CASE 1 Mary applied for a job at the Millstone Restaurant. She was told her uniform...

 

Transcribed Image Text:

CASE 1 Mary applied for a job at the Millstone Restaurant. She was told her uniform would be a white blouse and black skirt, with a hem an inch above the knee. She agreed, but when she started work, she realized that female staff was dressed accordingly, but the men wore white shirts and black pants. At a later date, Mary appeared at work also dressed in a white shirt and black pants. The manager of the restaurant told her she was "out of uniform," words were exchanged, and Mary was fired. Is there a Charter issue here? Discuss. CASE 2 FM 96 Tiger Radio wanted to set up a three-day live-remote event in a provincial park for the Labour Day weekend. The provincial parks commission approved the plan, subject to a payment of $4,100, comprised of a park event permit ($1,000), a sanitation charge ($1,000), a broadcasting permit ($500), a beer/wine premises special occasion permit ($1,500), and a fire inspection fee for the beer/wine consumption premises ($100). How should FM 96 respond to the provincial commission? CASE 3 In the year 1555, Maxwell was drunk, lost control of his horse and killed a child. He was executed for his crime. In the year 1955, Sharon was sober, lost control of her car and killed a child. She was given a suspended sentence and ordered to pay a $100 fine. In the year 2005, Karl was drunk, lost control of his car and killed a child. He was given one year imprisonment, a $1,000 fine and is subject to a lifetime licence suspension. In what way is the principle of stare decisis at work here, if at all? CASE 1 Mary applied for a job at the Millstone Restaurant. She was told her uniform would be a white blouse and black skirt, with a hem an inch above the knee. She agreed, but when she started work, she realized that female staff was dressed accordingly, but the men wore white shirts and black pants. At a later date, Mary appeared at work also dressed in a white shirt and black pants. The manager of the restaurant told her she was "out of uniform," words were exchanged, and Mary was fired. Is there a Charter issue here? Discuss. CASE 2 FM 96 Tiger Radio wanted to set up a three-day live-remote event in a provincial park for the Labour Day weekend. The provincial parks commission approved the plan, subject to a payment of $4,100, comprised of a park event permit ($1,000), a sanitation charge ($1,000), a broadcasting permit ($500), a beer/wine premises special occasion permit ($1,500), and a fire inspection fee for the beer/wine consumption premises ($100). How should FM 96 respond to the provincial commission? CASE 3 In the year 1555, Maxwell was drunk, lost control of his horse and killed a child. He was executed for his crime. In the year 1955, Sharon was sober, lost control of her car and killed a child. She was given a suspended sentence and ordered to pay a $100 fine. In the year 2005, Karl was drunk, lost control of his car and killed a child. He was given one year imprisonment, a $1,000 fine and is subject to a lifetime licence suspension. In what way is the principle of stare decisis at work here, if at all?

Answer rating: 100% (QA)

CASE 1 While a differential in dress prerequisites could conceivably be a case of unreasonableness u... View the full answer