Question: Case EvaluationRita agrees to paint Bobs house for $ 2 0 , 0 0 0 . The partys agreed to a sky blue ( RGB

Case EvaluationRita agrees to paint Bobs house for $20,000. The partys agreed to a sky blue (RGB 135,206,235) color. Bob prepays for the job and gives Rita $20,000 in advance. Rita notices that Bob had a lot of Detroit Lions memorabilia throughout his home. Rita decided to surprise Bob and purchased and painted the home with Honolulu blue (RGB 0,118,182). When Bob sees the finished paint job he is extremely upset and tells Rita to repaint the house using the agreed upon sky blue code or return the $20,000 payment. After a few days, the color grows on Bob, and he likes it better than the sky-blue color due to his fondness for the Detroit Lions. He calls Rita and tells her that he doesnt want to fight over it anymore and if she gives him $10,000 that he would drop the matter. Rita agrees to pay him $10,000 however she never makes the payment. Bob sues Rita for $10,000.The state where Rita and Bob reside, requires all civil cases go through the case evaluation (CE) process as a precursor to trial. The CE panel has three neutral attorneys. The three attorneys will hear the matter and then decides how the case should be resolved. The parties have a choice to accept or reject the CE award. However, if a party rejects the award and elects to go to trial, the party must beat the CE award by 10% or else pay the other parties legal/court fees that accumulate after the CE process.If the CE panel awards $9,000 to Bob, and Bob accepts the award and Rita rejects. The case then goes to trial, and the judge awards $8,700 to Bob. Rita must pay Bob $8,700 and his legal/court costs. Why? Rita needed to beat the CE award by $900($9,000 x 10%). So, Rita needed the trial court judgment to be $8,100 or less to not pay Bobs legal/court fees.However, lets assume that Bob rejects that the CE panels award, and Rita accepts. The case then goes to trial, and the judge awards $8,700 to Bob. Rita must pay Bob $8,700, but Bob must pay Ritas legal/court costs. Why? Bob needed to beat the CE award by $900($9,000 x 10%). So, Bob needed the trial court judgment to be $9,900 or more to not pay Ritas legal/court fees.Does this make sense?

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

1 Expert Approved Answer
Step: 1 Unlock blur-text-image
Question Has Been Solved by an Expert!

Get step-by-step solutions from verified subject matter experts

Step: 2 Unlock
Step: 3 Unlock

Students Have Also Explored These Related General Management Questions!