Question: Assignment Question Read the case notes below and consider the information shown in the appendix. Use this information to determine the likely consequences of the

Assignment Question

Read the case notes below and consider the information shown in the appendix.

Use this information to determine the likely consequences of the introduction of a profit sharing scheme.

Then write a report for the Directors of PK Mart which addresses this issue and makes appropriate recommendations.

Profit Sharing

You have recently been appointed as an analyst within a large retail organisation (PK Mart) that employs approximately 10,000 individuals. PK Mart is a non-specialist retailer selling items such as clothing, electricals and furniture.

The Directors of PK Mart are considering whether the company should introduce a profit sharing scheme for all of its employees. To help with this important decision the Directors want to determine the possible benefits associated with such a scheme.

You have therefore been asked to undertake some quantitative analysis looking at this issue. While you are familiar with various different aspects of statistics and a number of statistical packages you have not undertaken a project of this nature before. Hence you start by conducting a literature search.

This search proves beneficial and you find that there are a number of existing studies which look at the impact of profit sharing, although none specifically in a retail context.

In terms of theoretical work two principle arguments have been put forward to suggest that profit sharing may have positive effects. The first of these postulates that introduction of such a scheme will improve employee satisfaction and organisational commitment. The second that there will be greater alignment of employee and employer interests if such a scheme is introduced. In both cases there is also the suggestion that individual productivity is likely to increase. In contrast, empirical work has tended to focus on the impact which the introduction of a profit sharing scheme is likely to have upon the performance of the company concerned.

In this context various measures of company performance have been used including return on capital employed, value added and shareholder wealth. All such studies also contain 'control variables' which are likely to impact on company performance. The most frequently used of these are firm size and market power. In addition, many studies have attempted to control for the industry in which the firms are located.

From the material you have identified you draw up a list of variables which can be used to identify the impact, if any, of the introduction of a profit sharing scheme. You then obtain numerical data on each of these variables (details of the data can be found in Appendix I).

You now need to consider how you will analyse this information. In addition you need to consider how you will explain the approach(es) you have adopted and the implications of your analysis given that the Directors of PK Mart are not experts in quantitative or statistical methods.

Appendix I

The data related to this assignment, in total there are 280 observations. The first 6 observations are shown below. All data is annual.

Variable definitions:

Roce: Return on capital employed, percent.

Prod: Productivity, output per employee averaged across the firm.

Commit: Employee commitment, 3 point scale averaged across the firm.

Scheme: 1 if company has a profit sharing scheme, 0 otherwise.

Assets: Book value of firm assets, m. Measure of firm size.

Power: Market power, proxied by market share (percent).

Industry: Sector in which company operates:

1 if primary,

2 if manufacturing,

3 if services

Roce Prod Commit Scheme Assets Power Industry
16.8 3.62 2.05 1 8782 18 3
22.4 7.42 2.56 1 7795 14 3
-3.5 1.56 1.71 1 12805 15 2
16.8 4.34 1.79 1 7071 12 1
16.1 4.62 1.93 1 13840 14 3
26.6 6.7 2.06 1 4884 21 3
9.8 2.94 2.19 1 6035 21 2
21.7 7.58 2.08 1 13961 16 3
23.1 7.5 2 1 10967 9 3
18.2 7.86 2.09 1 8574 13 2
28.7 8.45 2.64 1 5996 15 3
18.9 6.87 2.22 1 1792 13 3
17.5 5.42 2.41 1 48 17 3
16.1 4.25 1.92 1 5207 15 3
15.4 5.19 2.03 1 3557 17 3
26.6 8.72 2.05 1 4440 18 3
-4.2 1.37 1.71 1 2805 10 2
25.9 8.7 2.33 1 5538 12 3
11.9 4.21 2.04 1 8125 10 2
6.3 2.13 2.06 0 14006 17 3
11.2 4.49 2.41 1 6051 13 2
9.1 2.8 1.71 1 14977 18 3
6.3 2.59 2.15 1 7698 13 2
6.3 2.74 2.02 0 8683 10 3
17.5 5.4 1.95 1 4036 17 2
23.8 6.26 2.12 1 10910 15 3
8.4 2.3 1.84 0 5906 11 2
26.6 10.1 2.49 1 13216 15 3
11.9 3.45 2.29 0 2356 19 2
14.7 4.83 2.21 0 7750 17 2
10.5 4.14 2.09 1 4855 11 3
12.6 4.34 2.22 0 6874 10 2
11.9 3.29 1.76 1 15596 15 3
16.8 3.52 1.84 0 12446 16 2
14.7 4.92 2.32 1 4205 10 3
23.1 8.71 2.48 1 1213 20 2
6.3 1.98 2.14 1 1929 16 2
14 3.98 2.04 1 6831 14 3
24.5 7.86 2.15 1 13248 16 3
20.3 10.76 2.28 1 7034 11 3
21 6.24 2.05 1 7038 14 3
2.1 2.36 1.73 0 762 13 3
22.4 9.19 2.2 1 4237 16 3
21.7 10.85 2.32 1 7456 16 3
9.1 2.19 2 1 11399 15 3
12.6 3.31 1.96 0 9717 18 3
24.5 8.89 2.45 1 6569 14 2
18.2 8.89 2.63 1 3726 17 2
25.2 7.08 2.45 1 9038 18 3
9.8 2.95 2.15 0 6699 12 3
11.2 3.82 1.79 0 13444 15 2
22.4 7.95 2.45 1 5402 12 2
14 3.99 2.32 1 6979 16 2
19.6 5.93 2.17 1 8632 16 3
25.2 7.43 2.11 1 14916 14 3
21 6.73 2.34 0 10463 15 3
15.4 5.22 2.14 1 6035 10 3
18.2 10.22 2.42 1 13678 13 3
30.1 8.76 2.33 0 4143 11 3
22.4 8.2 2.41 1 9347 13 3
15.4 5.07 2.09 0 6963 16 3
18.2 10.58 2.3 1 3998 17 3
17.5 5.34 2.15 1 9427 16 3
11.9 4.58 1.71 1 2736 15 3
18.2 8.79 2.49 1 3581 16 3
-4.2 1.48 2.01 0 1227 18 2
21.7 6.36 2.03 1 7322 20 2
19.6 5.66 2.12 1 7057 13 3
18.2 7.92 2.41 1 11673 16 3
23.8 9.5 2.68 1 7526 15 3
6.3 2.7 1.65 1 6153 15 3
15.4 5.05 2.09 1 9568 19 3
24.5 10.37 2.09 1 6579 12 3
11.9 3.21 2 1 1776 16 3
20.3 10.58 2.32 1 10930 20 3
16.1 5.31 2.04 1 6838 13 1
13.3 3.55 1.93 1 6920 17 2
23.8 8.5 2.08 1 12160 10 3
11.2 4.58 2.4 0 3260 16 2
37.8 14.4 2.81 1 4348 18 2
18.2 5.46 2 0 12012 14 1
18.2 5.54 1.89 1 8330 13 3
10.5 4.76 2.22 1 9524 9 3
-1.4 1.51 1.98 0 6318 17 3
24.5 6.2 2.4 0 7156 14 3
11.9 3.63 2.23 0 8224 13 3
11.9 3.72 2.4 1 2515 13 2
30.8 12.19 2.44 1 11452 21 1
28 10.86 2.7 1 9356 12 2
11.2 4.5 1.95 0 5870 17 2
24.5 7.74 1.87 1 12590 15 3
9.8 2.94 1.85 0 8945 15 3
25.9 9.06 2.07 1 16357 19 3
23.1 9.23 2.19 1 12357 16 2
13.3 3.66 2.33 1 3298 19 3
7 1.85 1.58 0 2880 11 3
16.1 3.29 2.19 0 3808 16 3
-2.8 1.56 1.67 0 11362 14 2
12.6 4.11 1.68 1 3753 16 3
9.8 2.91 2.03 1 9990 13 2
13.3 3.86 2.08 0 2636 15 3
2.8 2.04 1.78 1 4152 14 2
22.4 6.55 2.56 0 8424 22 2
24.5 6.4 2.34 1 7728 19 3
0.7 1.55 2.01 0 4145 14 3
8.4 2.07 1.98 0 1179 14 3
16.1 3.8 2.18 0 15200 17 2
19.6 6.04 2 1 7733 13 1
12.6 4.16 2.16 1 5981 18 3
18.2 8.7 2.22 1 13979 11 3
14.7 4.86 1.71 1 11062 20 2
20.3 6.15 2.22 0 4273 12 3
12.6 4.22 2.26 1 737 16 2
21 6.65 2.37 1 4380 16 3
0.7 1.02 1.63 0 4605 20 3
3.5 2.01 1.64 0 9424 19 3
11.2 3.39 1.89 0 9813 16 2
16.1 5.34 2.36 1 8842 15 3
11.2 4.21 2.23 1 173 13 3
14.7 4.31 2.22 1 7100 12 3
24.5 7.74 2.43 0 14710 13 3
2.8 1.98 2.07 1 4595 13 3
10.5 3.1 2.03 1 8676 15 2
2.1 2.36 1.85 1 12108 15 3
7 1.8 1.82 1 4103 14 3
11.9 3.21 2.46 0 7512 14 3
23.1 7.1 2.18 1 7136 14 3
21 6.98 2.58 1 8348 15 2
24.5 8.33 2.25 1 5364 16 2
2.8 2.18 2.38 0 2491 16 3
8.4 1.98 2.04 0 6549 17 3
2.8 2.14 1.62 0 2739 11 2
30.8 12.21 2.72 1 4386 16 3
18.9 7.1 2.28 1 3470 16 3
4.9 2.41 2 1 6384 14 2
9.8 2.91 1.74 0 4154 14 2
28 6.47 2.37 1 8150 19 3
8.4 2.63 1.87 0 4208 13 3
18.2 7.96 2.67 1 3396 14 2
15.4 5.2 2.33 1 971 12 3
14.7 3.43 2.11 0 275 17 2
21 6.44 2.3 1 6045 16 3
11.9 3.75 1.97 1 15234 11 2
14 3.93 2.05 1 5903 19 2
30.8 9.26 2.5 1 14078 16 2
21.7 9.03 2.54 1 10248 10 3
16.8 3.64 2.03 0 12054 12 2
18.2 5.54 2 1 12522 11 2
22.4 6.42 2.13 1 2865 18 1
13.3 3.89 1.87 1 1982 17 3
0 1.01 1.87 0 863 14 2
4.2 2.65 2.27 0 9152 16 2
17.5 5.46 2.12 1 1910 16 3
14.7 3.82 2.08 0 6149 15 3
11.9 4.48 2.22 0 13024 16 3
19.6 5.8 2.46 0 9776 12 2
11.2 4.12 2.07 0 2929 18 3
14 4.63 2.28 0 5485 16 3
8.4 2.29 1.75 1 4541 17 2
14.7 4.08 2.22 0 6619 20 3
10.5 3.19 1.86 1 3279 12 3
3.5 2.13 1.96 0 3799 12 1
18.2 5.5 2.23 1 6754 16 3
20.3 7.26 2.19 1 8254 10 3
4.9 2.3 1.69 0 3266 21 3
11.2 4.43 2.01 1 8476 9 2
20.3 9.67 2.48 1 12992 12 2
15.4 5.08 2.24 1 2690 13 3
16.1 4.1 1.96 0 1427 13 1
18.9 7.25 2.42 1 7971 13 3
18.9 10.47 2.3 1 11269 14 2
28.7 6.21 2.2 0 11830 15 2
19.6 5.75 2.59 1 3311 15 3
16.1 3.35 2.13 1 4140 11 2
16.8 3.31 2.35 1 26 15 2
14.7 3.31 1.94 1 12199 16 3
23.8 9.55 2.25 1 2186 7 3
6.3 2.72 1.75 1 16012 21 3
19.6 5.79 2.5 1 8831 14 3
12.6 4.51 2.38 1 11880 14 3
22.4 8.82 2.53 1 10801 13 1
37.8 13.34 2.55 1 14906 18 3
9.8 3.03 1.77 0 4526 13 2
10.5 4.61 2.32 0 1504 14 3
15.4 5.1 1.89 1 8307 15 3
11.2 3.71 1.84 0 11707 11 3
13.3 3.73 2.06 0 8484 11 3
7.7 2.32 2.43 1 348 12 2
8.4 2.55 1.63 0 6835 12 3
28 10.26 2.02 1 7850 15 3
19.6 5.62 2.09 1 9969 21 3
31.5 12.6 2.48 1 11465 13 3
11.2 3.59 2.19 0 4375 12 2
12.6 4.25 2.05 1 10364 19 3
7 1.79 2.21 1 16747 9 3
17.5 5.41 2.2 0 14281 16 2
13.3 4.36 2.23 1 4801 17 3
16.1 4.34 1.88 1 7016 13 3
8.4 2.5 1.75 0 2572 16 3
15.4 5.12 2.04 1 3842 10 3
6.3 2.71 1.97 0 6068 15 1
12.6 4.29 2.07 1 9530 13 2
21 8.04 2.48 1 3650 17 3
21 6.76 2.11 1 3904 11 1
10.5 3.5 2.07 1 4248 13 2
14 3.95 2.05 0 5145 14 3
4.9 1.93 1.97 0 4066 16 3
23.1 9.18 2.38 0 4092 10 3
21.7 7.5 1.91 1 8150 13 3
10.5 3.17 2.23 1 6660 12 3
9.8 3.04 2.05 0 8352 13 1
28 8.97 2.27 1 6494 16 3
9.1 2.87 2.12 0 7448 15 2
39.2 15.5 2.53 1 8428 14 3
32.2 12.96 2.65 1 3167 13 3
28 9.5 2.47 1 6697 12 2
24.5 6.32 2.15 0 2485 15 3
21.7 10.24 2.48 1 9968 13 2
21 6.93 2.29 1 4608 14 2
24.5 8.85 2.41 1 8580 10 3
7.7 1.89 2.03 0 6805 19 2
32.9 13 2.4 1 3328 12 3
10.5 3.14 1.81 1 10015 18 3
9.1 2.75 2.01 0 7871 14 3
10.5 3.17 1.96 0 9564 16 3
16.8 3.62 2.15 1 10768 16 1
14 4.66 2.35 0 6670 16 3
30.8 11.08 2.63 1 1701 16 3
14.7 4.84 2.15 1 11142 13 3
20.3 6.14 2.41 1 14586 12 3
14.7 4.85 2.26 1 10980 16 3
6.3 2.75 1.83 1 11460 13 3
21.7 6.43 2.5 1 6733 15 2
23.1 10.75 2.45 1 6842 17 3
14.7 4.93 1.98 1 13932 11 3
20.3 6.1 2.25 1 1668 10 3
3.5 1.95 1.77 1 4229 15 3
14.7 4.95 2 1 7688 10 3
17.5 5.44 2.34 1 5754 13 2
14 4.46 1.93 1 8715 15 3
8.4 2.25 2.2 0 12600 16 3
18.9 6.55 2.06 1 12244 17 1
26.6 9.28 2.56 1 7804 19 2
-0.7 1.79 1.94 0 2723 18 3
15.4 5.2 2.02 1 11452 11 2
24.5 8.77 2.4 1 9517 12 3
11.9 3.65 2.28 1 11555 15 3
18.9 7.2 2.36 1 10737 13 3
30.1 6.25 2.23 1 4672 13 1
11.9 3.22 2.45 0 1871 14 2
17.5 4.81 2.16 1 6680 12 2
19.6 5.67 2.26 1 6172 15 3
12.6 3.33 1.84 0 10356 14 3
9.8 2.87 2.14 1 12306 15 3
21.7 6.89 2.25 1 6181 16 2
12.6 3.39 2.01 1 9125 16 3
24.5 6.53 2.22 1 8544 14 3
15.4 4.98 2.39 1 9140 17 3
16.1 3.98 2.05 1 11854 13 2
4.9 2.33 2.23 0 7108 12 2
13.3 4.43 1.98 1 10883 12 2
7 1.87 1.71 1 3466 16 2
25.2 8.95 2.39 1 14658 16 2
16.1 3.62 2.15 0 12613 16 3
18.2 5.47 1.94 1 6692 11 3
0.7 1.17 2.13 0 5599 19 3
19.6 6.03 1.94 1 6136 13 3
21.7 6.69 1.95 1 11850 14 1
18.2 5.57 2.09 1 15498 17 2
20.3 7.62 1.89 0 6119 11 3
23.8 6.69 2.45 0 6253 14 3
15.4 5.25 2.01 1 8962 14 3
20.3 8.49 2.04 1 2863 15 1
20.3 6.06 2.6 0 979 17 2
11.2 3.37 1.94 0 9812 14 2
16.1 4.53 1.95 1 8451 15 2
18.9 8.07 2.57 1 7474 12 3
14.7 3.84 2.13 1 7300 14 3
32.9 13.2 2.36 1 6182 12 3
18.2 9.94 2.67 1 7410 8 3

Further Guidance

It is important to bear in mind that the content of your answer will depend on the argument that you wish to put forward in answer to the question and not solely on the concepts that the question explicitly identifies. Remember, the Directors of PK Mart are not experts in statistical analysis. Hence you will need to explain what you are doing and why, as well as the meaning of your results.

In structuring your report you may wish to consider the following framework. This does not mean that you simply respond to (a) to (e) below, but rather that you formulate headings and sub-headings for your report using the framework as a starting point.

  1. A graphical representation of the data and a discussion of any issues or patterns which arise from this exercise. You need to decide upon the exact data to use and appropriate graph(s).

  1. Descriptive analysis and discussion of the variables shown in the data set.

  1. Bivariate (two variable) analysis and discussion which considers these variables and the effects of profit sharing.

  1. Multivariate (three or more variable) analysis and associated discussion which makes use of the data given.

  1. Any other issues, problems or additional complications which you feel should be conveyed to the Directors of PK Mart with respect to your analysis.

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

1 Expert Approved Answer
Step: 1 Unlock blur-text-image
Question Has Been Solved by an Expert!

Get step-by-step solutions from verified subject matter experts

Step: 2 Unlock
Step: 3 Unlock

Students Have Also Explored These Related Finance Questions!