Former manager awarded over RM800,000 by Industrial Court for unfair dismissal by MDEC Malay Mail, 5...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Former manager awarded over RM800,000 by Industrial Court for unfair dismissal by MDEC Malay Mail, 5 February 2021 KUALA LUMPUR, Feb 5 A former manager for the government agency Malaysia Digital Economy Corporation (MDEC) was awarded over RM800,000 yesterday after the Industrial Court found the company guilty of unfair dismissal, after nearly two years of court proceedings. In the case document sighted by Malay Mail the claimant Thomas Kuruvilla, who worked at MDEC from September 2007 to May 2018, was awarded approximately RM 810,628, to be paid within 30 days of the award date. Kuruvilla was represented by lawyer T. M. Varughese, while MDEC was represented by lawyers Shariffullah Majeed and Amardeep Singh Toor. Industrial Court chairman Augustine Anthony presided over the case. MDEC, an agency established in 1996 and now under the Communications and Multimedia Ministry, was formed to implement the Multimedia Super Corridor initiative and to lead the growth of information and communications technology as well as the digital economy in the country. During the course of the trial, which began on February 28, 2019, MDEC argued that Kuruvilla's work performance began to degrade from 2015 onwards, which forced it to place him under several performance improvement plans (PIP) which lasted until 2017. Despite guidance given to the claimant to achieve his job scope and key performance indicators, MDEC eventually rated the ex-manager's performance as unacceptable with failure to make the necessary improvements, leading to his dismissal in May 2018. On his part, Kuruvilla argued that when he began working in the company in September 2007 in a senior managerial role, no unsatisfactory issues relating to his performance were reported for the first seven years. He claimed that when a new chief executive officer took over the helm in September 2014, he was subsequently transferred o another department in April, 2015. The then-new CEO who began heading MDEC in September 2014 is Datuk Yasmin Mahmood, formerly the managing director of Microsoft Malaysia and general manager of HP and Dell. She served for over four years before resigning from the post in January 2019. Kuruvilla claimed that he was not a poor performer and should have never been placed under the PIPS, adding that in the new department he was given multiple objectives unrelated to his job scope, made subordinate to several other different managers, given limited or no guidance at all, and at times placed under humiliating circumstances. In Kuruvilla's argument, this was an attempt by the company to terminate him as an employee, and that in doing so they engaged in unfair labour practices by victimising and then dismissing him, a decision which he said was tainted with bad faith and done without just cause or excuse. Following the court proceedings over the course of 23 months, with numerous similar unfair employment dismissal cases from 1981 to 2019 cited throughout, the Industrial Court determined that Kuruvilla was indeed not given enough time to accomplish the tasks assigned to him, nor was he accorded sufficient opportunity improve, and was not given adequate guidance and assistance during his PIPs. It also determined that Kuruvilla's frequent transfers in a short period of less than four years after his September 2014 transfer to another department, and his placement under various performance managers is clear evidence of MDEC putting him under extreme pressure and creating impediments and frustration to his work performance. As such the company's cumulative conduct was deemed not to be in aid of bettering Kuruvilla's performance, but instead driven to cause its deterioration instead. To this it ruled that MDEC failed to prove on the balance of probabilities that his dismissal from employment was done with just cause or excuse. Kuruvilla's awarded sum includes 24 months of back wages totalling RM572,208, and compensation in lieu of reinstatement for 10 months totalling RM238,420. Question 1 Based on the above case, describe FIVE (5) actions by the management (employer) in an organisation that may lead a workman to consider himself unfairly dismissed. (50 marks) Question 2 MDEC could have prevented Thomas Kuruvilla's unfair dismissal claim as referred to the Industrial Court. Discuss FIVE (5) management (organisational) strategies that could be employed to prevent unfair dismissal claims by workmen. --- End of Assignment 2 Questions --- (50 marks) SMESN Former manager awarded over RM800,000 by Industrial Court for unfair dismissal by MDEC Malay Mail, 5 February 2021 KUALA LUMPUR, Feb 5 A former manager for the government agency Malaysia Digital Economy Corporation (MDEC) was awarded over RM800,000 yesterday after the Industrial Court found the company guilty of unfair dismissal, after nearly two years of court proceedings. In the case document sighted by Malay Mail the claimant Thomas Kuruvilla, who worked at MDEC from September 2007 to May 2018, was awarded approximately RM 810,628, to be paid within 30 days of the award date. Kuruvilla was represented by lawyer T. M. Varughese, while MDEC was represented by lawyers Shariffullah Majeed and Amardeep Singh Toor. Industrial Court chairman Augustine Anthony presided over the case. MDEC, an agency established in 1996 and now under the Communications and Multimedia Ministry, was formed to implement the Multimedia Super Corridor initiative and to lead the growth of information and communications technology as well as the digital economy in the country. During the course of the trial, which began on February 28, 2019, MDEC argued that Kuruvilla's work performance began to degrade from 2015 onwards, which forced it to place him under several performance improvement plans (PIP) which lasted until 2017. Despite guidance given to the claimant to achieve his job scope and key performance indicators, MDEC eventually rated the ex-manager's performance as unacceptable with failure to make the necessary improvements, leading to his dismissal in May 2018. On his part, Kuruvilla argued that when he began working in the company in September 2007 in a senior managerial role, no unsatisfactory issues relating to his performance were reported for the first seven years. He claimed that when a new chief executive officer took over the helm in September 2014, he was subsequently transferred o another department in April, 2015. The then-new CEO who began heading MDEC in September 2014 is Datuk Yasmin Mahmood, formerly the managing director of Microsoft Malaysia and general manager of HP and Dell. She served for over four years before resigning from the post in January 2019. Kuruvilla claimed that he was not a poor performer and should have never been placed under the PIPS, adding that in the new department he was given multiple objectives unrelated to his job scope, made subordinate to several other different managers, given limited or no guidance at all, and at times placed under humiliating circumstances. In Kuruvilla's argument, this was an attempt by the company to terminate him as an employee, and that in doing so they engaged in unfair labour practices by victimising and then dismissing him, a decision which he said was tainted with bad faith and done without just cause or excuse. Following the court proceedings over the course of 23 months, with numerous similar unfair employment dismissal cases from 1981 to 2019 cited throughout, the Industrial Court determined that Kuruvilla was indeed not given enough time to accomplish the tasks assigned to him, nor was he accorded sufficient opportunity improve, and was not given adequate guidance and assistance during his PIPs. It also determined that Kuruvilla's frequent transfers in a short period of less than four years after his September 2014 transfer to another department, and his placement under various performance managers is clear evidence of MDEC putting him under extreme pressure and creating impediments and frustration to his work performance. As such the company's cumulative conduct was deemed not to be in aid of bettering Kuruvilla's performance, but instead driven to cause its deterioration instead. To this it ruled that MDEC failed to prove on the balance of probabilities that his dismissal from employment was done with just cause or excuse. Kuruvilla's awarded sum includes 24 months of back wages totalling RM572,208, and compensation in lieu of reinstatement for 10 months totalling RM238,420. Question 1 Based on the above case, describe FIVE (5) actions by the management (employer) in an organisation that may lead a workman to consider himself unfairly dismissed. (50 marks) Question 2 MDEC could have prevented Thomas Kuruvilla's unfair dismissal claim as referred to the Industrial Court. Discuss FIVE (5) management (organisational) strategies that could be employed to prevent unfair dismissal claims by workmen. --- End of Assignment 2 Questions --- (50 marks) SMESN
Expert Answer:
Related Book For
Principles of Information Systems
ISBN: 978-1133629665
11th edition
Authors: Ralph Stair, George Reynolds
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these finance questions
-
You have been hired as a project manager to develop a new Web site in the next six months for a store that sells music and books online. Describe how project management tools, such as a Gantt chart...
-
As a project manager of a manufacturing firm, you are tasked with determining the total cost for the specific tasks or phases of a larger project. As an example, let's assume you are responsible for...
-
As a project manager of a new team that's developing an online shopping site for a traditional department store, you have been asked to calculate how much your team will spend on user testing in the...
-
The functions in Exercises 1128 are all one-to-one. For each function, a. Find an equation for f -1 (x), the inverse function. b. Verify that your equation is correct by showing that f( f -1 (x)) = x...
-
Heather, a head of household, received a salary of $198,000 in 2013. She also had following additional types of income: $20,000 net long-term capital gain from the sale of stock, $4,000 dividend...
-
A 3.00-g lead bullet at 30.0C is fired at a speed of 240 m/s into a large block of ice at 0C, in which it becomes embedded. What quantity of ice melts?
-
The price of a non-dividend paying stock is \($19\) and the price of a three-month European call option on the stock with a strike price of \($20\) is \($1.\) The risk-free rate is 4% per annum. What...
-
On June 1, Beardsley Service Co. was started with an initial investment in the company of $22,100 cash. Here are the assets and liabilities of the company at June 30, and the revenues and expenses...
-
Consider the closed system with mass-action rate constants as shown. Suppose the rate constants are (in min-1) k = 0.05, kg = 0.7, k2= 0.005, and k4 = 0.4. ki k3 A B C k2 ka (a) Construct a...
-
This case can be assigned as a group activity. Additional instructions and material for this activity can be found on the Instructor Resource site and in WileyPLUS. Kenmare Architects Ltd. (KAL) was...
-
What is the yield for a 47-day Treasury Note with a face value of $800,000 and a price of $786,334? Express your answer as a percentage - not as a decimal. eg Use 6.45, not 0.0645 and to 2 decimal...
-
Visit a local building site and ascertain the number and type of subcontracts that are involved. How many subcontracts do you think may be needed for a downtown high-rise building? Why would there be...
-
What should be done to avoid a repetition of the real estate buddle of the early to mid-2000s, which caused a recession? Support your analysis with pertinent facts.
-
What will be the impact on double-breasted operations and the right-to-work provision of the TaftHartley legislation if labor is able to revoke existing practices regarding common sites picketing?
-
Visit a local contractor and determine the proportion of contracts that are negotiated against those that are competitively bid awards. Is this percentage likely to change significantly with small...
-
What is the present level of the prime rate? How does this rate relate to the current financing and overdraft charges for new building construction in your locality? (How many points above the prime...
-
Kayley is a professional fidget spinner at the local county fair. She is paid $20.00 per hour for her amazing fidget spinning skills. Her employer, Farm Fun Fairs pays her weekly using the 2020...
-
Using Gauss-Jordan elimination, invert this matrix ONLY 0 0 0 0 1
-
How have software development kits (SDKs) influenced software development?
-
Using the Internet, explore the most useful mobile applications for a business or industry of your choice. Also explore mobile applications for this business or industry that are not currently...
-
What is a solid state storage device?
-
What can a multinational firm do to reduce the level of stress that expatriates may feel as a result of real or perceived terrorist threats? Explain. One of the concomitants of international...
-
Form an even number of teams of five members each, with one pro team and one con team working for the same university. The pro team is asked to defend the advantage of opening a branch campus, while...
-
Research some recent articles dealing with the recent push by U.S. universities to start training foreign students abroad. Based on what you have read, what would you conclude in terms of the...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App