Consider a classic tragedy of the fishers where two individuals' actions have negative external effects on...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Consider a classic tragedy of the fishers where two individuals' actions have negative external effects on each other and also act as substitutes. Assume that individuals lower and Upper are maximizing utility functions: u= a(1-BE)e-e2 and U= a(1-ße)E - E2 a) Derive each individual's best response function to the other as a function of effort, plot these best response functions in effort space (i.e., e-E axes), draw in corresponding indifference curves, and circle the Nash Equilibrium. b) On the same graphs draw in indifference curves and identify (a) the egalitarian social planner's optimal choice (b) the outcome when lower has property rights and can make a take-it-or-leave-it offer to Upper to fish the lake for a permit and (c) the outcome when lower gets to choose their fishing effort first. Which of the three is pareto rankable compared to the Nash Equilibrium? Explain. c) Now consider a scenario where fishing has positive externalities and is a complement rather than a substitute. Graph linear best response functions in e-E space, show the Nash equilibrium, graph indifference curves for each of the three scenarios a,b,c in question 4.2 and comment on the welfare outcomes for first vs. second movers in part (c) relative to the Nash Equilibrium. Consider a classic tragedy of the fishers where two individuals' actions have negative external effects on each other and also act as substitutes. Assume that individuals lower and Upper are maximizing utility functions: u= a(1-BE)e-e2 and U= a(1-ße)E - E2 a) Derive each individual's best response function to the other as a function of effort, plot these best response functions in effort space (i.e., e-E axes), draw in corresponding indifference curves, and circle the Nash Equilibrium. b) On the same graphs draw in indifference curves and identify (a) the egalitarian social planner's optimal choice (b) the outcome when lower has property rights and can make a take-it-or-leave-it offer to Upper to fish the lake for a permit and (c) the outcome when lower gets to choose their fishing effort first. Which of the three is pareto rankable compared to the Nash Equilibrium? Explain. c) Now consider a scenario where fishing has positive externalities and is a complement rather than a substitute. Graph linear best response functions in e-E space, show the Nash equilibrium, graph indifference curves for each of the three scenarios a,b,c in question 4.2 and comment on the welfare outcomes for first vs. second movers in part (c) relative to the Nash Equilibrium.
Expert Answer:
Related Book For
Income Tax Fundamentals 2013
ISBN: 9781285586618
31st Edition
Authors: Gerald E. Whittenburg, Martha Altus Buller, Steven L Gill
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these economics questions
-
A fisherman at Hardin Lake can catch 20 fish per day, provided he has the lake to himself. Two fishermen can catch 19 fish apiece per day, and three can catch 18 fish apiece per day. Other numbers...
-
Plot both Renes total and marginal utility curves ongraphs. a. Total Utility b. Marginal Utility 35- 30 25 12- 10F 20 15- 10 F 5 4. 2 0 2 3 4 5 6 7 Quantity of Escargot Quantity of Escargot
-
Can an activity generate both positive and negative externalities at the same time? Explain your answer.
-
The equity profolio of a company is thus 31/12/2001. Nature: Actions A, Quantity = 350, Unit cost = 36000, Purchase dates = 03/1999, 2000 = 37000, 2001= 34000. Nature: Actions B, Qauntity = 125, Unit...
-
C-Spec, Inc., is attempting to determine whether an existing machine is capable of milling an engine part that has a key specification of 4 6 .003 inches. After a trial run on this machine, C- Spec...
-
Carrie D'Lake, Reed A. Green, and Doug A. Divot share a passion for golf and decide to go into the golf club manufacturing business together. On January 2, 2015, D'Lake, Green, and Divot form the...
-
Does the compass needle rotate? A. Yes, clockwise. B. Yes, counterclockwise. C. No, not at all. Positively charged rod Pivot
-
Jarvene Corporation uses the FIFO method in its process costing system. The following data are for the most recent month of operations in one of the company's processing departments: The cost of...
-
Find the following limits. Give reasons for your answers. x-2x-3 (i) lim x-3x-5x+12' (ii) lim x+2x - - 2x-3 5r+123 (iii) lim sin(2x). 414
-
Pet Emporium had a robbery on the weekend in which a large amount of inventory was taken. The loss is covered completely by insurance. A physical inventory count determined that the cost of the...
-
1. Briefly discuss the four factors that influence data quality. 2. Briefly explain what is meant by the term inferential statistics
-
As a newly appointed Police Chief in a major metropolitan city, of 100,000 residents that contains a diverse mixture of whites, African Americans, Asian Americans, and Hispanics. The unemployment...
-
What are the intricacies involved in the implementation of file systems within operating systems, with a focus on topics such as inode structures, journaling, and file allocation methods?...
-
1. What is your company, and what is its ticker symbol? 2. What industry is your company in? What are two or three of its biggest competitors? 3. Briefly describe what the company does. 4. Compare...
-
Last year, Barker Company's sales were $240,000, its fixed costs were $50,000, and its variable costs were $2 per unit. During the year, 80,000 units were sold. Estimate its contribution margin.
-
Now, in the order given below, make some modifications and populate your tables. Before you start below, make sure your initial code is run. The code is provided in BB. You should drop the tables...
-
Jackson Corporation bonds have 12 years to maturity. Interest is paid annually, the bonds have a face value of $1,000 and a coupon rate of 8%. The yield to maturity of the bonds is 9%. What is the...
-
The first national bank pays a 4% interest rate compound continuously. The effective annual rate paid by the bank is __________. a. 4.16% b. 4.20% c. 4.08% d. 4.12%
-
How much of each of the following prizes or awards is taxable? a. Cheline received a $50,000 gift bag at the Oscars in 2012. b. Jon received a gold watch worth $350 for 25 years of service to his...
-
Kathy Kennedy (age 44) is a single taxpayer and she lives at 212 North Pine Way, Payson, AZ 85541. Her Social Security number is 467-98-9784. Kathy's earnings and income tax withholding as the...
-
Mary paid $2,000 of state income taxes in 2012. The total sales tax she paid during 2012 was $5,500, which included $3,000 for the cost of a new car. How should Mary treat the taxes paid on her 2012...
-
Draw a block diagram for the feedback control of a liquid-level system, which consists of a valve with a control knob (0\%-100\%) and a liquid-level sensor. Clearly label essential components and...
-
A control system is represented using the block diagram shown in Figure 10.59. Sketch the root locus with respect to the proportional control gain K. Determine all the values of \(K\) for which the...
-
Roughly sketch the root locus with respect to \(K\) for the equation of \(1+K L(s)=0\) and the following choices for \(L(s)\). Make sure to give the asymptotes, arrival or departure angles, and...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App