Question: Barry is charged with robbery for robbing a discount store. He denies the charge and offers his friend Sam to testify as his alibi witness.

Barry is charged with robbery for robbing a discount store. He denies the charge and offers his friend Sam to testify as his alibi witness. Sam is to testify that at the time of the robbery Barry was with him at a sports event. At the pretrial hearing, the judge believes that Sam's testimony is not credible for he is not telling a consistent story. The prosecution argues that because Sam apparently is lying his testimony is not relevant.

Is Sam's testimony relevant?

Should the court permit him to testify?

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

1 Expert Approved Answer

Step: 1 Unlock blur-text-image

Question Has Been Solved by an Expert!

Get step-by-step solutions from verified subject matter experts

Step: 2 Unlock

Step: 3 Unlock

Students Have Also Explored These Related Law Questions!

Determine whether the evidence in the following cases is relevant. Do not only answer "yes" or "no". You need to give your reasoning. Barry is charged with robbery for robbing a discount store. He...

Question 6 (10 points) There are two aspects of relevancy. "The evidence has any tendency to make a fact more or less probable than it would be without it." This aspect of relevancy is known as:...

Question 63 (10 points) Saved Larry is charged with fraud and he denies the charge. He calls Sam to testify as his character witness. The prosecution intends to impeach Sam by showing that Sam was...

6.1 Grace and Hester were standing at an intersection. They saw Charlie's car go through a red light and slam into another car. Grace exclaimed: "Oh My God! Charlie went through a red light and...

Determine whether the evidence in the following cases is relevant. Do not only answer "yes" or "no". You need to give your reasoning. 2.1 Jeff is charged with robbery. The defense intends to offer...

6.4 Dick is charged with murder for murdering Fred. He claims insanity defense. To prove Dick was insane, the defense asks Velma to testify about Dick's statement when he was chasing and shooting at...

Identify all evidence law issues. Point out the applicable law with respect to each identified issue. Analyze the issue based on the facts of the question by applying relevant laws. Sufficiently...

7.3 Edgar is on trial for child molestation. The prosecution alleges that Edgar sexually abused his five-year-old stepdaughter, Lisa. The prosecution calls Lisa to testify. At the competency hearing,...

Sam is on trial for robbery and he denies the charge. He claims that on the day of the crime he was taking care of his grandma. The grandma testifies that on the day of the crime Sam was with her in...

1. Solve the pde +44=0

2. Prove that if a function f S T is right cancellable, then f is surjective.

A corporation is . Multiple Choice easy to create based on business conduct a domestic copocation in any state in which it chooses to do business dissolved when a member wethdraws totally controlled...

2023 1040 form 1.Phillip and Claire are married and file a joint return. Phillip is self-employed as a real estate agent, and Claire is a flight attendant. Phillip and Claire have three dependent...