Esmeralda has been patronising a traditional cake stall called Auntie Agnes Cake Stall since her childhood....
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Esmeralda has been patronising a traditional cake stall called "Auntie Agnes Cake Stall" since her childhood. The owner and operator of the stall, Auntie Agnes, is able to recognise Esmeralda and would often ask about Esmeralda and her family every time she visited the stall. When Esmeralda heard that the stall would be closing for good as Auntie Agnes is retiring, she felt a great sense of loss for the 60-year old stall which is steeped in cultural heritage due to the traditional methods used in the making of the cakes. As Esmeralda had some previous experience operating a cafe, she decided that she would try to buy out the business from Auntie Agnes (including the lease of the premises and all associated intellectual property such as the branding and recipes) so as to preserve the cultural heritage of the stall. Subsequently, Esmeralda visited the stall, and spoke to Auntic Agnes about her intention to buy out the business. Esmeralda said, "Auntie Agnes, you think about it - instead of closing down, you can sell the business to me for $80,000. It's not a small amount of money, and will go a long way in supporting your retirement. Also, all your previous hard work in building up the business will continue to live on." Auntie Agnes initially expressed some reluctance at handing the business over to an outsider, but eventually agreed to consider what Esmeralda had said. Later in the week, on a Wednesday, Esmeralda received a WhatsApp message from Auntie Agnes at 3.00pm, which stated as follows: "Hi Esmeralda, I consulted with my daughter, and she says that I should ask for more than $100,000 for the business, including the lease at #01- 02, 170 Upper Bukit Timah Road and all associated intellectual property of the business." Esmeralda gave it some thought before replying (at 4.00pm on the same day), "Auntie Agnes, how about this - $90,000, but we need your help to train our newly hired staff for three months. Is this ok?" Auntie Agnes took some time to think about it, and replied to Esmeralda (at 5.00pm on the same day) with a simple "Okay". Esmeralda was very happy when she saw Auntie Agnes' message. After that WhatsApp exchange, Esmeralda spent the next few weeks negotiating the other details of the deal with Auntie Agnes. Around the same time, Esmeralda started to raise funds for the purchase of the business. After a month passed from the date of their WhatsApp exchange, Esmeralda and Auntie Agnes finally worked out all the details of the deal, which Esmeralda then typed onto a written document. When Esmeralda brought a copy of the document to the stall for Auntie Agnes to keep as a record, Auntie Agnes apologetically explained that she will no longer be able to train the new hires for the stall as she would be migrating to Germany very soon to be with her daughter's family. Esmeralda was very disappointed at hearing this, and responded that she would need to rethink the whole deal. Auntie Agnes expressed surprise at this statement, as she thought that everything has already been agreed between them. (a) Explain whether there is a valid contract between Auntie Agnes and Esmeralda for the sale of the business involving the cake stall. In your answer, you should identify and discuss the four (4) elements of a contract. (This means that you should also state and define the four elements of a contract, discuss the relevant legal rules associated with them, and apply the legal rules with reference to the facts and circumstances described in the scenario.) (65 marks) Esmeralda has been patronising a traditional cake stall called "Auntie Agnes Cake Stall" since her childhood. The owner and operator of the stall, Auntie Agnes, is able to recognise Esmeralda and would often ask about Esmeralda and her family every time she visited the stall. When Esmeralda heard that the stall would be closing for good as Auntie Agnes is retiring, she felt a great sense of loss for the 60-year old stall which is steeped in cultural heritage due to the traditional methods used in the making of the cakes. As Esmeralda had some previous experience operating a cafe, she decided that she would try to buy out the business from Auntie Agnes (including the lease of the premises and all associated intellectual property such as the branding and recipes) so as to preserve the cultural heritage of the stall. Subsequently, Esmeralda visited the stall, and spoke to Auntic Agnes about her intention to buy out the business. Esmeralda said, "Auntie Agnes, you think about it - instead of closing down, you can sell the business to me for $80,000. It's not a small amount of money, and will go a long way in supporting your retirement. Also, all your previous hard work in building up the business will continue to live on." Auntie Agnes initially expressed some reluctance at handing the business over to an outsider, but eventually agreed to consider what Esmeralda had said. Later in the week, on a Wednesday, Esmeralda received a WhatsApp message from Auntie Agnes at 3.00pm, which stated as follows: "Hi Esmeralda, I consulted with my daughter, and she says that I should ask for more than $100,000 for the business, including the lease at #01- 02, 170 Upper Bukit Timah Road and all associated intellectual property of the business." Esmeralda gave it some thought before replying (at 4.00pm on the same day), "Auntie Agnes, how about this - $90,000, but we need your help to train our newly hired staff for three months. Is this ok?" Auntie Agnes took some time to think about it, and replied to Esmeralda (at 5.00pm on the same day) with a simple "Okay". Esmeralda was very happy when she saw Auntie Agnes' message. After that WhatsApp exchange, Esmeralda spent the next few weeks negotiating the other details of the deal with Auntie Agnes. Around the same time, Esmeralda started to raise funds for the purchase of the business. After a month passed from the date of their WhatsApp exchange, Esmeralda and Auntie Agnes finally worked out all the details of the deal, which Esmeralda then typed onto a written document. When Esmeralda brought a copy of the document to the stall for Auntie Agnes to keep as a record, Auntie Agnes apologetically explained that she will no longer be able to train the new hires for the stall as she would be migrating to Germany very soon to be with her daughter's family. Esmeralda was very disappointed at hearing this, and responded that she would need to rethink the whole deal. Auntie Agnes expressed surprise at this statement, as she thought that everything has already been agreed between them. (a) Explain whether there is a valid contract between Auntie Agnes and Esmeralda for the sale of the business involving the cake stall. In your answer, you should identify and discuss the four (4) elements of a contract. (This means that you should also state and define the four elements of a contract, discuss the relevant legal rules associated with them, and apply the legal rules with reference to the facts and circumstances described in the scenario.) (65 marks)
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
To determine whether there is a valid contract between Auntie Agnes and Esmeralda for the sale of the business involving the cake stall we need to analyze the four essential elements of a contract off... View the full answer
Related Book For
Managerial Accounting
ISBN: 978-1337270595
14th edition
Authors: Carl S. Warren, James M. Reeve, Jonathan Duchac
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
Planning is one of the most important management functions in any business. A front office managers first step in planning should involve determine the departments goals. Planning also includes...
-
The Crazy Eddie fraud may appear smaller and gentler than the massive billion-dollar frauds exposed in recent times, such as Bernie Madoffs Ponzi scheme, frauds in the subprime mortgage market, the...
-
Read the case study "Southwest Airlines," found in Part 2 of your textbook. Review the "Guide to Case Analysis" found on pp. CA1 - CA11 of your textbook. (This guide follows the last case in the...
-
To load and register a JDBC driver, two popular methods can be used: either using the Class.forName() method or creating a new instance of the Driver class.(True/False)
-
An ideal-gas mixture consists of 2 kmol of N2 and 4 kmol of CO2. The apparent gas constant of the mixture is (a) 0.215 kJ/kg = K (b) 0.225 kJ/kg - K (c) 0.243 kJ/kg - K (d) 0.875 kJ/kg = K (e) 1.24...
-
DOT Audit Report and Transmittal Letter. The following excerpt is from the Inspector Generals transmittal letter to the Secretary of the Department of Transportation (DOT). Required a. Explain the...
-
Cotton, Corp., uses the allowance method to account for uncollectible accounts. On May 31,2010, Allowance for Uncollectible Accounts has a $1,300 credit bal ance. Journalize the year-end adjusting...
-
The ledger of Witzling, Inc. on March 31, 2012, includes the following selected accounts before adjusting entries. An analysis of the accounts shows the following:1. Insurance expires at the rate of...
-
The Sindh Engineering Company produces a bicycle which sells at Rs.1,000 per unit. At 80% capacity utilization which is the normal level of activity, the sales are Rs.180 million. Costs are as under:...
-
The Economic Order Quantity (EOQ) model is a classical model used for controlling inventory and satisfying demand. Costs included in the model are holding cost per unit, ordering cost and the cost of...
-
Due today How will you graphically represent expenditure in different departments ? A. Column Chart B. Line Chart C. Pie Chart D. Dot Chart
-
A manufacturer claims that the average tar content of a certain kind of cigarette is \(\mu=14.0\). In an attempt to show that it differs from this value, five measurements are made of the tar content...
-
A random sample of 6 steel beams has a mean compressive strength of 58,392 psi (pounds per square inch) with a standard deviation of 648 psi. Use this information and the level of significance...
-
The statistical program MINITAB will calculate \(t\) tests. With the nanopillar height data in \(\mathrm{C} 1\), You must compare your preselected \(\alpha\) with the printed \(P\)-value in order to...
-
Referring to Exercise 7.82 and using 14,380 as an estimate of \(\sigma\), find the sample size that would have been needed to be able to assert with \(95 \%\) confidence that the sample mean is off...
-
In a fatigue study, the time spent working by employees in a factory was observed. The ten readings (in hours) were \[\begin{array}{llllllllll}4.8 & 3.6 & 10.8 & 5.7 & 8.2 & 6.8 & 7.5 & 7.7 & 6.3 &...
-
George and Barbara own a pharmacy together. At the end of the financial year, George decides to get rid of the surplus stock with a big sale. George advertised in the pharmacy window the exclusive...
-
After Theorem 1.5 we note that multiplying a row by 0 is not allowed because that could change a solution set. Give an example of a system with solution set S0 where after multiplying a row by 0 the...
-
The actual variable cost of goods sold for a product was $140 per unit, while the planned variable cost of goods sold was $136 per unit. The volume increased by 2,400 units to 14,000 actual total...
-
The management of Firebolt Industries Inc. manufactures gasoline and diesel engines through two production departments, Fabrication and Assembly. Management needs accurate product cost information in...
-
The financial statements for Nike, Inc., are presented in Appendix E at the end of the text. The following additional information is available (in thousands): Accounts receivable at May 31, 2013...
-
Marsha Solomon, a physiotherapist, opened a practice. The business completed the following transactions: After these transactions, how much cash does the business have to work with? Use T-accounts to...
-
Refer to Exercise 2-3. Which of the transactions of Marsha Solomon, P.T., increased the total assets of the business? For each transaction, identify the asset that was increased or decreased....
-
Assume that Lululemon Athletica Inc. reported the following summarized data at December 31, 2020. Accounts appear in no particular order; dollar amounts are in millions. Prepare the trial balance of...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App