Could you please explain holding and ration on this case ?

Date: 20221027 Docket: CI 16-01-03826 (Winnipeg Centre) Indexed as: Perdue v. MacDonald Cited as: 2022 MBKB 204 COURT OF KING'S BENCH OF MANITOBA B E T W E E N: LORI DIANE PERDUE, plaintiff, -and- ) COUNSEL: ) ) RICHARD BEAMISH ) for the plaintiff ) ) PETER BENJAMIN MACDONALD, defendant. ) THOR HANSELL ) DANIELLE BARCHYN ) for the defendants. ) ) JUDGMENT DELIVERED: )