As the ASNG (AS Natural Gas) Audit Committee Chair, I am charged with reviewing four bids...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
As the ASNG (AS Natural Gas) Audit Committee Chair, I am charged with reviewing four bids submitted by four CPA firms to perform ASNG's first financial statement audit. BACKGROUND: Based on our class discussion what factors would you use to choose a CPA firm for the annual audit of ASNG's financial statements? Use the guidance provided by SAS 114 or AU Section 380. The Potential Client: AS Nasty Gas (ASNG) is a natural gas distribution company located in AnyMetroArea, AS. It is a wholly owned subsidiary of Big Energy Company, a diversified public traded company located in Sate Capital, AS. Before the current year, ASNG did not produce its own financial statements. Instead its financial statements were consolidated into those of Big Energy. However, now ASNG wishes to issue its own debt and so must issue its own financial statements. Hence, ASNG is interviewing several audit firms to conduct the first ever annual audit of ASNG' financial statements. ASNG has $750,000,000 in annual revenue and net income of $50,000,000. It has 400,000 customers. Formally, ASNG was an operating division of Very Expensive Electric Company and was formed into its own company five years ago. A natural gas distribution company is regulated by the State Corporation Commission. However, natural gas is not regulated at the well head. It is regulated at the transmission line. ASNG has its own officers and a board of directors composed of the Chair of the Board of Big Energy Company, The CEO and CFO of ASNG, and five outside directors (mostly local business people). The five outside directors are considered independent directors and financially competent for SoX purposes. The audit committee is composed of three of these outside directors. The audit committee meets regularly four times a year. ASNG's CEO, CFO and Internal Auditor all attend the audit committee meetings. The Directors meet separately and alone with the Chief Audit Executive at the end of each meeting. The Audit Firms and Their Offers: WaterhouseArthurLybrand (WAL)- A Big Four Firm that does the annual audit of Big Energy Company. Initially, they assumed they would do the annual audit of ASNG. They told the ASNG CFO that they would be happy to do the ASNG Audit for $50,000. Now faced with competition, WAL has put in a bid of $35,000. Their bid for extra work includes a Partner Rate of $300, a Manager Rate of $200, and a staff rate of $100. WAL has an impressi distribution companies. list of clients in the public utility sector but not many natural gas ToucheDelloite (TD) – A Big Four Firm that has an impressive list of natural gas distribution clients. TD have put in a bid of $50,000. Their bid for extra work includes a Partner Rate of $350, a Manager Rate of $250, and a staff rate of $100. Arthur Whinnev (AW) - A Big Four Firm that has an impressive list of Fortune 500 clients including diversified energy companies like Big Energy. AW have put in a bid of $75,000. Their bid for extra work included a Partner Rate of $400, a Manager Rate of $300, and a staff rate of $200. Lincoln, Grant, Sherman and Sheridan (LGSS) – A large regional firm, primarily located in the South has an impressive list of publicly traded clients primarily in the banking sector. The firm entered the Tidewater area by purchasing a very successful old local firm. The partners from this firm have many contacts in the community and especially the local banking community. They put in a bid of $30,000 with extra work proposed at a Partner Rate of $200, a Manager Rate of $150, and a Staff Rate of $75. Some important issues to cover: Corporate Governance as opposed to Management The role of the Board of Directors The role of the Audit Committee of the Board of Directors The Blue Ribbon Commission on Audit Committees SOX Requirements of Audit Committees Who should hire the company's CPA firm? What factors would you use to choose a CPA firm? What issues should be covered in the engagement letter? What communications should take place between predecessor and successor auditors? What issues should be discussed between the CPA firm and its clients audit committee? Any additional issues? As the ASNG (AS Natural Gas) Audit Committee Chair, I am charged with reviewing four bids submitted by four CPA firms to perform ASNG's first financial statement audit. BACKGROUND: Based on our class discussion what factors would you use to choose a CPA firm for the annual audit of ASNG's financial statements? Use the guidance provided by SAS 114 or AU Section 380. The Potential Client: AS Nasty Gas (ASNG) is a natural gas distribution company located in AnyMetroArea, AS. It is a wholly owned subsidiary of Big Energy Company, a diversified public traded company located in Sate Capital, AS. Before the current year, ASNG did not produce its own financial statements. Instead its financial statements were consolidated into those of Big Energy. However, now ASNG wishes to issue its own debt and so must issue its own financial statements. Hence, ASNG is interviewing several audit firms to conduct the first ever annual audit of ASNG' financial statements. ASNG has $750,000,000 in annual revenue and net income of $50,000,000. It has 400,000 customers. Formally, ASNG was an operating division of Very Expensive Electric Company and was formed into its own company five years ago. A natural gas distribution company is regulated by the State Corporation Commission. However, natural gas is not regulated at the well head. It is regulated at the transmission line. ASNG has its own officers and a board of directors composed of the Chair of the Board of Big Energy Company, The CEO and CFO of ASNG, and five outside directors (mostly local business people). The five outside directors are considered independent directors and financially competent for SoX purposes. The audit committee is composed of three of these outside directors. The audit committee meets regularly four times a year. ASNG's CEO, CFO and Internal Auditor all attend the audit committee meetings. The Directors meet separately and alone with the Chief Audit Executive at the end of each meeting. The Audit Firms and Their Offers: WaterhouseArthurLybrand (WAL)- A Big Four Firm that does the annual audit of Big Energy Company. Initially, they assumed they would do the annual audit of ASNG. They told the ASNG CFO that they would be happy to do the ASNG Audit for $50,000. Now faced with competition, WAL has put in a bid of $35,000. Their bid for extra work includes a Partner Rate of $300, a Manager Rate of $200, and a staff rate of $100. WAL has an impressi distribution companies. list of clients in the public utility sector but not many natural gas ToucheDelloite (TD) – A Big Four Firm that has an impressive list of natural gas distribution clients. TD have put in a bid of $50,000. Their bid for extra work includes a Partner Rate of $350, a Manager Rate of $250, and a staff rate of $100. Arthur Whinnev (AW) - A Big Four Firm that has an impressive list of Fortune 500 clients including diversified energy companies like Big Energy. AW have put in a bid of $75,000. Their bid for extra work included a Partner Rate of $400, a Manager Rate of $300, and a staff rate of $200. Lincoln, Grant, Sherman and Sheridan (LGSS) – A large regional firm, primarily located in the South has an impressive list of publicly traded clients primarily in the banking sector. The firm entered the Tidewater area by purchasing a very successful old local firm. The partners from this firm have many contacts in the community and especially the local banking community. They put in a bid of $30,000 with extra work proposed at a Partner Rate of $200, a Manager Rate of $150, and a Staff Rate of $75. Some important issues to cover: Corporate Governance as opposed to Management The role of the Board of Directors The role of the Audit Committee of the Board of Directors The Blue Ribbon Commission on Audit Committees SOX Requirements of Audit Committees Who should hire the company's CPA firm? What factors would you use to choose a CPA firm? What issues should be covered in the engagement letter? What communications should take place between predecessor and successor auditors? What issues should be discussed between the CPA firm and its clients audit committee? Any additional issues?
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Answer Why hire a Certified Public Accountant Hiring new staff can impact your existing team and you... View the full answer
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
What factors would you consider in deciding whether to use direct labor dollars or direct labor hours in charging overhead to jobs in a service firm?
-
As an investor, what factors would you consider before investing in the emerging stock market of a developing country?
-
What factors would you take into account in deciding whether to split a job?
-
Suppose a product can be produced using virgin ore at a marginal cost given by MC 1 = 0. 5q 1 and with recycled materials at a marginal cost given by MC 2 = 5 + 0. 1q 2 . (a) If the inverse demand...
-
1. Define the problem and develop a list of research objectives. 2. Write the research objective for one of your problems defined in your answer to the first question.
-
You are valuing the Vancouver Rain-Making Company (VRM) and need to calculate the following: a. Required rate of return b. Price of VRM based on the current dividend of $1.25 and a dividend growth...
-
What are the main objectives of an international compensation plan? Would an integrated solution or a best-of-breed solution make more sense for a large manufacturing corporation? Do you believe that...
-
Entre Preneur found a site for his new haute cuisine restaurant. The site has a vacant gasoline station. He purchased the property for $ 900,000 and had the station demolished at a cost of $ 30,000....
-
In the accompanying diagram, PA is tangent to circle O at A. If CB = 21 and PB = 4, what is the length of PA? 0. A P B C
-
Allison, age 40, earns $81,915 annually; her wage replacement ratio has been determined to be 73%. She expects inflation will average 3% over her entire life expectancy. She expects to work until 67...
-
In its most recent year, HiFlyer Plc's return on capital was 50% on the reported invested capital of $2 billion. An analyst decides to treat Research and Development expenditure as capital...
-
What is an action standard? How might defining action standards lead to better results?
-
Discuss the pros and cons of diversification as a rationale for mergers.
-
Explain how to calculate the adjustments required to update an allowance for doubtful debts at the end of a reporting period.
-
Suppose a U.S. firm must pay 200 million Swiss francs to a Swiss firm in 90 days. Briefly explain how the firm would use forward exchange rates to lock in the price of the payable due in 90 days.
-
Explain why it is imperative to measure the correct construct? What could go wrong if the correct constructs are not used in a research project?
-
For the beam and loading shown in Figure 4, knowing that a = 2m, co = 100kN/m and E = 200 GPa. Determine a) the slope at support A b) the deflection at point C Use Method of Integration. Express your...
-
From 1970 to 1990, Sri Lanka's population grew by approximately 2.2 million persons every five years. The population in 1970 was 12.2 million people.What is the best formula for P, Sri Lanka's...
-
Who was Phar-Mors flamboyant Chief Executive Officer?
-
Which of the following generally is not considered something of value? 1. Cash, money or checks 2. Airline miles or hotel credits associated with frequent activity (e.g., frequent flier miles) 3. An...
-
Which of the following is not one of the five major categories of fraudulent disbursements? 1. Payroll schemes 2. Expense reimbursement schemes 3. Shell company schemes 4. Billing schemes
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App