Did the peer respond to everything asked by the assignment prompt? Was the peer's overall response organized and logical? Was it easy to follow and smooth? Was it easy to understand the ideas the student was trying to communicate, or did you have to make assumptions to make sense out of what the peer wrote? Did the peer use their own words, or if they borrowed from somewhere else, did they give credit to the source they used? Were there consistent errors in grammar and punctuation that made it hard to understand or make sense out of the writing