TWO CUSTOMERS En. Soleh felt that something was wrong in the whole approach to costing and...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
TWO CUSTOMERS En. Soleh felt that something was wrong in the whole approach to costing and pricing in this industry. Using the comments he had read in Drucker's book, he began reviewing the manner in which his division, and indeed the whole industry, priced its coffee service. Using two typical customers, En. Soleh considered the implications of the existing procedure. The first customer was a small office complex in Ipoh. The customer generally ordered six kits of coffee every month. The office used a single brewing machine. Deliveries could only be made during regular working hours. The salesperson had quoted the price of the service at RM 44.42 per kit, to reflect the fact that the delivery was somewhat inconvenient and to incorporate a 23 per cent net profit margin on the business. This had been determined as follows: Cost of coffee 6 x RM 18.00 Operating Cost 6 x RM 16.20 Total Cost Selling Price with 23% Profit Selling Price per kit Customer Cost per cup RM 44.42/500 RM 108.00 97.20 205.20 266.52 44.42 RM 0.088 The second customer was much larger. It was a restaurant operation in downtown Penang. This client generally ordered 25 kits of roasted coffee per month. This customer operated a single brewing machine in the restaurant. The delivery was very easy because the restaurant was accustomed, and designed, to handle visits from suppliers. The pricing for this customer was as follows, with a net profit margin of 12 per cent in recognition of the higher volume purchased: Cost of coffee 25 x RM 18.00 Operating Cost 25 x RM 16.20 Total Cost Selling Price with 12% Profit Selling Price per kit Customer Cost per cup RM 38.86/500 RM 450.00 405.00 885.00 971.50 38.86 RM 0.078 The discount had been necessary to get this customer from a competitor. Unfortunately, the offering of the discount meant that this contract could not generate 15 per cent profit on sales. En. Solch was concerned that if his salespeople had to offer these discounts to get large outer business, and perhaps offer greater discounts to keep large order business, the Coffee Services Division of Solch Kopi-O could end up failing to achieve the needed profit to remain viable and grow. Obviously, the existing pricing approach was not generating the results that were sought. Could it be possible that there was something wrong in the entire approach to costing and pricing in this industry? En. Soleh wondered what he might do to make his firm competitive and still earn the desired profit levels in this business. Exhibit 1 SOLEH KOPI-O COST STRUCTURE-FOR THE COFFEE SERVICE DIVISION Kits of Roasted Coffee (27,777 kits x RM 18.00) Personnel Costs This covered the cost of salaries for all personnel (8 people) Equipment Costs This covered the cost of coffee brewing equipment and maintenance on the equipment Vehicle Costs This covered the depreciation and operating costs of all division vehicles Other Overhead Costs This covered all other divisional expenses not included in the above categories Total Costs NOTE: These data have been disguised to preserve confidentiality. RM 500,000 220,000 90,000 70,000 70,000 950,000 (b) Refer to En. Soleh's analysis of the two typical customers. In your opinion, what is the main problem with the existing costing and pricing approach used by En. Soleh? Explain. Plain TWO CUSTOMERS En. Soleh felt that something was wrong in the whole approach to costing and pricing in this industry. Using the comments he had read in Drucker's book, he began reviewing the manner in which his division, and indeed the whole industry, priced its coffee service. Using two typical customers, En. Soleh considered the implications of the existing procedure. The first customer was a small office complex in Ipoh. The customer generally ordered six kits of coffee every month. The office used a single brewing machine. Deliveries could only be made during regular working hours. The salesperson had quoted the price of the service at RM 44.42 per kit, to reflect the fact that the delivery was somewhat inconvenient and to incorporate a 23 per cent net profit margin on the business. This had been determined as follows: Cost of coffee 6 x RM 18.00 Operating Cost 6 x RM 16.20 Total Cost Selling Price with 23% Profit Selling Price per kit Customer Cost per cup RM 44.42/500 RM 108.00 97.20 205.20 266.52 44.42 RM 0.088 The second customer was much larger. It was a restaurant operation in downtown Penang. This client generally ordered 25 kits of roasted coffee per month. This customer operated a single brewing machine in the restaurant. The delivery was very easy because the restaurant was accustomed, and designed, to handle visits from suppliers. The pricing for this customer was as follows, with a net profit margin of 12 per cent in recognition of the higher volume purchased: Cost of coffee 25 x RM 18.00 Operating Cost 25 x RM 16.20 Total Cost Selling Price with 12% Profit Selling Price per kit Customer Cost per cup RM 38.86/500 RM 450.00 405.00 885.00 971.50 38.86 RM 0.078 The discount had been necessary to get this customer from a competitor. Unfortunately, the offering of the discount meant that this contract could not generate 15 per cent profit on sales. En. Solch was concerned that if his salespeople had to offer these discounts to get large outer business, and perhaps offer greater discounts to keep large order business, the Coffee Services Division of Solch Kopi-O could end up failing to achieve the needed profit to remain viable and grow. Obviously, the existing pricing approach was not generating the results that were sought. Could it be possible that there was something wrong in the entire approach to costing and pricing in this industry? En. Soleh wondered what he might do to make his firm competitive and still earn the desired profit levels in this business. Exhibit 1 SOLEH KOPI-O COST STRUCTURE-FOR THE COFFEE SERVICE DIVISION Kits of Roasted Coffee (27,777 kits x RM 18.00) Personnel Costs This covered the cost of salaries for all personnel (8 people) Equipment Costs This covered the cost of coffee brewing equipment and maintenance on the equipment Vehicle Costs This covered the depreciation and operating costs of all division vehicles Other Overhead Costs This covered all other divisional expenses not included in the above categories Total Costs NOTE: These data have been disguised to preserve confidentiality. RM 500,000 220,000 90,000 70,000 70,000 950,000 (b) Refer to En. Soleh's analysis of the two typical customers. In your opinion, what is the main problem with the existing costing and pricing approach used by En. Soleh? Explain. Plain
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Question Problems with present costing Currently traditional method of overhead allocation is used b... View the full answer
Related Book For
Physics
ISBN: 978-0077339685
2nd edition
Authors: Alan Giambattista, Betty Richardson, Robert Richardson
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these finance questions
-
Customers arrive at an automated coffee vending machine at a rate of 4 per minute, following a Poisson distribution. The coffee machine dispenses a cup of coffee at a constant rate of 10 seconds. (a)...
-
During its first month of operations, a business made purchases and sales as shown in the table below: All sales were made at £2 each. Required Calculate the profit for the month and the stock...
-
En Ramli retired optionally from government service on 28 February 2019, his 58 years birthday. He commenced employment with Tanjong Sdn Bhd on 1 April 2019 at a monthly salary of RM9,000. The...
-
On January 1, 2018, Rastall Co. signed a long-term finance lease for an office building. The terms of the lease required Rastall to pay $30,000 annually, beginning December 31, 2018, and continuing...
-
What causes customers to become dissatisfied?
-
Assume that the transactions listed in the first column of the table below are anticipated by U.S. firms that have no other foreign transactions. Place an X in the table wherever you see possible...
-
Plaintiff grounds manager sued a manufacturer, Monsanto, alleging that herbicide use caused his non-Hodgkins lymphoma. The jury awarded the plaintiff \($39.3\) million in compensatory damages and...
-
GroFast Company manufactures a high-quality fertilizer, which is used primarily by commercial vegetable growers. Two departments are involved in the production process. In the Mixing Department,...
-
Why are both ER Diagrams and Relational Modeling needed when a database system is developed?
-
Sukdev Basi funded an irrevocable simple trust in May 2008. The trust benefits Sukdev's son for life and grandson upon the son's death. One of the assets he transferred to the trust was Jetco stock,...
-
The probability that the economy will experience a recession next year is 0.3 while the probabilities of moderate growth or rapid expansion are 0.5 and 0.2 respectively. The common stock of firm A is...
-
You are required to make a choice among three alternatives for a distribution system for your firm. The first option involves investment of $30 billion to build a new distribution system costing $30...
-
1b) Who are the duty holders and their responsibilities (according to WHS Laws) in regard to implementing the organisation's WHSMS? 1c) Section 19(3)c of the WHS Act 2011 states a PCBU must provide...
-
A new network was set up with the Internet protocol (IP) range of 192.168.13.2-192.168.13.100. The internet service provider has set up a static IP address of 104.215.148.63. How are devices able to...
-
Narrative Techniques - Atwood uses a variety of narrative techniques in the telling of her story. Find an example of each of the following techniques in the novel. Technique Example 1st person...
-
A traffic engineer counted vehicles on Rt. 9 and found that, on average, a vehicle passes in front of her at a rate of every 5 seconds. If vehicles keep coming at this rate, what would be the...
-
How will the equilibrium price (P*) and equilibrium quantity (Q*) of strawberry ice-cream be affected if the price of chocolate ice-cream (a substitute) increases? O P* will decrease and Q* will...
-
The production budget of Artest Company calls for 80,000 units to be produced. If it takes 30 minutes to make one unit and the direct labor rate is $16 per hour, what is the total budgeted direct...
-
An automobile with a mass of 1600 kg has a speed of 30.0 m/s. What is its kinetic energy?
-
Two identical spheres are dropped into two different columns: one column contains a liquid of viscosity 0.5 Pas, while the other contains a liquid of the same density but unknown viscosity. The...
-
A large parallel plate capacitor has plate separation of 1.00 cm and plate area of 314 cm2. The capacitor is connected across an emf of 20.0 V and has air between the plates. With the emf still...
-
Consider a sample taken from the population of all taxi-in times for all flights that land in Los Angeles. Identify the symbols used for the sample standard deviation, the population standard...
-
An article in the New York Times noted that these new ZIP codes were created in New York City: 10065, 10021, 10075. Find the mean of these three numbers. What is fundamentally wrong with this result?
-
Shown below is a boxplot of a sample of 20 brain volumes (cm 3 ). What do the numbers in the boxplot represent? 963 1034.5 1079 1439 1188.5
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App