Bernie, Director of Paralegals, has asked for a report about mandatory and persuasive legal authority. He...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Bernie, Director of Paralegals, has asked for a report about mandatory and persuasive legal authority. He also has asked all the interns to begin their practice with legal analysis/reasoning. Provide the information requested below in a report to Bernie in the format specified below. This is a two-part report. Instructions Part I: Mandatory and Persuasive Authority Read the scenario and answer the questions below. Scenario: Mabel Smith, 80, was shopping at a supermarket with her daughter in Montgomery County, Maryland. She walked slowly, with her daughter holding her arm. While walking down an aisle, she and her daughter maneuvered around an employee who was restocking fruit from a stack of boxes placed in the middle of the aisle. Despite her attempts to walk around the boxes, Mrs. Smith's left foot caught on the corner of the bottom box, and she fell to the floor. She sprained her ankle, and her head hit the side of a fruit stand. Because she had hit her head and appeared disoriented, an ambulance was called to transport her to the hospital. She was diagnosed with a concussion and had bruises and a cut on her head and spent two days in the hospital. Mrs. Smith wants to file a lawsuit in the Circuit Court for Montgomery County, Maryland, against the supermarket to recover costs for her medical expenses. You are tasked with reviewing case law and secondary sources, then completing a preliminary analysis of Mabel Smith's case by answering the questions below. A. In your research, you find a case decided by the Maine Supreme Judicial Court, Rogers v. Friday Markets. The facts of Rogers v. Friday Markets are similar to the facts in Mrs. Smith's case. The Maine Supreme Judicial Court held in Rogers v. Friday Markets that the injured person in the case was entitled to the damages for medical expenses awarded by the jury. 1. Is Rogers v. Friday Markets mandatory authority or persuasive authority in Mrs. Smith's case? 2. Explain your answer. B. In your research, you find a case decided by the Court of Special Appeals of Maryland, Starr v. Noah's Market. The facts of Starr v. Noah's Market are similar to the facts in Mrs. Smith's case and the Court of Special Appeals held that the injured person in that case was entitled to the damages for medical expenses awarded by the jury. 1. Is Starr v. Noah's Market mandatory authority or persuasive authority in Mrs. Smith's case? 2. Explain your answer. C. In your research, you find an article in a well-respected academic law journal that surveys and summarizes the law in "slip and fall" cases similar to Mrs. Smith's case in all 50 states. The article concludes that the modern trend is for courts to hold businesses liable for plaintiffs' injuries when the plaintiff shows a reasonable probability that the business created a potentially dangerous condition and the business had knowledge of the potentially dangerous condition. 1. Would this summary of the law provide mandatory authority or persuasive authority for Mrs. Smith's case? 2. Explain your answer. Part II: Legal Analysis/Analogical Reasoning Read the scenario and answer the questions below. Scenario A: You have found a case that is mandatory authority for Mrs. Smith's case. The case is Garcia v. Home Stuff Stores. In the Garcia case, the court upheld the jury's award to Garcia for $220,000 in damages for medical expenses. Maria Garcia was shopping in Home Stuff Stores in Maryland when she fell on a wet and soapy floor. She sustained a broken leg and a wrist injury requiring medical treatment and extensive physical therapy. Garcia sued the store for failing to warn of the wet floor and potential fall hazard. The store admitted "wet floor" warning signs were not placed at the time of the accident, and the wet area was not blocked off from customers. 1. How might Mrs. Smith support her request for damages from the store by comparing the facts of her case and the facts of Garcia v. Home Stuff Stores? 2. How might the store oppose Mrs. Smith's request for damages by distinguishing the facts of Mrs. Smith's case and the facts of Garcia v. Home Stuff Stores? Format The report should follow the format below. Label all parts, and sub parts of the report. TO: Bernie Franks, Director of Paralegals FROM: your name RE: Mandatory and Persuasive Authority and Legal Analysis/Reasoning DATE: Part 1. Mandatory and Persuasive Authority A. 1. 2 B. 1. 2 C. 1. 2. Part II. Legal Analysis/Reasoning A. 1. 2. Bernie, Director of Paralegals, has asked for a report about mandatory and persuasive legal authority. He also has asked all the interns to begin their practice with legal analysis/reasoning. Provide the information requested below in a report to Bernie in the format specified below. This is a two-part report. Instructions Part I: Mandatory and Persuasive Authority Read the scenario and answer the questions below. Scenario: Mabel Smith, 80, was shopping at a supermarket with her daughter in Montgomery County, Maryland. She walked slowly, with her daughter holding her arm. While walking down an aisle, she and her daughter maneuvered around an employee who was restocking fruit from a stack of boxes placed in the middle of the aisle. Despite her attempts to walk around the boxes, Mrs. Smith's left foot caught on the corner of the bottom box, and she fell to the floor. She sprained her ankle, and her head hit the side of a fruit stand. Because she had hit her head and appeared disoriented, an ambulance was called to transport her to the hospital. She was diagnosed with a concussion and had bruises and a cut on her head and spent two days in the hospital. Mrs. Smith wants to file a lawsuit in the Circuit Court for Montgomery County, Maryland, against the supermarket to recover costs for her medical expenses. You are tasked with reviewing case law and secondary sources, then completing a preliminary analysis of Mabel Smith's case by answering the questions below. A. In your research, you find a case decided by the Maine Supreme Judicial Court, Rogers v. Friday Markets. The facts of Rogers v. Friday Markets are similar to the facts in Mrs. Smith's case. The Maine Supreme Judicial Court held in Rogers v. Friday Markets that the injured person in the case was entitled to the damages for medical expenses awarded by the jury. 1. Is Rogers v. Friday Markets mandatory authority or persuasive authority in Mrs. Smith's case? 2. Explain your answer. B. In your research, you find a case decided by the Court of Special Appeals of Maryland, Starr v. Noah's Market. The facts of Starr v. Noah's Market are similar to the facts in Mrs. Smith's case and the Court of Special Appeals held that the injured person in that case was entitled to the damages for medical expenses awarded by the jury. 1. Is Starr v. Noah's Market mandatory authority or persuasive authority in Mrs. Smith's case? 2. Explain your answer. C. In your research, you find an article in a well-respected academic law journal that surveys and summarizes the law in "slip and fall" cases similar to Mrs. Smith's case in all 50 states. The article concludes that the modern trend is for courts to hold businesses liable for plaintiffs' injuries when the plaintiff shows a reasonable probability that the business created a potentially dangerous condition and the business had knowledge of the potentially dangerous condition. 1. Would this summary of the law provide mandatory authority or persuasive authority for Mrs. Smith's case? 2. Explain your answer. Part II: Legal Analysis/Analogical Reasoning Read the scenario and answer the questions below. Scenario A: You have found a case that is mandatory authority for Mrs. Smith's case. The case is Garcia v. Home Stuff Stores. In the Garcia case, the court upheld the jury's award to Garcia for $220,000 in damages for medical expenses. Maria Garcia was shopping in Home Stuff Stores in Maryland when she fell on a wet and soapy floor. She sustained a broken leg and a wrist injury requiring medical treatment and extensive physical therapy. Garcia sued the store for failing to warn of the wet floor and potential fall hazard. The store admitted "wet floor" warning signs were not placed at the time of the accident, and the wet area was not blocked off from customers. 1. How might Mrs. Smith support her request for damages from the store by comparing the facts of her case and the facts of Garcia v. Home Stuff Stores? 2. How might the store oppose Mrs. Smith's request for damages by distinguishing the facts of Mrs. Smith's case and the facts of Garcia v. Home Stuff Stores? Format The report should follow the format below. Label all parts, and sub parts of the report. TO: Bernie Franks, Director of Paralegals FROM: your name RE: Mandatory and Persuasive Authority and Legal Analysis/Reasoning DATE: Part 1. Mandatory and Persuasive Authority A. 1. 2 B. 1. 2 C. 1. 2. Part II. Legal Analysis/Reasoning A. 1. 2.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Report Regarding Mandatory and Persuasive Authority and Legal AnalysisReasoning ... View the full answer
Related Book For
Auditing a risk based approach to conducting a quality audit
ISBN: 978-1133939153
9th edition
Authors: Karla Johnstone, Audrey Gramling, Larry Rittenberg
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these law questions
-
The Crazy Eddie fraud may appear smaller and gentler than the massive billion-dollar frauds exposed in recent times, such as Bernie Madoffs Ponzi scheme, frauds in the subprime mortgage market, the...
-
Managing Scope Changes Case Study Scope changes on a project can occur regardless of how well the project is planned or executed. Scope changes can be the result of something that was omitted during...
-
Planning is one of the most important management functions in any business. A front office managers first step in planning should involve determine the departments goals. Planning also includes...
-
Football Comm LLC is a manufacturer of devices for football coaches and their coaching staffs that enable them to quickly and effectively communicate with one another during a game through a wireless...
-
Name at least four differences between partnerships and corporations.
-
Find the length x using the given volume V. V = 45 cm 5 cm X 9 cm
-
Evergreen Company's 2020 reconciliation between pretax GAAP income and taxable income is as follows. Pretax GAAP income.. Depreciation adjustment. Permanent difference. Taxable income.. $ 200,000...
-
1. Assume you are a financial analyst who works for a major brokerage company that is heavily invested in Bre-X Minerals. a. In what ways would investigating management and directors help determine...
-
Thank you so much Question 19 The following accounts appeared on the trail balance of Blossom Company at December 31, 2020. Notes Payable (short-term) Accumulated Depreciation - Bldg. Supplies...
-
Bruce also requires a calculation of taxable income for the most recent year ended December 31, 2019. The calculation should be prepared in Excel. He has also requested that you prepare the year-end...
-
Joe Smith, age 50, is widowed and his social security number is 123-45-6789. His wife, Susan, died in 2020. He lives at 123 Main Drive., New York, NY 55555. Joe does not want to contribute to the...
-
Give two (2) examples of communication strategies when implementing a continuous-improvement initiative. Give Two (2) examples of business-related processes related to your chosen communication...
-
It carries out a synthesis on the topic of efficiency in the Walrasian balance and proposes an application case on a real-life topic. (Practical case explained step by step) Remember that it is only...
-
n people decide to elect a leader by arranging themselves in a circle and eliminating every m-th person around the circle, closing ranks as each person drops out. The problem is to find out which...
-
The matter of self-representation is a strong social issue. Many believe the cost of lawyers is to blame preventing the poor, low income and even the middle-class out of being fairly represented...
-
VR-X issued 100,000 common stocks at par value of $12 to expand its business 3 years ago specialized in interior design services. The company has just paid a dividend of $2 per share and predicts for...
-
sub all info in Use of Human Resources Use of Janitorial Human resources -- 5% Janitorial 10% -- Assembly 60% 40% Finishing 30% 55% The budgeted costs in the service departments are: Human Resources,...
-
What is the expected payoff of an investment that yields $5,000 with a probability of 0.15 and $500 with a probability of 0.85? Select one: O a. $325 O b. $5,500 O c. $2,750 O d. $1,175
-
The following are risks relating to marketable securities. Categorize each risk as relating to either (a) inherent or fraud risk or (b) control risk. 1. Management manipulation of the classification...
-
MULTIPLE-CHOICE QUESTIONS 1. Which of the following characteristics would lead the auditor to assess control risk at a higher level? a. It is difficult for the auditor to determine or gain access to...
-
You have sent confirmations to 40 customers of Berg Shovick Express, a long-time audit client experiencing some financial difficulty. The company sells specialized high-technology goods. You have...
-
A Mrs T Hulley is paid monthly. For part of April 19X6 she earns 860 and then goes on maternity leave, her maternity pay for April being 90. She has pay free of tax 320, whilst on the next 250 she...
-
A P Urmston is paid monthly. For June 19X6 he earns 1,500 and also receives statutory sick pay of 150. He pays 90 superannuation which is allowed as a relief against income tax and he has further...
-
The data which follows was extracted from the books of account of H Kirk, an engineer, on 31 March 19X6, his financial year end. You are required to allocate each or part of the items above to either...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App