii won its claim in the lower courts. The president appealed and the Supreme Court took the case, Trump v. Hawaii. The Supreme Court's first question was whether the courts had the authority to act on Hawaii's claim against the president's action. However, in its ruling, the Court looked past the initial question and found that President Trump's actions did not violate the president's constitutional or statutory authority, and the Court upheld the September 2017 proclamation limiting entry by the banned nationals. (A) Identify the legal concern that is common to both Trump v. Hawaii (2017) and Baker v. Carr (1962). (B) Based on the concern identified in part A, explain why the facts of Baker v. Carr led to a different holding than the holding in Hawaii v. Trump. (C) Explain how a presidential administration could use the decision in Hawaii v. Trump to further shape United States foreign policy.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Answer A The legal concern that is common to both Trump v Hawaii 2017 and Baker v Carr 1962 is the i... View the full answer
Related Book For
The Legal Environment Of Business A Managerial Approach Theory To Practice
ISBN: 9781260247800
4th Edition
Authors: Sean Melvin, Enrique Guerra-Pujol
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these law questions
-
Read the case study "Southwest Airlines," found in Part 2 of your textbook. Review the "Guide to Case Analysis" found on pp. CA1 - CA11 of your textbook. (This guide follows the last case in the...
-
A week after assuming office, President Donald J. Trump issued an executive order suspending the entry of all refugees to the United States for 120 days, barring Syrian refugees indefinitely, and...
-
The per-unit cost of an item is its average total cost (5 total cost/quantity). Suppose that a new cell phone application costs $100,000 to develop and only $.50 per unit to deliver to each cell...
-
Identify the three different types of work teams. How does each improve responsiveness and effectiveness?
-
Data from the office for national Statistics show that the mean age at which men in great Britain get married is 30.8 years (the Guardian, February 15, 2013). A news reporter noted that this...
-
What is a secular term?
-
South Carolina Corporation has one temporary difference at the end of 2008 that will reverse and cause taxable amounts of $55,000 in 2009, $60,000 in 2010, and $65,000 in 2011. South Carolinas pretax...
-
Specify and Explain all parts of a SQL Server error message.?
-
a. Describe the emerging and evolution of Australian central bank (The Reserve Bank of Australia), and the roles of the central bank. b. Discuss the regulatory evolution on Australian financial...
-
The following income statement and balance sheets for Virtual Gaming Systems are provided. VIRTUAL GAMING SYSTEMS Income Statement For the Year Ended December 3 1 , 2 0 2 4 Net sales $ 3 , 0 2 1 , 0...
-
At June 30, Almond Co.'s cash balance was $10,012 before adjustments, while its ending bank statement balance was $10,772. Check number 101 was issued June 2 in the amount of $95, but was erroneously...
-
At the end of June, the job cost sheets at Ace Roofers show the following costs accumulated on three jobs. At June 3 0 Job 5 Job 6 Job 7 Direct materials $ 1 8 , 0 0 0 $ 3 4 , 5 0 0 $ 2 8 , 5 0 0...
-
Suppose Union University has spent $10,000 on an option to purchase land for new dormitories at a price of $100,000. Also assume that it is later offered an equally attractive site for $95,000. What...
-
After graduating from high school, Jose is thinking about going to college. The college tuition is $18,000 a year. Instead of going to college, Jose could take a full-time job that pays $28,000. What...
-
Write a response about the following statement First thing a manufacturer should determine before adding new products to its assortment
-
Independent random samples of sizes n1 = 30 and n2 = 50 are taken from two normal populations having the means 1 = 78 and 2 = 75 and the variances 21 = 150 and 22 = 200. Use the results of Exercise...
-
Convert 52 nm to sm.
-
A helicopter has a rotor diameter of 30 ft and it is being operated in a hover at 286.5 rpm. Find the tip speed Vt of the rotor.
-
The airplane in Problem 6 starts from a brakeslocked position on the runway. The airplane takes off at an airspeed of 200 fps. Find the time for the aircraft to reach takeoff speed.
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App