Criteria Excellent $(5$ points$)$ Good $(4$ points$)$ Satisfactory $(3$ points$)$ Needs Improvement $(2$ points$)$ Unsatisfactory $(1$ point$)$ Clarity of Purpose Statement Clearly articulated and well$-$defined personal purpose, with strong connection to reflections. Personal purpose is clear but could be more specific or detailed. Purpose statement is somewhat clear but lacks depth or specificity. Vague or unclear purpose statement with limited connection to reflections. No clear purpose statement provided. Depth of Reflection Thoughtfully addresses all reflection questions, showing deep self$-$awareness. Addresses most reflection questions with some depth and selfawareness. Addresses some reflection questions but lacks depth in responses. Limited responses to reflection questions with minimal insight. Does not address reflection questions meaningfully. Organization and Structure Well$-$organized, logical flow of ideas, easy to follow. Generally organized but some areas lack flow or clarity. Somewhat organized but may be difficult to follow at times. Poorly organized, lacks clear structure. No clear organization or structure. Writing Quality Writing is clear, free of errors, and wellpolished. Mostly clear writing with few errors. Writing is understandable but contains noticeable errors. Writing is unclear or difficult to follow, with frequent errors. Writing is very poor, with significant issues in clarity or grammar