Are auditors truly independent? An auditing academic was heard to make the following statement: True audit...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Are auditors truly independent? An auditing academic was heard to make the following statement: True audit independence can never be achieved! Auditors operate in a commercial environment and need to work to wvin the audit of a client. The ongoing fees that they receive are then obviously conditional on management's approval. If management is unhappy with the auditor they will find a way to get rid of them – it is as simple as that. Perhaps a solution could be to give the role of appointing auditors to ASIC? They could allocate auditors to the top 300 listed companies and give them a fixed term audit for five years. Then they would reallocate the auditors to those compamies. Auditors would not have to compromise their independence to win the client or keep the client. Summarise the literature on whether auditor independence has improved in light of the recent reforms (e.g. APES110, CLERP 9), then use research evidence to evaluate this academic's proposal – that is, discuss its strengths, weaknesses, and viability supported by research evidence. Are auditors truly independent? An auditing academic was heard to make the following statement: True audit independence can never be achieved! Auditors operate in a commercial environment and need to work to wvin the audit of a client. The ongoing fees that they receive are then obviously conditional on management's approval. If management is unhappy with the auditor they will find a way to get rid of them – it is as simple as that. Perhaps a solution could be to give the role of appointing auditors to ASIC? They could allocate auditors to the top 300 listed companies and give them a fixed term audit for five years. Then they would reallocate the auditors to those compamies. Auditors would not have to compromise their independence to win the client or keep the client. Summarise the literature on whether auditor independence has improved in light of the recent reforms (e.g. APES110, CLERP 9), then use research evidence to evaluate this academic's proposal – that is, discuss its strengths, weaknesses, and viability supported by research evidence.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Answer Audit independence can never be truly ascertained if the role of t... View the full answer
Related Book For
Accounting
ISBN: 978-1118608227
9th edition
Authors: Lew Edwards, John Medlin, Keryn Chalmers, Andreas Hellmann, Claire Beattie, Jodie Maxfield, John Hoggett
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
A business student was heard to make the following remark: With the advent of credit cards and the existence of factor businesses, it now possible for business entities to offer extensive credit...
-
Find the values of a needed to make the following transformation orthogonal. -a a
-
The Pentire Corporation is looking to make the following annual dividend payments over the next four years, commencing one year from today: $10, $14, $7 and $2 respectively. After this time (four...
-
Find the inverse of each of the given matrices by the method of Example 1 of this section. Data from Example 1 Find the inverse of the matrix First, we interchange the elements on the principal...
-
Independent random samples of business and economics faculty were asked to respond on a scale from 1 (strongly disagree) to 4 (strongly agree) to this statement: The threat and actuality of takeovers...
-
Which meal are people most likely to order at a drivethrough? A survey was conducted in 2009, but the sample sizes were not reported. Suppose the results, based on a sample of 100 males and 100...
-
Data 2.7 on page 95 introduces the dataset HollywoodMovies, which contains information on more than 900 movies that came out of Hollywood between 2007 and 2013. We will consider this the population...
-
Net Working Capital In our capital budgeting examples we assumed that a firm would recover all of the working capital it invested in a project. Is this a reasonable assumption? When might it not be...
-
A gas station on a lake sells fuel to boaters. Falling fuel prices throughout the country have decreased the gas station's costs, but over the same period, the lake has become an increasingly popular...
-
You are the Owners project manager on an electrical upgrade project. Existing overhead power lines are being buried in a duct bank to hide them from view in an area of the town that is being...
-
View the standard deduction schedule. Requirement What is her 2023 taxable income? Schedule of Standard Deductions STANDARD DEDUCTION Filing Status Married individuals filing joint returns and...
-
suppose a person who buys only wine and cheese is given $1,000 in food stamps to supplement his $1,000 income. The food stamps cannot be used to buy wine. Might the consumer be better off with $2,000...
-
Accounts balances as of August 3 1 , 2 0 xx for Hurricane Supplies are listed in alphabetically order. Using the "ALORE classification simplified" document in Canvas, created an income statement and...
-
Suppose your firm is choosing between two new product lines. One project has an initial investment of $450 million and offers annual cashflows of $160 million for 5 years. The other has an initial...
-
1.Reconsider the example above, where you are contemplating the purchase of the coupon bond with a face value of $1,000, which matures in 14 years, and pays 3.15% (annual) coupons. Now, If you...
-
Nov 4 Purchased $5,900 of merchandise on account from Tire Warehouse. Terms, 3/15, n/45, FOB shipping point. Tire Warehouse prepaid the $50 shipping cost and added the amount to the invoice. 7...
-
Question 8 The actual sales and forecast sales for Year 1 are 46 and 26 respectively. What is its forecast error? (Enter a whole number please). Question 9 80 F3 999 200 MacBook Air F6 0.6 pts F7 0.6...
-
During the month, services performed for customers on account amounted to $7,500 and collections from customers in payment of their accounts totaled $6,000. At the end of the month, the Accounts...
-
Tom Shanks, production manager for Innovative Products Ltd, had just finished his annual performance appraisal with the managing director, May Martin. May had indicated that, although Toms...
-
Jill owns and operates a business that makes hand-crafted rocking chairs. The business is expanding but the increasing costs of raw materials and labour, and the GST, have badly affected...
-
An inventory purchase on credit of $10 000 plus GST was correctly recorded in the purchases journal of a business. However, when postings were made to the accounts payable in the subsidiary ledger,...
-
Explain how the financial manager might use industry norms in the design of the companys financing mix.
-
You have developed the following income statement for Sing-Tel Corporation. It represents the most recent years operations, which ended yesterday. Your supervisor in the controllers office has just...
-
Financial data for three corporations are displayed here. MEASURE FIRM FIRM FIRM INDUSTRY A B C NORM Debt ratio 21% 24% 39% 21% Times interest 7.5 10.2 7.0 9.1 times earned times times times...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App