case study I need these points 1. Issues 2. Law 3.application4. Conclusion

Q6. Examine the below given case study give the solution and comments. (CLO5) (3 marks for Application 2 marks for comment =5 marks) (10 minutes) Marie walling Vs. Harry Johnson and Realty Company . This appeal concerns to action to recover the value of two diamond rings owned by plaintiff. They were delivered and accepted for safe keeping by the commodore Hotel, operated by defendant partnership and were subsequently taken from the hotel safe by robbery. Plaintiff had occupied an apartment in the hotel for some years. On July 9 , 1960, having been confined in a hospital with a broken leg she directed her son to take two rings from her apartment and deposit them with the hotel clerk for safe keeping.in accordance with customary practice in performing this service, the rings were exhibited to the clerk and placed in a sealed "safety deposit envelop' . Used by the hotel for depositing valuables belongings to guests. A numbered stub attached to the envelope was signed by the clerk and plaintiff's son. And a "depositor's check" containing the same number was detached from the signed stub and given to him. This depositor's check was to present when the envelope and contents were called for at which time the depositor was required to sign it so the signature could be compared