As you read the two case scenarios below, consider the decisions made by Johniny and Mary...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
As you read the two case scenarios below, consider the decisions made by Johniny and Mary Jo and the resulting outcomes. What influences their decision-making? What sandions, if any, should Johnny or Mary Jo face? Assuming that both protagonists wanted to act ethically, what could they have done differently? Would that change the outcomes? If no, how? Professional Scenario Johnny, a certified public accountant (CPA) who is acting as the in-charge/senior on the audit engagement, works on the ABC Company audit, an existing firm client. 1 Johnny works hard to complete this engagement along with his other engagements during the Spring busy season. The following Fall, the Public Company Accounting Ovensight Board (PCAOB) notifies the fim of the inspection visit timing, scheduled in a litte over two weeks, and the selection of ABC Company's work papers. Knowing that the PCAOB would be arriving soon to examine tha ABC Company audit work papers, the manager and the partner review the work papers and refresh themselves on the details of the engagement. Johnny recelves an email from the document. Johnny exchanges emails with the corporate controllor and arranges to have the letter delivered prior to 8:30 a.m. on the day of the inspectors arival, The letter is Inserted into the hard copy documents on Monday moming without documenting the true date of insertion or the reason why it is added. Johnny takes the completed, revised work papers and delivers them to the PCAOB inspectors when they arive. Student Scenaria Mary Jo and Samantha discuss an exam for their hardest class this semester, Accounting 355. As they leave Tuesday's locture, Mary Jo complains to her friend, Samantha, that she did not want to fail the exam but she felt too tired to study anymore as this was her third exam this week. Samantha asks Mary Jo if she wants the test bank to study, Samantha proclaims that she has eamed almost all As since she starled using the tnst banks as study aids. Knowing that she is running out of time prior to the exam date and that the exam grade will significantly impact her final grade for the course, Mary lo downloads the test bank for the textbook from the wobsite Samantha give her and uses it as a study aid. The test bank's Cover page clearty states that the document is only for "instructor use" and contains a copyright notice at the bottom of each page On the exam, the instructor requires students to sign a certification that they are aware of the academic integrity code of their institution and the acadenic integrity polices set forth on the syllabus Also, they must certify that they have rno knowledge of violations of either the code or the alass policy by themselves or other students. Mary Ja signs the certifications and does very well on the test DISCUSSION QUESTIONS Apply the following ethical framework to eech scenario: 1. What standards and principles of ethics did Johnny and Mary Jo violate? Shoukd Johnny be sanctioned by the firm or the PCAOB? If so, how? Should Mary Jo be sanctioned by the university office responsible for ensuring academic integrity? If so, how? 2. Who are the main stakeholders in each situation aside from Johnny and Mary Jo? How might each of these stakeholders be affected by Johnny's and Mary s choices, respectively? 3. How might Johnny and Mary Jo rationalize their behavior as acceptable? 4. What altemative actions would you recommend for Johnny and Mary Jo? 5. Johnny and Mary Jo both failed to speak up when confronted with their ethical dilemmas. What factors contributed to their silence? Assume that they wanted to act ethically. How could they have given voice to their concerms? As you read the two case scenarios below, consider the decisions made by Johniny and Mary Jo and the resulting outcomes. What influences their decision-making? What sandions, if any, should Johnny or Mary Jo face? Assuming that both protagonists wanted to act ethically, what could they have done differently? Would that change the outcomes? If no, how? Professional Scenario Johnny, a certified public accountant (CPA) who is acting as the in-charge/senior on the audit engagement, works on the ABC Company audit, an existing firm client. 1 Johnny works hard to complete this engagement along with his other engagements during the Spring busy season. The following Fall, the Public Company Accounting Ovensight Board (PCAOB) notifies the fim of the inspection visit timing, scheduled in a litte over two weeks, and the selection of ABC Company's work papers. Knowing that the PCAOB would be arriving soon to examine tha ABC Company audit work papers, the manager and the partner review the work papers and refresh themselves on the details of the engagement. Johnny recelves an email from the document. Johnny exchanges emails with the corporate controllor and arranges to have the letter delivered prior to 8:30 a.m. on the day of the inspectors arival, The letter is Inserted into the hard copy documents on Monday moming without documenting the true date of insertion or the reason why it is added. Johnny takes the completed, revised work papers and delivers them to the PCAOB inspectors when they arive. Student Scenaria Mary Jo and Samantha discuss an exam for their hardest class this semester, Accounting 355. As they leave Tuesday's locture, Mary Jo complains to her friend, Samantha, that she did not want to fail the exam but she felt too tired to study anymore as this was her third exam this week. Samantha asks Mary Jo if she wants the test bank to study, Samantha proclaims that she has eamed almost all As since she starled using the tnst banks as study aids. Knowing that she is running out of time prior to the exam date and that the exam grade will significantly impact her final grade for the course, Mary lo downloads the test bank for the textbook from the wobsite Samantha give her and uses it as a study aid. The test bank's Cover page clearty states that the document is only for "instructor use" and contains a copyright notice at the bottom of each page On the exam, the instructor requires students to sign a certification that they are aware of the academic integrity code of their institution and the acadenic integrity polices set forth on the syllabus Also, they must certify that they have rno knowledge of violations of either the code or the alass policy by themselves or other students. Mary Ja signs the certifications and does very well on the test DISCUSSION QUESTIONS Apply the following ethical framework to eech scenario: 1. What standards and principles of ethics did Johnny and Mary Jo violate? Shoukd Johnny be sanctioned by the firm or the PCAOB? If so, how? Should Mary Jo be sanctioned by the university office responsible for ensuring academic integrity? If so, how? 2. Who are the main stakeholders in each situation aside from Johnny and Mary Jo? How might each of these stakeholders be affected by Johnny's and Mary s choices, respectively? 3. How might Johnny and Mary Jo rationalize their behavior as acceptable? 4. What altemative actions would you recommend for Johnny and Mary Jo? 5. Johnny and Mary Jo both failed to speak up when confronted with their ethical dilemmas. What factors contributed to their silence? Assume that they wanted to act ethically. How could they have given voice to their concerms?
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
1 The standards and principles of ethics that Johnny and Mary Jo violated were honesty integrity and ... View the full answer
Related Book For
Money Banking and Financial Markets
ISBN: 978-0078021749
4th edition
Authors: Stephen Cecchetti, Kermit Schoenholtz
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
Two unrelated taxpayers consulted Andrew, a certified public accountant and active member of the AICPA, in regards to the depreciation method to be utilized in accordance with a particular...
-
A Certified Public Accountant CPA for a nonprofit agency is responsible for the investment strategy of the agencies funds to ensure a successful flow of revenue to support their business activity The...
-
Case study Chicken Run Encik Selamat, a Certified Public Accountant (CPA), had been the General Manager of Excel Poultry & Meat Sdn Bhd (EPM), a subsidiary of PCK Holding, since 2005. The set up...
-
Using the information for Sarot, Inc., in SE 4 and SE 5, compute the current ratio, quick ratio, receivable turnover, days sales uncollected, inventory turnover, days inventory on hand, payables...
-
Suppose you plan to draw all possible samples of size 64 from a large population with a mean () of 2500 and a standard deviation () of 32. You then will compute the mean (x-bar) for each sample. a....
-
Four factors are thought to possibly influence the taste of a soft-drink beverage: type of sweetener (A), ratio of syrup to water (B), carbonation level (C), and temperature (D). Each factor can be...
-
What is the major difference between a sample and a census?
-
In Mordica Company, total materials costs are $33,000, and total conversion costs are $54,000. Equivalent units of production are materials 10,000 and conversion costs 12,000. Compute the unit costs...
-
How do cultural beliefs, values, and traditions contribute to the resilience of communities facing systemic challenges, and how can culturally sensitive approaches enhance resilience-building efforts...
-
Mr. M has been employed as an engineer by A Ltd., a company incorporated in Hong Kong. During the year ended 31 March 2019, Mr. M had the following income and expenditure. A monthly salary of...
-
The following defined pension data of Carla Vista Corp. apply to the year 2025. Projected benefit obligation, 1/1/25 (before amendment) $582,000 Plan assets, 1/1/25 566,900 Pension liability, 1/1/25...
-
Explain, intuitively, the concept of the mean, or expected value, of a random variable.
-
Use the \(F\)-test to test single null hypotheses or joint null hypotheses.
-
Explain the term "random sampling."
-
A venture capital company feels that the rate of return \((X)\) on a proposed investment is approximately normally distributed with a mean of \(40 \%\) and a standard deviation of \(10 \%\). a. Find...
-
Test hypotheses about single coefficients and about linear combinations of coefficients in a multiple regression model. In particular, a. What is the difference between a one-tail and a two-tail...
-
1 points QUESTION 6 1. You wish to accumulate 1,000,000 SAR by depositing 5,000 SAR per month into a savings account that earns 3.75% compounded monthly. How many months will it take? 156 154 153 152
-
Suppose that the laptop of Prob. 2.16 is placed in an insulating briefcase with a fully charged battery, but it does not go into sleep mode, and the battery discharges as if the laptop were in use....
-
When banks failed in the 1929-1933 period, the lack of deposit insurance meant that depositors experienced sizable losses. How big were these losses? For September 1929 through February 1933, plot...
-
Consider a small company run by a manager who is also the owner. If this company borrows funds, why might a moral hazard problem still exist?
-
Suppose that the yield curve shows that the one-year bond yield is 3 percent, the two-year yield is 4 percent, and the three-year yield is 5 percent. Assume that the risk premium on the one-year bond...
-
When randomly selecting a day of the week, it is certain that you will select a day containing the letter y, so P(y) = 1. For Exercises 510, decide whether the statement makes sense (or is clearly...
-
If there is a 0.9 probability that it will rain sometime today, then there is a probability of 0.1 that it will not rain sometime today. For Exercises 510, decide whether the statement makes sense...
-
What do we mean when we say that the probability of getting 20 babies of the same gender when 20 random babies are born is 1/524,288? Is such an event unusual? Why or why not?
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App