Let's see whether quadratic voting can avoid the paradox of voting that arose in Table 5.3...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Let's see whether quadratic voting can avoid the paradox of voting that arose in Table 5.3 when using 1p1v in a series of paired-choice majority votes. To reexamine this situation using quadratic voting, the table below presents the maximum willingness to pay of Garcia, Johnson, and Lee for each of the three public goods. Notice that each person's numbers for willingness to pay match her or his ordering of preferences (1st choice, 2nd choice, 3rd choice) presented in Table 5.3. Thus, Garcia is willing to spend more on her first choice of national defense ($400) than on her second choice of a road ($100) or her third choice of a weather warning system ($0). TABLE 5.3 Paradox of Voting Preferences Public Good Garcia Johnson Lee National defense 1st choice 3d choice 2d choice Road 2d cholce 1st choice 3d choice Weather warning system 3d cholce 2d choice 1st choice Election Voting Outcomes: Winner 1. National defense vs. road National defense (preferred by Garcia and Lee) 2. Road vs. weather warning system Road (preferred by Garcia and Johnson) 3. National defense vs. weather warning system Weather warning system (preferred by Johnson and Lee) Individual Voter Willingness to Pay for the Listed Public Projects Public Good Garcia Johnson Lee National defense $400 $50 $150 Road 100 300 100 Weather warning system 150 250 a. Assume that voting will be done using a quadratic voting system and that Garcia, Johnson, and Lee are each given $500 that can only be spent on purchasing votes (i.e., any unspent money has to be returned). How many votes will Garcia purchase to support national defense? How many for the road? Place those values into the appropriate blanks in the table below and then do the same for the blanks for Johnson and Lee. Assume there are no additional costs beyond the cost of purchasing votes and that votes must be purchased in whole numbers. Instructions: Enter your answers as a whole number. Number of Votes Purchased by Each Voter for the Listed Public Projects Public Good National defense Garcia Johnson Lee 12 Road 17 Weather warning system b. Across all three voters, how many votes are there in favor of national defense? The road? The weather warning system? Votes for national defense: Votes for road: Votes for weather warning system: c. If a paired-choice vote is taken of national defense versus the road, which one wins? (Click to select) d. If a paired-choice vote is taken of the road versus the weather warning system, which one wins? (Click to select) e. If a paired-choice vote is taken of national defense versus the weather warning system, which one wins? (Click to select) Let's see whether quadratic voting can avoid the paradox of voting that arose in Table 5.3 when using 1p1v in a series of paired-choice majority votes. To reexamine this situation using quadratic voting, the table below presents the maximum willingness to pay of Garcia, Johnson, and Lee for each of the three public goods. Notice that each person's numbers for willingness to pay match her or his ordering of preferences (1st choice, 2nd choice, 3rd choice) presented in Table 5.3. Thus, Garcia is willing to spend more on her first choice of national defense ($400) than on her second choice of a road ($100) or her third choice of a weather warning system ($0). TABLE 5.3 Paradox of Voting Preferences Public Good Garcia Johnson Lee National defense 1st choice 3d choice 2d choice Road 2d cholce 1st choice 3d choice Weather warning system 3d cholce 2d choice 1st choice Election Voting Outcomes: Winner 1. National defense vs. road National defense (preferred by Garcia and Lee) 2. Road vs. weather warning system Road (preferred by Garcia and Johnson) 3. National defense vs. weather warning system Weather warning system (preferred by Johnson and Lee) Individual Voter Willingness to Pay for the Listed Public Projects Public Good Garcia Johnson Lee National defense $400 $50 $150 Road 100 300 100 Weather warning system 150 250 a. Assume that voting will be done using a quadratic voting system and that Garcia, Johnson, and Lee are each given $500 that can only be spent on purchasing votes (i.e., any unspent money has to be returned). How many votes will Garcia purchase to support national defense? How many for the road? Place those values into the appropriate blanks in the table below and then do the same for the blanks for Johnson and Lee. Assume there are no additional costs beyond the cost of purchasing votes and that votes must be purchased in whole numbers. Instructions: Enter your answers as a whole number. Number of Votes Purchased by Each Voter for the Listed Public Projects Public Good National defense Garcia Johnson Lee 12 Road 17 Weather warning system b. Across all three voters, how many votes are there in favor of national defense? The road? The weather warning system? Votes for national defense: Votes for road: Votes for weather warning system: c. If a paired-choice vote is taken of national defense versus the road, which one wins? (Click to select) d. If a paired-choice vote is taken of the road versus the weather warning system, which one wins? (Click to select) e. If a paired-choice vote is taken of national defense versus the weather warning system, which one wins? (Click to select)
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Answers a Garcia purchase 32 votes for support of National Defense and Garci... View the full answer
Related Book For
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these economics questions
-
All of the following are employer-provided benefits except : Group of answer choices Social Security. wages. sick and holiday pay. health insurance.
-
Let us modify Computer Exercise C8.4 by using voting outcomes in 1990 for incumbents who were elected in 1988. Candidate A was elected in 1988 and was seeking reelection in 1990; voteA90 is Candidate...
-
When would a company be willing to pay more than the face amount (a premium) for a held-to-maturity security?
-
Consider the cash flows in Table P6.7 for the following investment projects (MARR = 15%). Determine the annual equivalent worth for each project at i = 15% and determine the acceptability of each...
-
The lead example of this chapter concerned the deflection of a beam with supported ends subject to uniform loading. The boundary-value problem governing this physical situation is with boundary...
-
Derive the conclusion of the following symbolized arguments. Use conditional proof or indirect proof as needed.
-
Two bonding agents, \(A\) and \(B\), are available for making a laminated beam. Of 50 beams made with Agent \(A, 11\) failed a stress test, whereas 19 of the 50 beams made with Agent \(B\) failed. At...
-
Ink Spot Inc. is a new business located in upstate New York. It prints promotional flyers for local businesses and distributes them at public places or area events. The flyers are either placed on...
-
Assume Lance Corp. has the following reported amounts: Sales revenue $796,000, Sales returns and allowances $23,000, Cost of goods sold $517,910, and Operating expenses $171,600. . When typing your...
-
Explain how you would determine how much profit was generated from orders placed in April 2009. Figure 1-5: ORDERS Order# Customer# Orderdate Shipdate Shipstreet Shipcity Shipstate Shipzip Shipcost...
-
A uniform slender rod of total length 800 mm and mass 5 kg is pinned at O (200 mm from one end) and is initially held by a cable at its other end at A as shown, such that the rod is at a angle of 30...
-
Define and describe the Custodial and Rehabilitation Models of incarceration. What are the pros and cons of each? Which do you feel is the most relevant in today's society and why? In your responses,...
-
Summarize some of the elements in New Zealand's political, economic, and cultural environments that can impact the market opportunity for Walmart expansion.
-
benefits for suppliers and trading partners estimates the demand forecasting. [Nilaikan LIMA (3) faedah untuk pembekal dan rakan kongsi perdagangan menganggarkan ramalan permintaan.] (5 Marks/...
-
Fird Inc. dividends during the last years were $1.00 in 2017, $1.08 in 2018, $1.17 in 2019 and $1.26 in 2020. The company will issue new stocks at $50 with flotation costs of 6%. What will be the...
-
Does Maslow's hierarchy of needs provide a universal model of human motivation? Why or why not?
-
Identify those that have stake in the outcome of the collaborative Identification of the problem to be solved- Identify barriers to creating a solution Clarification of the agreed outcome Clarify the...
-
What is the maximum volume of 0.25 M sodium hypochlorite solution (NaOCl, laundry bleach) that can be prepared by dilution of 1.00 L of 0.80 M NaOCl?
-
The manager of a frozen yogurt store claims that a medium-size serving contains an average of more than 4 ounces of yogurt. From a random sample of 14 servings, she obtains a mean of 4.31 ounces and...
-
1. Summarize the results of John's analysis in one paragraph that a manager, not a forecaster, can understand. 2. Describe the trend and seasonal effects that appear to be present in the sales data...
-
1. How many units would you forecast for a day in which the high temperature is 89 degrees? 2. How many units would you forecast for a day in which the high temperature is 41 degrees? 3. Based on the...
-
Because we cannot see any obvious difference between the ends of a bar magnet, could it be that like poles attract each other and unlike poles repel each other?
-
If you are constructing a parallel-plate capacitor, having air and paper as the dielectric medium between the plates, which dielectric material within the plates will make the capacitor act better?...
-
(a) Is the interaction between a charged object and an electrically neutral object always attractive? Why or why not? (b) In Figure 27.4, which type of magnetic pole is induced at the top of each...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App