Case Name: Bosse vs. Brinker Restaurant Corp d/b/a Chili's Bar and Grill Which court is making...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Case Name: Bosse vs. Brinker Restaurant Corp d/b/a Chili's Bar and Grill Which court is making this decision? The Massachusetts superior court/ the appellate court Who is the Plaintiff? Bosse Who did what to whom? Who is the Defendant? Brinker restaurant corp Bosse was part of a group who dined and dashed. A regular patron followed them, whose car was unmarked, he had no Chili's uniform or any other insignia of employment at Chili's. In this car chase, they crash and Bosse suffers injuries generating the lawsuit against Chili's. What relief (claim) was sought by the plaintiff in the lower court? Bosse sued for damages and personal injuries related to the crash. What was the lower court's decision? And, if applicable, the Court of Appeals' decision? The court granted the plaintiff's motion for a summary judgment. The court ruled that the evidence was insufficient to create a genuine issue of whether Chili's authorized the patron to act as a pose to conduct a chase. Who prevailed in the lower court(s)? Bosse, for suffering injuries, which lead to him suing upon the theory of respondeat superior. What is the specific legal question, based on what facts, is this court being asked to address? Do the undisputed material facts permit a genuine issue, whether Chili's consented to, controlled, and benefitted from the pursuit of the deadbeat teenagers by the zealous patron? What law(s) and specifically, which legal element(s) is (are) at issue? Agency relationship, which requires three elements. In this case, they were consent, the right of control, and agent conduct that benefits the principal somehow. What is the court's reason (interpretation) for the application of, change in, or exception to the law? The court considered whether the parties' conduct created an agency relationship. What had to be proven by the plaintiff and was the burden met? He had to prove reasonable expectation of proving an essential element of his claim. These elements were not met. What had to be proven by Defendant and was the burden met? He had to prove that no genuine issue of fact existed regarding the lack of an agency relationship through express acts or implication. The burden was met. What did the court decide on the legal question? The evidence seems to have failed to materialize upon all three of the elements. Consequently, the plaintiffs enjoy n reasonable expectation of proving an agency relationship. What is this court's order? Full summary judgment. Will the plaintiff's claim in the lower court be: granted, allowed to proceed, or denied? Denied! Evidence appears to have failed to materialize upon all three of the elements. Who prevailed in this court? Brinker prevailed in this court. Case Name: Bosse vs. Brinker Restaurant Corp d/b/a Chili's Bar and Grill Which court is making this decision? The Massachusetts superior court/ the appellate court Who is the Plaintiff? Bosse Who did what to whom? Who is the Defendant? Brinker restaurant corp Bosse was part of a group who dined and dashed. A regular patron followed them, whose car was unmarked, he had no Chili's uniform or any other insignia of employment at Chili's. In this car chase, they crash and Bosse suffers injuries generating the lawsuit against Chili's. What relief (claim) was sought by the plaintiff in the lower court? Bosse sued for damages and personal injuries related to the crash. What was the lower court's decision? And, if applicable, the Court of Appeals' decision? The court granted the plaintiff's motion for a summary judgment. The court ruled that the evidence was insufficient to create a genuine issue of whether Chili's authorized the patron to act as a pose to conduct a chase. Who prevailed in the lower court(s)? Bosse, for suffering injuries, which lead to him suing upon the theory of respondeat superior. What is the specific legal question, based on what facts, is this court being asked to address? Do the undisputed material facts permit a genuine issue, whether Chili's consented to, controlled, and benefitted from the pursuit of the deadbeat teenagers by the zealous patron? What law(s) and specifically, which legal element(s) is (are) at issue? Agency relationship, which requires three elements. In this case, they were consent, the right of control, and agent conduct that benefits the principal somehow. What is the court's reason (interpretation) for the application of, change in, or exception to the law? The court considered whether the parties' conduct created an agency relationship. What had to be proven by the plaintiff and was the burden met? He had to prove reasonable expectation of proving an essential element of his claim. These elements were not met. What had to be proven by Defendant and was the burden met? He had to prove that no genuine issue of fact existed regarding the lack of an agency relationship through express acts or implication. The burden was met. What did the court decide on the legal question? The evidence seems to have failed to materialize upon all three of the elements. Consequently, the plaintiffs enjoy n reasonable expectation of proving an agency relationship. What is this court's order? Full summary judgment. Will the plaintiff's claim in the lower court be: granted, allowed to proceed, or denied? Denied! Evidence appears to have failed to materialize upon all three of the elements. Who prevailed in this court? Brinker prevailed in this court.
Expert Answer:
Related Book For
Legal Environment of Business A Managerial Approach Theory to Practice
ISBN: 978-1259686207
3rd edition
Authors: Sean Melvin, Enrique Guerra Pujol
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these law questions
-
Patrick HAYDEN and Melissa Hayden, on behalf of their minor child, A.H., Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. GREENSBURG COMMUNITY SCHOOL CORPORATION, et al., Defendants-Appellees. No. 13-1757.Decided: February...
-
1. If the pursuing patron were actually an off-duty employee of Chilis, how would that impact your agency analysis? 2. When the pursuing patron called the Chilis employee with a description of the...
-
In the Tokyo subway system, routes are labeled by letters and stops by numbers, such as G-8 or A-3. Stations allowing transfers are sets of stops. Find a Tokyo subway map on the web, develop a simple...
-
Twenty-six countries won medals in the 2010 Winter Olympics. The table lists them, along with the total number of medals each won: a) Try to make a display of these data. What problems do you...
-
Which is more critical to success in organizations continuous improvement or quality control? Support your position.
-
True or False. For a beam with grid points \(-1,1,2,3, \ldots\), the central difference approximation of \(\left.\frac{d^{2} W}{d x^{2}} ight|_{1}=0\) yields \(W_{2}-2 W_{1}+W_{-1}=0\).
-
A number of costs are listed on the next page that may be relevant in decisions faced by the management of Poulsen & Sonner A/S, a Danish furniture manufacturer: Required: Copy the information above...
-
Collapse The SQL Server backup and restore component provides an essential safeguard for protecting critical data stored in your SQL Server databases. Why is it vital that you backup your data and...
-
How does ideology function as a tool for both justifying and challenging existing power structures, and what are the implications for political discourse ?
-
A researcher hypothesizes that the Gross Domestic Product (measured in millions of dollars) of a country is impacted by its percent Urban Population (measured as % of population living in Urban...
-
This is wrong bad news email written , please correct this bad news message. Subject: after thinking it over, I've decided to not grant you the free repair for your sony plasma tv and blu-ray player....
-
If total assets increased $100,000 during the year and total liabilities decreased $60,000, what is the amount of owner's equity at the end of the year? Owner's equity $
-
An elephant of mass 6000 kg is standing near the left edge of a platform with wheels which has a mass 1 . 0 times 10 4 kg he walks a distance 2 . 2 m towards the right edge of the platform if there...
-
As a project manager, you have a team member who is a subject matter expert and will answer questions as needed during the execution of the project. What role will this person be assigned in a RACI...
-
How can leaders address individual and organizational resistance to change?
-
7. Baladna wants to analyze process that includes delivery by suppliers, production inside the company, transportation to to its customers and information systems. Then it also wants to find out...
-
Calculate the correlations among all numeric variables in Exercise 9.1 using SPSS, or R. (In R read in the data as a data.frame (e.g., theData) and then use (cor(theData). You dont need to attach...
-
Using one of the online calculators, how large a correlation would you need for the relationships shown in Exercise 9.2 to be significant? (This will involve a bit of trial and error.) Calculate the...
-
What are the strongest single predictors of infant mortality in Exercise 9.2? Exercise 9.2 Calculate the correlations among all numeric variables in Exercise 9.1 using SPSS, or R. (In R read in the...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App