A particularly difficult issue with revenue recognition occurs when multiple elements are essentially sold to the...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
A particularly difficult issue with revenue recognition occurs when multiple "elements" are essentially sold to the customer in one transaction (in accounting lingo this is sometimes referred to as "multiple-element deliverables"). There are numerous examples of this in practice: computer hardware and software, equipment and installation, equipment and service/maintenance agreements, cell phones and cellular service, etc. The accounting for "multiple-element" transactions becomes particularly challenging when these "elements" are delivered at different times. The issue becomes: How much revenue do I allocate to the different elements and when do I recognize these revenues? Apple's accounting for sales of its iPhones demonstrates the difficulties that can arise when applying Generally Accepted Accounting Principles, particularly when the principles were not necessarily designed to capture the economics of an involving industry like the software and hardware industries. Case: Accounting for the iPhone at Apple, Inc.: At the time the case was written, iPhone sales were subject to a specific set of revenue recognition guidelines known as SOP 97-2. These guidelines were originally set forth to address revenue recognition issues arising in the software industry. Because the iPhone's h software was considered an integral part of the transaction, Apple was required to follow these guidelines when determining the revenue recognition policy for iPhone sales. Under these guidelines, if the value of any "undelivered" elements to a transaction could not be determined, sales for the transaction must be recognized under "subscription" accounting in other words, the entire amount of cash from the sale would be deferred and recognized ratably into revenue over some period of time. This method is in contrast to the more typical "point of sale" accounting method that would recognize the revenue and related cost of goods sold when the phone is transferred to the customer (i.e.. "at the point of sale"). Exhibit 3 in the case provides an example of the journal entries that would be recorded for a hypothetical iPhone sale under these guidelines. In the fourth quarter of 2008, Apple decided to supplement their required financial disclosures with voluntary "non-GAAP" disclosures (also known as "pro forma" reporting). We will also encounter "pro forma" reporting in the Groupon case. In Apple's case, their goal was to provide information about what their financial statements would look like without the requirement to record revenue on a subscription basis. Case Questions: 1. Using the hypothetical example in Exhibit 3 of the case, calculate the gross profit associated with the sale of an iPhone under subscription accounting in 1) the quarter of the sale and 2) each of the subsequent seven quarters. Calculate the gross profit that would be reported under "point of sale" accounting in the same quarters. 2. If the company had always used "point of sale" accounting, which accounts on the income statement and balance sheet would change and in what direction? Would their cash flows have changed? 3. a. Calculate the company's return on assets and return on shareholders' equity for 2008 using the reported financial statements. b. How would these ratios change if the company had used point of sale accounting? No calculations are necessary, a directional effect is sufficient along with your reasoning. 4. Do you agree with management's decision to issue non-GAAP financial statements? Are there any potential costs to issuing such disclosures? 5. If you were the CFO of Apple, would you lobby the FASB to change GAAP? A particularly difficult issue with revenue recognition occurs when multiple "elements" are essentially sold to the customer in one transaction (in accounting lingo this is sometimes referred to as "multiple-element deliverables"). There are numerous examples of this in practice: computer hardware and software, equipment and installation, equipment and service/maintenance agreements, cell phones and cellular service, etc. The accounting for "multiple-element" transactions becomes particularly challenging when these "elements" are delivered at different times. The issue becomes: How much revenue do I allocate to the different elements and when do I recognize these revenues? Apple's accounting for sales of its iPhones demonstrates the difficulties that can arise when applying Generally Accepted Accounting Principles, particularly when the principles were not necessarily designed to capture the economics of an involving industry like the software and hardware industries. Case: Accounting for the iPhone at Apple, Inc.: At the time the case was written, iPhone sales were subject to a specific set of revenue recognition guidelines known as SOP 97-2. These guidelines were originally set forth to address revenue recognition issues arising in the software industry. Because the iPhone's h software was considered an integral part of the transaction, Apple was required to follow these guidelines when determining the revenue recognition policy for iPhone sales. Under these guidelines, if the value of any "undelivered" elements to a transaction could not be determined, sales for the transaction must be recognized under "subscription" accounting in other words, the entire amount of cash from the sale would be deferred and recognized ratably into revenue over some period of time. This method is in contrast to the more typical "point of sale" accounting method that would recognize the revenue and related cost of goods sold when the phone is transferred to the customer (i.e.. "at the point of sale"). Exhibit 3 in the case provides an example of the journal entries that would be recorded for a hypothetical iPhone sale under these guidelines. In the fourth quarter of 2008, Apple decided to supplement their required financial disclosures with voluntary "non-GAAP" disclosures (also known as "pro forma" reporting). We will also encounter "pro forma" reporting in the Groupon case. In Apple's case, their goal was to provide information about what their financial statements would look like without the requirement to record revenue on a subscription basis. Case Questions: 1. Using the hypothetical example in Exhibit 3 of the case, calculate the gross profit associated with the sale of an iPhone under subscription accounting in 1) the quarter of the sale and 2) each of the subsequent seven quarters. Calculate the gross profit that would be reported under "point of sale" accounting in the same quarters. 2. If the company had always used "point of sale" accounting, which accounts on the income statement and balance sheet would change and in what direction? Would their cash flows have changed? 3. a. Calculate the company's return on assets and return on shareholders' equity for 2008 using the reported financial statements. b. How would these ratios change if the company had used point of sale accounting? No calculations are necessary, a directional effect is sufficient along with your reasoning. 4. Do you agree with management's decision to issue non-GAAP financial statements? Are there any potential costs to issuing such disclosures? 5. If you were the CFO of Apple, would you lobby the FASB to change GAAP?
Expert Answer:
Related Book For
Financial Accounting and Reporting a Global Perspective
ISBN: 978-1408076866
4th edition
Authors: Michel Lebas, Herve Stolowy, Yuan Ding
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these business communication questions
-
The table below shows the instruction type breakdown of a given application executed on 1, 2, 4, or 8 processors. Using this data, you will be exploring the speedup of applications on parallel...
-
A recent study found that 2% of adults with a BMI at the 90th percentile or higher go to a health club at least once per week for exercise. Previous research has found that 1% of people go to a...
-
Planning is one of the most important management functions in any business. A front office managers first step in planning should involve determine the departments goals. Planning also includes...
-
If you wanted to double $1,000 in 10 years' time, what average rate of return would you require on your investment?
-
Use the Autos of Red Deer data in exercise S12A-4 to compute the following: a. Payments to employees b. Payments of other expenses
-
Show that in a flow network with noninteger capacities, the Ford-Fulkerson algorithm may not terminate.
-
E ALUATIN G H E ALTH CARE CO E RAGE. Blake Wright was a self-employed window washer earning approximately $700 per week. One day, while cleaning windows on the eighth floor of the First National Bank...
-
Aymans Office Supplies Company recently had a new information system installed to help its managers with inventory. In speaking with the managers, you notice that they seemed disgruntled with the...
-
11. You purchase a 20 year junk bond with a Yield to Maturity of 15%. If the bond pays an annual coupon of $750 and has a par value of $10,000, what is the Market Value of the bond? Please show your...
-
How can distributive leadership models, characterized by shared decision-making and collaborative problem-solving among team members, enhance organizational adaptability and innovation in...
-
In Exercises 21-24, use these results from the "1-Panel-THC" test for marijuana use, which is provided by the company Drug Test Success: Among 143 subjects with positive test results, there are 24...
-
Please attached excel solution with formulars. An electronics manufacturer wants to expand its market in Europe. The demand in Europe is forecasted as: England France Spain Germany Italy Sweden 9 16...
-
Write a 1,500-2,000-word evaluation paper using the following instructions to complete this assignment. Go to the FBI Uniform Crime Reporting Program website (See link in the Class Resources). Search...
-
The y-intercept of the graph of the exponential function f(x) = 7.5(0.98)* is. Answer:
-
Using the following data definitions: bytel BYTE OFFh, 1, 2 byte2 BYTE 14h wordl WORD OFFFFh, 1, 2 word2 WORD 3 word3 SWORD 7FFFh, 8000h word4 SWORD 9000h dword1 DWORD 10h, 20h, 30h, 40h dArray DWORD...
-
Required information The following information applies to the questions displayed below.) Year 1 total cash dividends Year 2 total.cash dividends Year 3 total cash dividends Year 4 total cash...
-
Which one of the following anhydrous chloride is not obtained on direct heating of its hydrated chloride? (A) BaCl2 (B) CaClz (C) MgCl2 (D) SrCl2
-
The balance sheet of the Mutter & Tochter companies, as of 31 December X1, is given in the following table (Mutter Co. is the parent and Tochter Co. is the subsidiary). Separate balance sheets as at...
-
Multiple Choice Question Select the right answer (only one possible answer unless otherwise stated). 1 The most appropriate method of depreciation of land is (a) The straight-line method (b) The...
-
The Smetana Company has a commercial activity in the sector of beauty products and cosmetics. Required 1. With the help of the balance sheet, income statement, and additional information (see...
-
Research new software products that assist in communications management for large projects. Write a short paper summarizing your findings. Include Web sites for software vendors and your opinion of...
-
Review the following scenarios, and then write a paragraph for each one describing what media you think would be most appropriate to use and why. See Table 10-2 for suggestions. a. Many of the...
-
Review the templates for various project documents provided in this chapter. Pick one of them and apply it to a project of your choice. Make suggestions for improving the template. LO.1
![Mobile App Logo](https://dsd5zvtm8ll6.cloudfront.net/includes/images/mobile/finalLogo.png)
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App