Although he was hired as a financial analyst after completing his business degree, David Ong's first...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Although he was hired as a financial analyst after completing his business degree, David Ong's first assignment at Wang Systems was with the firm's marketing department. Historically, the major focus of David's sales effort was on demonstrating the technological superiority of the firm's product line. However, many of Wang's traditional customers have embarked on cost-cutting programs in recent years, and as a result, Wang's marketing director asked David's boss, the Chief Financial Officer, to lend David to marketing to help them develop some analytical procedures for the sales force to use that will demonstrate the financial benefits of buying Wang's products. Page 7 of 8 Wang Systems manufactures fluid control systems that are used in a wide variety of applications, including sewage treatment systems, petroleum refining, and pipeline transmission. The complete systems include sophisticated pumps, sensors, and control units that continuously monitor the flow rate and the pressure along a line, and automatically adjust the pump to meet preset pressure specifications. Most of Wang's systems are made up of standard components, and most complete systems are priced from $50,000 to $100,000. Because of the highly technical nature of the products, the majority of Wang's sales force have backgrounds in engineering. As he began to think about his assignment, David quickly came to the conclusion that the best way to sell a system to a cost-conscious customer would be to conduct a capital budgeting analysis which would demonstrate the system's cost effectiveness. Further, he concluded that the best way to begin was with an analysis for one of Wang's actual customers. From discussions with the firm's sales people, David decided that a proposed sale to Selangor River Council (SRC) was perfect to use as an illustration. SRC is considering the purchase of one of Wang's standard fluid control systems which costs $80,000 including taxes and delivery. It would cost SRC another $5,000 to install the equipment, and this expense would be added to the invoice price of the equipment to determine the depreciable basis of the system. For taxation purposes the system can be depreciated over 6 years, using the following schedule, but has an economic life of 8 years and it will be used for that period. After 8 years, the system will probably be obsolete, so it will have a zero salvage value at that time. Current depreciation allowances are: Year 1: 20% Year 2: 32% Year 3: 19% Year 4: 12% Year 5: 11% Year 6: 6% This system would replace a control system which has been used for about 20 years and which has been fully depreciated. The costs for removing the current system are about equal to its scrap value, so its current net market value is zero. The advantages of the new system are that (1) it would be more energy efficient, (ii) it would reduce waste, because the chemical processes could be more carefully controlled, and (ii) it would require less human monitoring and maintenance. In total, the new system would save SRC $25,000 annually in before-tax operating costs. For capital budgeting, SRC uses a 10% cost of capital, and the applicable tax rate is 40%. Mary Seong, Wang's marketing manager, gave David a free hand in structuring the analysis. Now put yourself in David's position and develop a capital budgeting analysis for the fluid control systems. As you go through the analysis, keep in mind that the purpose of the analysis is to help Wang's sales representatives sell equipment to other nonfinancial people, so the analysis must be as clear as possible, yet technically correct. In other words, the analysis must not only be right, it must also be understandable to decision makers, and the presenter - David, in this case - must be able to answer all questions, ranging from the performance characteristics of the equipment to the assumptions underlying the capital budgeting decision criteria. Required: (A) Identify the relevant cash flows for the project? What is the project's net present value (NPV)? Explain the economic rationale behind the NPV. Could the NPV of this particular project be different for SRC than for one of Wang's other potential customers? Explain. (B) Calculate the proposed project's internal rate of return (IRR). Explain the rationale for using the IRR to evaluate capital investment projects. Could the IRR for this project be different for SRC than for another customer? Explain. (C) Suppose one of SRC executives uses the payback method as a primary capital budgeting decision tool and wants some payback information. a. What is the project's payback period? b. What is the rationale behind the use of payback period as a project evaluation tool? c. What deficiencies does payback have as a capital budgeting decision method? d. Does payback provide any useful information regarding capital budgeting decisions? Although he was hired as a financial analyst after completing his business degree, David Ong's first assignment at Wang Systems was with the firm's marketing department. Historically, the major focus of David's sales effort was on demonstrating the technological superiority of the firm's product line. However, many of Wang's traditional customers have embarked on cost-cutting programs in recent years, and as a result, Wang's marketing director asked David's boss, the Chief Financial Officer, to lend David to marketing to help them develop some analytical procedures for the sales force to use that will demonstrate the financial benefits of buying Wang's products. Page 7 of 8 Wang Systems manufactures fluid control systems that are used in a wide variety of applications, including sewage treatment systems, petroleum refining, and pipeline transmission. The complete systems include sophisticated pumps, sensors, and control units that continuously monitor the flow rate and the pressure along a line, and automatically adjust the pump to meet preset pressure specifications. Most of Wang's systems are made up of standard components, and most complete systems are priced from $50,000 to $100,000. Because of the highly technical nature of the products, the majority of Wang's sales force have backgrounds in engineering. As he began to think about his assignment, David quickly came to the conclusion that the best way to sell a system to a cost-conscious customer would be to conduct a capital budgeting analysis which would demonstrate the system's cost effectiveness. Further, he concluded that the best way to begin was with an analysis for one of Wang's actual customers. From discussions with the firm's sales people, David decided that a proposed sale to Selangor River Council (SRC) was perfect to use as an illustration. SRC is considering the purchase of one of Wang's standard fluid control systems which costs $80,000 including taxes and delivery. It would cost SRC another $5,000 to install the equipment, and this expense would be added to the invoice price of the equipment to determine the depreciable basis of the system. For taxation purposes the system can be depreciated over 6 years, using the following schedule, but has an economic life of 8 years and it will be used for that period. After 8 years, the system will probably be obsolete, so it will have a zero salvage value at that time. Current depreciation allowances are: Year 1: 20% Year 2: 32% Year 3: 19% Year 4: 12% Year 5: 11% Year 6: 6% This system would replace a control system which has been used for about 20 years and which has been fully depreciated. The costs for removing the current system are about equal to its scrap value, so its current net market value is zero. The advantages of the new system are that (1) it would be more energy efficient, (ii) it would reduce waste, because the chemical processes could be more carefully controlled, and (ii) it would require less human monitoring and maintenance. In total, the new system would save SRC $25,000 annually in before-tax operating costs. For capital budgeting, SRC uses a 10% cost of capital, and the applicable tax rate is 40%. Mary Seong, Wang's marketing manager, gave David a free hand in structuring the analysis. Now put yourself in David's position and develop a capital budgeting analysis for the fluid control systems. As you go through the analysis, keep in mind that the purpose of the analysis is to help Wang's sales representatives sell equipment to other nonfinancial people, so the analysis must be as clear as possible, yet technically correct. In other words, the analysis must not only be right, it must also be understandable to decision makers, and the presenter - David, in this case - must be able to answer all questions, ranging from the performance characteristics of the equipment to the assumptions underlying the capital budgeting decision criteria. Required: (A) Identify the relevant cash flows for the project? What is the project's net present value (NPV)? Explain the economic rationale behind the NPV. Could the NPV of this particular project be different for SRC than for one of Wang's other potential customers? Explain. (B) Calculate the proposed project's internal rate of return (IRR). Explain the rationale for using the IRR to evaluate capital investment projects. Could the IRR for this project be different for SRC than for another customer? Explain. (C) Suppose one of SRC executives uses the payback method as a primary capital budgeting decision tool and wants some payback information. a. What is the project's payback period? b. What is the rationale behind the use of payback period as a project evaluation tool? c. What deficiencies does payback have as a capital budgeting decision method? d. Does payback provide any useful information regarding capital budgeting decisions?
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
A Relevant Cash Flows and Net Present Value NPV To perform a capital budgeting analysis we need to identify the relevant cash flows associated with the project These cash flows include initial investm... View the full answer
Related Book For
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
Hyten Corporation On June 5, 1998, a meeting was held at Hyten Corporation, between Bill Knapp, Director of Marketing/Sales, and John Rich, director of engineering. The purpose of the meeting was to...
-
Planning is one of the most important management functions in any business. A front office managers first step in planning should involve determine the departments goals. Planning also includes...
-
Case: Getting it Right at Anns Baking World Concepts to consider in analysis: Human Resource Management | HRM Planning | Diversity | Organization Culture | Recruitment and Selection | Compensation |...
-
Integrate using an appropriate formula For each problem, state the formula number, u and du, identify any constants (if appropriate), and show any constant "adjustments" / "Multiply by 1" if needed....
-
Differences in operating income between variable costing and absorption costing are due solely to accounting for fixed costs. Do you agree? Explain.
-
Using a CAS and Eq. (5), determine the value of to within an error less than 104. -5
-
A 60-g Mars bar will supply you with \(1095 \mathrm{~kJ}\) of energy. How many of them would you need to get enough energy to climb the first \(800 \mathrm{~m}\) of the highest structure in the...
-
Gumchara Corporation reported the following information with respect to the materials required to manufacture amalgam florostats during the current month: Standard price per gram of materials . . . ....
-
A multinational corporation is accused of environmental pollution and human rights violations in a foreign country where it operates. What legal challenges arise in holding the corporation...
-
Sketch vo for each network of Fig. 2.177 for the input shown. Would it be a good approximation to consider the diode to be ideal for both configurations? Why? 120 V Si Si E - 20V
-
Ayayai Corporation had the following stockholders equity accounts on January 1, 2020: Common Stock ($4 par) $400,000, Paid-in Capital in Excess of ParCommon Stock $175,000, and Retained Earnings...
-
Case ID 1 2 1 2 3 3 4 1 1 I 2 3 2 2 4 4 4 4 3 3 3 3 2. Task Label Create Fine Create Fine Send Bill Send Bill Create Fine Send Bill Create Fine Send Bill Process Payment Close Case Send Reminder Send...
-
Using only information from AirTran, Frontier, Ryanair, Southwest and Westjet, please perform a price-earnings multiples valuation and a EBIT Multiples valuation for both trailing and leading for...
-
What are some strategies for building quality into projects? What are some types of documentation that must be maintained for projects? What are the characteristics of good documents?
-
What is the required rate of return of the equity issue? What is the current value of the stock? What type of companies usually experience constant dividend growth and supernormal dividend growth...
-
On March 1, Gescan Electric Inc. issued and sold $312,000, 7 year bonds with an interest rate of 9%. The market rate at the time of issue was 10%. Any premium or discount on the bond is amortized...
-
1. 2. 3. Explain and discuss the different factors affecting the evaporation rate for each method below; a. Energy Balance Method b. Aerodynamic Method C. Combined Method d. Priestly-Taylor Method...
-
A copper wire (density = 8.96 g/cm 3 ) has a diameter of 0.25 mm. If a sample of this copper wire has a mass of 22 g, how long is the wire?
-
Imagine this scenario. A few years after graduating from Boston College, Florida Gulf Coast University, or the University of North Texas with an accounting degree, you find yourself working as an...
-
"Come on, Brian. You don't mean that." "I meant every word of it, Elise. Here, let me repeat it for you: My career will be a total failure if I don't make audit partner. A complete bust, an absolute...
-
Thursday, October 24, 1929, easily ranks as the most dramatic day that Wall Street has ever seen.1 That day witnessed the beginning of the Great Stock Market Crash that over the following few years...
-
A candlestick chart is similar to a bar chart except that the candlestick chart: A. Represents upward movements in price with Xs. B. Also graphically shows the range of the periods highs and lows. C....
-
What considerations might encourage a market analyst to rely more on a top-down or bottom-up forecast of S&P 500 operating earnings?
-
Which of the following criticisms expressed by Ryan about the use of historical data is the least valid? A. In a context of hyperinflation, the approach may not be appropriate. B. The companies...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App