Answer: Then, identify possible Philosophical works that we have read this semester that have addressed a theme
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Answer:
Transcribed Image Text:
Then, identify possible Philosophical works that we have read this semester that have addressed a theme present in the ship of Theseus thought exercise. Some examples might be: identity, self, objects through time; immortality of soul; criteria for knowledge; nature of reality; bundle theory; or others. Next, create a comparison chart to explore how each author develops his/her arguments in support of their respective positions regarding the theme in response to the ship of Theseus. For example, if you choose Plato and Parmenides and the theme is what is really real, then you might: 1. Outline argument of Plato on nature of reality 2. Outline argument of Parmenides on nature of reality 3. According to these authors, analyze and apply these respective approaches to the question: Which is the true ship, and why? 4. Distinguish whether they differ in their interpretations on this issue enough to be significant to discuss in this paper. Decide whether you agree or not and offer your response. As previously mentioned, students can use the chart as a tool; the information then can be used in the essay. Introduction In the first paragraph, identify the titles and authors of the selected philosophy essays and define all philosophical terms you will be using. Also, the opening paragraph must provide a broad, but accurate, synopsis of the Ship of Theseus thought experiment, the two essays, and a clearly defined thesis statement. Body Paragraphs When comparing and/or contrasting two pieces, students should strive for an organization that helps the reader establish relationships among the information. Two common methods for comparing and/or contrasting items in an essay are block format and point by point. Block format allows students to discuss one piece completely before discussing the other piece. The following sample outline provides a general overview of the way in which one could organize the essay with the block method. 1. Introduction 2. Body paragraphs 1. Argument: Piece A (block 1) 1. Evidence element 1 2. Evidence element 2 3. Evidence element 3. 2. Argument: Piece B (block 2) 1. Evidence element 1 2. Evidence element 2 3. Evidence element 3 3. Conclusion The point-by-point method allows the student to move back and forth between two or three arguments being compared and/or contrasted, as in the following sample outline. 1. Introduction 2. piece B 3. Argument element 3 (point 3) 1. piece A 2. piece B 3. Conclusion The key to using these organizational methods is to be consistent in the ideas presented. For example, with the block format, make sure to discuss Argument elements 1, 2, and 3 for Philosophy piece A and then Argument elements 1, 2, and 3 for Philosophy piece B. In point- by-point format, discuss Argument element 1 for both pieces A and B before moving on to element 2. Another important consideration with both organizational methods is to use transitional words and phrases to help the reader understand connections among the ideas. Choose the organizational method that supports the essay s purpose. To give a reader a complete, overall picture of each piece, use the block format. However, to present a number of distinct points from both pieces for the reader to consider individually, use point by point. Regardless of the paper s organization, present a balanced, objective analysis of both pieces. Conclusion The closing paragraph should refer back to the original question posed regarding the Ship of Theseus and the chosen theme for your paper with a concluding phrase addressing your results. For the writer, the conclusion is the final opportunity to make a lasting impression in the reader s mind. Keep in mind that a strong conclusion resonates with the reader. Be certain that you present your own response to this question and conclude with a strong summative remark addressing the fact that you have addressed and proven your thesis. Then, identify possible Philosophical works that we have read this semester that have addressed a theme present in the ship of Theseus thought exercise. Some examples might be: identity, self, objects through time; immortality of soul; criteria for knowledge; nature of reality; bundle theory; or others. Next, create a comparison chart to explore how each author develops his/her arguments in support of their respective positions regarding the theme in response to the ship of Theseus. For example, if you choose Plato and Parmenides and the theme is what is really real, then you might: 1. Outline argument of Plato on nature of reality 2. Outline argument of Parmenides on nature of reality 3. According to these authors, analyze and apply these respective approaches to the question: Which is the true ship, and why? 4. Distinguish whether they differ in their interpretations on this issue enough to be significant to discuss in this paper. Decide whether you agree or not and offer your response. As previously mentioned, students can use the chart as a tool; the information then can be used in the essay. Introduction In the first paragraph, identify the titles and authors of the selected philosophy essays and define all philosophical terms you will be using. Also, the opening paragraph must provide a broad, but accurate, synopsis of the Ship of Theseus thought experiment, the two essays, and a clearly defined thesis statement. Body Paragraphs When comparing and/or contrasting two pieces, students should strive for an organization that helps the reader establish relationships among the information. Two common methods for comparing and/or contrasting items in an essay are block format and point by point. Block format allows students to discuss one piece completely before discussing the other piece. The following sample outline provides a general overview of the way in which one could organize the essay with the block method. 1. Introduction 2. Body paragraphs 1. Argument: Piece A (block 1) 1. Evidence element 1 2. Evidence element 2 3. Evidence element 3. 2. Argument: Piece B (block 2) 1. Evidence element 1 2. Evidence element 2 3. Evidence element 3 3. Conclusion The point-by-point method allows the student to move back and forth between two or three arguments being compared and/or contrasted, as in the following sample outline. 1. Introduction 2. piece B 3. Argument element 3 (point 3) 1. piece A 2. piece B 3. Conclusion The key to using these organizational methods is to be consistent in the ideas presented. For example, with the block format, make sure to discuss Argument elements 1, 2, and 3 for Philosophy piece A and then Argument elements 1, 2, and 3 for Philosophy piece B. In point- by-point format, discuss Argument element 1 for both pieces A and B before moving on to element 2. Another important consideration with both organizational methods is to use transitional words and phrases to help the reader understand connections among the ideas. Choose the organizational method that supports the essay s purpose. To give a reader a complete, overall picture of each piece, use the block format. However, to present a number of distinct points from both pieces for the reader to consider individually, use point by point. Regardless of the paper s organization, present a balanced, objective analysis of both pieces. Conclusion The closing paragraph should refer back to the original question posed regarding the Ship of Theseus and the chosen theme for your paper with a concluding phrase addressing your results. For the writer, the conclusion is the final opportunity to make a lasting impression in the reader s mind. Keep in mind that a strong conclusion resonates with the reader. Be certain that you present your own response to this question and conclude with a strong summative remark addressing the fact that you have addressed and proven your thesis.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Ship of Theseus Thought Exercise The ship of Theseus also known as the Theseus paradox is a thought experiment that asks if a thing that has had every one of its elements changed is still essentially ... View the full answer
Related Book For
A Concise Introduction to Logic
ISBN: 978-1305958098
13th edition
Authors: Patrick J. Hurley, Lori Watson
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these economics questions
-
Answer the questions below. Note that to address some problems that may result in changes in investment in equilibrium, you need to first analyze the effect on the loanable funds market, then...
-
Answer parts ac for each of the following cases. Answer parts ac for each of the following cases. a. Calculate the future value at the end of the specified deposit period. b. Determine the effective...
-
Multiple Choice Questions Select the right answer (only one possible answers unless otherwise stated). 1 Which of the following measurement basis does not exist? (a) Historical cost (b) Decreasing...
-
What is the leading cause of death among people with HIV / AIDS in Africa?
-
After the accountant posted the adjusting entries for M. Wally, Designer, the work sheet contained the following account balances on May 31: Required 1. Write the owners name on the Capital and...
-
What tests are available for determining the convergence and divergence of improper integrals that cannot be evaluated directly? Give examples of their use.
-
Fill in the Blank. A nonperiodic function can be treated as a periodic function having a(n) __________ period.
-
Jay Rexford, president of Photo Artistry Company, was just concluding a budget meeting with his senior staff. It was November of 20x4, and the group was discussing preparation of the firms master...
-
We will be using a Pierce BCA protein assay kit to determine the protein concentration in non-fat dry milk. First, you will be preparing the standard solutions using 2 mg/mL Bovine Serum Albumin...
-
For the rotational system shown in Figure P2.25, write the equations of motion from which the transfer function, G(s) = 1 (s)/T(s), can be found. Figure P2.25 T(t) 0,(1) N J. K D N2 N3 J2 N4 JL. J4...
-
Use the modulus-density chart and find out the following: (a) the material with the highest density (b) the metal with the lowest modulus (c) the polymer with the highest density (d) the approximate...
-
Consider an automobile manufacturing plant where the rate at which the plant uses power-lock mechanisms (an automobile component) is stochastic and normally distributed, with a mean of 192 per day (8...
-
Suppose at the end of a status reporting period, you gather the following metrics: EV = $120, PV = $120, and AC = $120. Applying fundamental EVM analysis, what can you conclude about the schedule...
-
The management team is interested in knowing what potential vulnerabilities exist for my environment. Take this opportunity to review common vulnerabilities specific to my environment and provide the...
-
For New York City weekday late afternoon subway travel from Times Square to the Mets stadium, you can take the #7 train that leaves Times Square every 5 minutes. The waiting time is equally likely to...
-
For financial reporting purposes, Michelotti Co. reported depreciation expense of $12,000 in 2017. In 2018, because of a change in the expected useful life of its equipment, Michelotti reported...
-
A. List the top 3 ethical issues in "Responsibility vs. Profitability at MGM Grand Resorts Intl." ? B. Number these issues in terms of which should be dealt with first : 1 = should be addressed...
-
Kims Konstructions has assembled the following data for a proposed straw-reinforced brick maker (SRBM): SRBM Cost: $26,000 Life: 5 years Revenue (p.a.) $11,000 Operating Expenses (p.a.) $3,000...
-
Dear Ann: Ive read that one aspirin taken every other day will reduce the risk of heart attack. Why not take two and double the protection? Most of the following selections were taken from...
-
Use the eighteen rules of inference to derive the conclusions of the following symbolized arguments. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. N (S-K) RS / 2. K 1. T (Fv F) | ~T
-
For the sorites in Part I above, rewrite each in standard form, reducing the number of terms when necessary. Then use the five rules for sorites to test each for validity. 1. No B are C. Some D are...
-
(a) Among 880 smart phones sold by a retailer, 72 required repairs under the warranty. Estimate the probability that a new phone, which has just been sold, will require repairs under the warranty....
-
A car rental agency has 19 compact cars and 12 intermediate-size cars. If four of the cars are randomly selected for a safety check, what is the probability of getting two of each kind?
-
With reference to Exercise 3.34, suppose that the questionnaire filled in by one of the 150 persons is to be double-checked. If it is chosen in such a way that each questionnaire has a probability of...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App