case study consists in your composing a reply to this letter. in doing so, consider poppers theory
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
case study consists in your composing a reply to this letter. in doing so, consider popper’s theory of science, his view pertaining to the problem of demarcation between science and pseudo-science, its solution, and the characteristics of good scientific behavior. the arguments included in your reply should be backed-up by examples of theories, statements, or enterprises which meet popper’s criterion of demarcation and theory of science.
Transcribed Image Text:
PHIL-213 Case Study 2 The following letter was received by the editor of a science journal. Dear Sir: I am taking the liberty of calling upon you to be the judge in a dispute between me and an acquaintance who is no longer a friend. The question at issue is this: Is my creation, umbrellaology, a science? Allow me to explain.... For the past eighteen years assisted by a few faithful disciples, I have been collecting mate- rials on a subject hitherto almost wholly neglected by scientists, the umbrella. The results of my investigations to date are embodied in the nine volumes which I am sending to you under a separate cover. Pending their receipt, let me describe to you briefly the nature of their contents and the method I pursued in compiling them. I began on the Island of Manhattan. Proceeding block by block, house by house, family by family, and individual by individual, I ascer- tained (1) the number of umbrellas possessed, (2) their size, (3) their weight, (4) their color. Having covered Manhattan after many years, I eventually extended the survey to the other boroughs of the City of New York, and at length com- pleted the entire city. Thus I was ready to carry forward the work to the rest of the state and indeed the rest of the United States and the whole known world. It was at this point that I approached my erstwhile friend. I am a modest man, but I felt I had the right to be recognized as the creator of a new science. He, on the other hand, claimed that umbrellaology was not a science at all. First, he said, it was silly to investigate umbrellas. Now this argument is false, because science scorns not to deal with any object, however humble and lowly, even to the hind leg of a flea. Then why not umbrellas? Next, he said that umbrellaology could not be recognized as a science because it was of no use or benefit to mankind. But is not the truth the most precious thing in life? Are not my nine volumes filled with the truth about my subject? Every word in them is true. Every sentence contains a hard, cold fact. When he asked me what was the object of umbrellaology I was proud to say, To seek and discover the truth is object enough for me. I am a pure scientist; I have no ulterior motives. Hence it follows that I am satisfied with truth alone. Next, he said my truths were dated and that any one of my finds might cease to be true tomorrow. But this, I pointed out, is not an argument against umbrellaology, but rather an argument for keeping it up to date, which exactly is what I propose. Let us have surveys monthly, weekly, or even daily, to keep our knowledge abreast of the changing facts. His next contention was that umbrellaology had entertained no hypotheses and had developed no theories or laws. This is a great error. In the course of my investigations, I employed innumerable hypotheses. Before entering each new block and each new section of the city, I entertained an hypothesis as regards the number and characteristics of the umbrellas that would be found there, which hypotheses were either verified or nullified by my PHIL-213 Case Study 2 subsequent observations, in accordance with proper scientific procedure, as explained in authoritative texts. (In fact, it is of interest to note that I can sub- stantiate and document every one of my replies to these objections by numerous quotations from standard works, leading journals, public speeches of eminent scientists, and the like.) As for theories and laws, my work represents an abun- dance of them. I will here mention only a few, by way of illustration. There is the Law of Color Variation Relative to Ownership by Sex. (Umbrellas owned by women tend to great variety of color, whereas those owned by men are almost all black.) To this law I have given exact statistical formulation. (See vol. 6, Appendix 1, Table 3, p. 582.) There are the curiously interrelated Laws of Individual Ownership of Plurality of Umbrellas, and Plurality of Ownership of Individual Umbrellas. The interrelationship assumes the form, in the first law, of almost direct ratio to annual income, and in the second, in almost inverse ratio to annual income. (For an exact statement of the modifying circumstances, see vol. 8, p. 350.) There is also the Law of Tendency Toward Acquisition of Umbrellas in Rainy Weather. To this law I have given experimental verification in chapter 3 of volume 3. In the same way I have performed numerous other experiments in connection with my generalizations. Thus I feel that my creation is in all respects a genuine science, and I appeal to you for substantiation of my opinion.... This case study consists in your composing a reply to this letter. In doing so, consider Popper s theory of science, his view pertaining to the problem of demarcation between science and pseudo-science, its solution, and the characteristics of good scientific behavior. The arguments included in your reply should be backed-up by examples of theories, statements, or enterprises which meet Popper s criterion of demarcation and theory of science. PHIL-213 Case Study 2 The following letter was received by the editor of a science journal. Dear Sir: I am taking the liberty of calling upon you to be the judge in a dispute between me and an acquaintance who is no longer a friend. The question at issue is this: Is my creation, umbrellaology, a science? Allow me to explain.... For the past eighteen years assisted by a few faithful disciples, I have been collecting mate- rials on a subject hitherto almost wholly neglected by scientists, the umbrella. The results of my investigations to date are embodied in the nine volumes which I am sending to you under a separate cover. Pending their receipt, let me describe to you briefly the nature of their contents and the method I pursued in compiling them. I began on the Island of Manhattan. Proceeding block by block, house by house, family by family, and individual by individual, I ascer- tained (1) the number of umbrellas possessed, (2) their size, (3) their weight, (4) their color. Having covered Manhattan after many years, I eventually extended the survey to the other boroughs of the City of New York, and at length com- pleted the entire city. Thus I was ready to carry forward the work to the rest of the state and indeed the rest of the United States and the whole known world. It was at this point that I approached my erstwhile friend. I am a modest man, but I felt I had the right to be recognized as the creator of a new science. He, on the other hand, claimed that umbrellaology was not a science at all. First, he said, it was silly to investigate umbrellas. Now this argument is false, because science scorns not to deal with any object, however humble and lowly, even to the hind leg of a flea. Then why not umbrellas? Next, he said that umbrellaology could not be recognized as a science because it was of no use or benefit to mankind. But is not the truth the most precious thing in life? Are not my nine volumes filled with the truth about my subject? Every word in them is true. Every sentence contains a hard, cold fact. When he asked me what was the object of umbrellaology I was proud to say, To seek and discover the truth is object enough for me. I am a pure scientist; I have no ulterior motives. Hence it follows that I am satisfied with truth alone. Next, he said my truths were dated and that any one of my finds might cease to be true tomorrow. But this, I pointed out, is not an argument against umbrellaology, but rather an argument for keeping it up to date, which exactly is what I propose. Let us have surveys monthly, weekly, or even daily, to keep our knowledge abreast of the changing facts. His next contention was that umbrellaology had entertained no hypotheses and had developed no theories or laws. This is a great error. In the course of my investigations, I employed innumerable hypotheses. Before entering each new block and each new section of the city, I entertained an hypothesis as regards the number and characteristics of the umbrellas that would be found there, which hypotheses were either verified or nullified by my PHIL-213 Case Study 2 subsequent observations, in accordance with proper scientific procedure, as explained in authoritative texts. (In fact, it is of interest to note that I can sub- stantiate and document every one of my replies to these objections by numerous quotations from standard works, leading journals, public speeches of eminent scientists, and the like.) As for theories and laws, my work represents an abun- dance of them. I will here mention only a few, by way of illustration. There is the Law of Color Variation Relative to Ownership by Sex. (Umbrellas owned by women tend to great variety of color, whereas those owned by men are almost all black.) To this law I have given exact statistical formulation. (See vol. 6, Appendix 1, Table 3, p. 582.) There are the curiously interrelated Laws of Individual Ownership of Plurality of Umbrellas, and Plurality of Ownership of Individual Umbrellas. The interrelationship assumes the form, in the first law, of almost direct ratio to annual income, and in the second, in almost inverse ratio to annual income. (For an exact statement of the modifying circumstances, see vol. 8, p. 350.) There is also the Law of Tendency Toward Acquisition of Umbrellas in Rainy Weather. To this law I have given experimental verification in chapter 3 of volume 3. In the same way I have performed numerous other experiments in connection with my generalizations. Thus I feel that my creation is in all respects a genuine science, and I appeal to you for substantiation of my opinion.... This case study consists in your composing a reply to this letter. In doing so, consider Popper s theory of science, his view pertaining to the problem of demarcation between science and pseudo-science, its solution, and the characteristics of good scientific behavior. The arguments included in your reply should be backed-up by examples of theories, statements, or enterprises which meet Popper s criterion of demarcation and theory of science.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Dear Thank you for your letter and for sending along your nine volume work on umbrella ology I have ... View the full answer
Related Book For
Microeconomics An Intuitive Approach with Calculus
ISBN: 978-0538453257
1st edition
Authors: Thomas Nechyba
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these general management questions
-
The Crazy Eddie fraud may appear smaller and gentler than the massive billion-dollar frauds exposed in recent times, such as Bernie Madoffs Ponzi scheme, frauds in the subprime mortgage market, the...
-
Planning is one of the most important management functions in any business. A front office managers first step in planning should involve determine the departments goals. Planning also includes...
-
Case Study: Quick Fix Dental Practice Technology requirements Application must be built using Visual Studio 2019 or Visual Studio 2017, professional or enterprise. The community edition is not...
-
Based on the information in Problems 9 and 10, what is Ryan and Nicoles liquidity ratio? What is their debt to asset ratio? Comment on each ratio. In Problems 10 Mortgage......... $ 43,500 Car...
-
Explain the assumptions used in cost estimation.
-
The intangible assets section of Glover Ltd. at December 31, 2016, is presented below. Patents (60,000 cost less 6,000 amortization)...................54,000 Franchises (48,000 cost less 19,200...
-
Fuel economy leaders for the category of small sport utility vehicles include the Hyundai all-electric vehicle, Kona Electric, at 120 miles per gallon of gasoline equivalent (MPGe) and the Ford...
-
KVS Pharmacy fills prescriptions for a popular childrens antibiotic, Amoxycilin. The daily demand for Amoxycilin is normally distributed with a mean of 200 ounces and a standard deviation of 80...
-
The type of tooling to make for a manufacturing process depends on the expected total quantity of parts. Tooling made from standard components and less wear-resistant materials (soft tooling) can be...
-
Bowman Specialists Inc. (BSI) manufactures specialized equipment for polishing optical lenses. There are two modelsone (A25) principally used for fine eyewear and the other (A10) for lenses used in...
-
. Identify two behaviors portrayed in the video. The video had behaviors such as interruption and mouthing from one person. He disrespected all members of the group, including the social worker....
-
Write a program to print below pattern?
-
Jhon Ltd is a private company, considering an initial investment of $500,000 which generates $100,000 cash inflows for 7 years. Calculate the discount payback period discount rate given is 8%. when
-
A satellite traveling at 8.2 km/s at perigee fires a retrorocket at perigee altitude of 480 km. What delta-v is necessary to reach a minimum altitude of 100 miles during the next orbit?
-
What are the ethical considerations surrounding project governance structures and project leadership responsibilities, particularly in relation to accountability, transparency, and stakeholder trust ?
-
Of our secondary and tertiary education system, are we doing a great job preparing students for the professional world post-college, or should that be placed upon the employer? If we need have a...
-
Narayana Hrudayalaya Heart Hospital: Cardiac Care for the Poor (A) (NH Heart Hospital) List the top 3 most important factors that allow NH Heart Hospital to operate with low costs. Which of these is...
-
Is the modified 5-question approach to ethical decision making superior to the modified moral standards or modified Past in approach?
-
Confirmation Bias, Politics, Research and Last-Minute Studying: Individuals have lots of assumptions about the way the world works, assumptions that help frame how they make decisions. These...
-
In exercise 17.9, we considered the case of me trading assets that allow you to transfer consumption from good times to bad times. Suppose again that your income during economic expansions is e E and...
-
In the text we discussed two main conditions under which the median voters favored policy is also the Condorcet winner. A: Review the definition of a Condorcet winner. (a) What are the two conditions...
-
State whether the following are true or false. If false, explain why. (a) We debit cash received, but credit cash paid. (b) Revenue is debited to a revenue account, but purchases are credited to a...
-
Activity-based management (ABM) is defined as: a. The implementation of an activity-based costing system in a service company, such as a management consulting firm. b. The identification and...
-
Why are there usually more debit balances in a trial balance than credit balances?
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App