Excelsior Management Co., a prominent hedge fund manager pursuing an event-driven strategy, charges a management fee of
Question:
Excelsior Management Co., a prominent hedge fund manager pursuing an event-driven
strategy, charges a management fee of 1.5% per annum and an incentive fee of 15% on any
"net new profits" (i.e., above the previous high water mark) earned by its fund after deducting
this management fee. All fees are charged and collected at the end of each year.
Over the past three years, the Fund generated the following gross returns (i.e., prior to any
fees being charged):
Year 1 +20%
Year 2 -10%
Year 3 +5%
After the technology stock bubble burst in 2000, some hedge fund managers attempted to
convince their investors to accept a "modified" incentive fee arrangement whereby they
would charge an incentive fee at half the rate of the full incentive fee on profits earned by
the Fund in any year in which it failed to surpass its previous high water mark, but that
lower incentive fee would stay in force until the Fund earned enough to return investors to
the point at which they would have been had the original arrangement been in place.
These managers argued they needed some incentive fee during these "catch-up" years in
order to have cash on hand to pay employees' bonuses and cover other ongoing expenses.
If Excelsior charged this modified incentive fee formula, what would have been the
effective annualized net return of its fund over this three-year period?
Auditing An International Approach
ISBN: 978-1259087462
7th edition
Authors: Wally J. Smieliauskas, Kathryn Bewley