For this week's discussion, we are looking at the Case Analysis on page 56: How Westland/Hallmark Put
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
For this week's discussion, we are looking at the Case Analysis on page 56: How Westland/Hallmark Put Profit above Safety
After Reading the case, please answer the 2 Discussion Questions
- In your opinion, why did the managers and employees of the meal packing plant behave in the way they did?
Transcribed Image Text:
56 2. Using information on the company's website, draw a picture of its hierarchy of authority. Try to identify the members of the top-management team. Is the CEO also the chair of the board of directors? 3. Does the company have divisional managers? What functional managers kinds of issues does it raise in this statement? be most important to the organization in achieving a competitive advantage? What is the functional background of the top-management team? 4. Does the organization have a published code of ethics or ethical stance? What 5. Search for information about your organization concerning the ethical or unethi- cal behavior of its managers. What does this tell you about its ethical stance? PART 1 THE ORGANIZATION AND ITS ENVIRONMENT How Westland/Hallmark Put Profit above Safety By all appearances the Westland/Hallmark Meat Co., based in Chico, California, and owned by its CEO Steven Mendell, was one the most efficient, sanitary, and state-of- the-art meatpacking plants in the United States. The meat- packing plant, which regularly passed inspections by the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA), employed over 200 workers who slaughtered and then prepared the beef for shipment to fast-food restaurants such as Burger King and Taco Bell. Most of the millions of pounds of meat the plant prepared yearly, however, were delivered under con- tract to one of the federal government's most coveted ac- counts: the National School Lunch Program, which named the plant supplier of the year in 2005.41 So at the end of 2007 when the Humane Society turned over a videotape, secretly filmed by one of its investigators who had taken a job as a plant employee, to the San Bernardino County district attorney that showed major vi- olations of safety procedures, it caused an uproar. The videotape showed two workers dragging sick cows up the ramp that led to the slaughterhouse using metal chains and forklifts, shocking them with electric prods, and shoot- ing streams of water in their noses and faces. Not only did the tape show inhumane treatment of animals, it also pro- vided evidence that the company was flaunting the ban on allowing sick animals to enter the food supply chain, something that federal regulations explicitly outlawed for fear of human health and disease issues. CASE FOR ANALYSIS seem By 2008, the USDA, concerned that contaminated beef had entered the supply chain, especially the one leading to the nation's schools, issued a notice for the recall of 143 mil- lion pounds of beef processed in the plant over the last two years, the largest recall in history. In addition, the plant was shut down as the investigation proceeded. In 2008, when CEO Steven Mendell was subpoenaed to appear before the House Panel Energy and Commerce Committee, he denied these violations had taken place and that any diseased cows had entered the food chain. When panel members demanded that he view the videotape, he claimed he had not seen it, to acknowledge that "two cows" had in fact entered the plant and that inhumane treatment of animals had taken place.4 Moreover, federal investigators turned up evidence that as early as 1996 the plant has been cited for overuse of electric prods to speed cattle through the plant and had been cited for other violations since, suggesting these abuses had been going on for a long period. This view gained strength when one of the workers shown in the videotape claimed that supervisors were pressuring work- ers to ensure 500 cows a day were slaughtered and processed so the plant could meet its quota and make the high profits the meatpacking business provides and that he and other workers had no say in the matter: They were just "following orders from the supervisor. These unethical and illegal work practices led investiga- tors to fear that over the years, thousands of sick cows had been allowed to enter the food chain. Most of the 143 million pounds of beef recalled had already been consumed anyway. Not only customers, and especially schoolchildren, have been harmed by the company's illegal actions, however. It seems likely that the plant will be permanently shut down and all 220 workers will lose their jobs. Indeed, the employees directly implicated by the video have already been prosecuted and one, who pleaded guilty to animal abuse, was convicted and sentenced to six months of imprisonment in 2008.43 Whether or not the company's managers will experi- ence the same fate remains to be seen, but clearly all stake- holders have been hurt by the unethical, inhumane, and ille- gal actions by managers that, as the Humane Society had suspected for years, were commonplace in the plant. n to - Discussion Questions 1. In your opinion, why did the managers and em- ployees of the meat packing plant behave in the way they did? 2. Outline a series of steps the plant's managers should have taken to prevent this problem from occurring. 56 2. Using information on the company's website, draw a picture of its hierarchy of authority. Try to identify the members of the top-management team. Is the CEO also the chair of the board of directors? 3. Does the company have divisional managers? What functional managers kinds of issues does it raise in this statement? be most important to the organization in achieving a competitive advantage? What is the functional background of the top-management team? 4. Does the organization have a published code of ethics or ethical stance? What 5. Search for information about your organization concerning the ethical or unethi- cal behavior of its managers. What does this tell you about its ethical stance? PART 1 THE ORGANIZATION AND ITS ENVIRONMENT How Westland/Hallmark Put Profit above Safety By all appearances the Westland/Hallmark Meat Co., based in Chico, California, and owned by its CEO Steven Mendell, was one the most efficient, sanitary, and state-of- the-art meatpacking plants in the United States. The meat- packing plant, which regularly passed inspections by the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA), employed over 200 workers who slaughtered and then prepared the beef for shipment to fast-food restaurants such as Burger King and Taco Bell. Most of the millions of pounds of meat the plant prepared yearly, however, were delivered under con- tract to one of the federal government's most coveted ac- counts: the National School Lunch Program, which named the plant supplier of the year in 2005.41 So at the end of 2007 when the Humane Society turned over a videotape, secretly filmed by one of its investigators who had taken a job as a plant employee, to the San Bernardino County district attorney that showed major vi- olations of safety procedures, it caused an uproar. The videotape showed two workers dragging sick cows up the ramp that led to the slaughterhouse using metal chains and forklifts, shocking them with electric prods, and shoot- ing streams of water in their noses and faces. Not only did the tape show inhumane treatment of animals, it also pro- vided evidence that the company was flaunting the ban on allowing sick animals to enter the food supply chain, something that federal regulations explicitly outlawed for fear of human health and disease issues. CASE FOR ANALYSIS seem By 2008, the USDA, concerned that contaminated beef had entered the supply chain, especially the one leading to the nation's schools, issued a notice for the recall of 143 mil- lion pounds of beef processed in the plant over the last two years, the largest recall in history. In addition, the plant was shut down as the investigation proceeded. In 2008, when CEO Steven Mendell was subpoenaed to appear before the House Panel Energy and Commerce Committee, he denied these violations had taken place and that any diseased cows had entered the food chain. When panel members demanded that he view the videotape, he claimed he had not seen it, to acknowledge that "two cows" had in fact entered the plant and that inhumane treatment of animals had taken place.4 Moreover, federal investigators turned up evidence that as early as 1996 the plant has been cited for overuse of electric prods to speed cattle through the plant and had been cited for other violations since, suggesting these abuses had been going on for a long period. This view gained strength when one of the workers shown in the videotape claimed that supervisors were pressuring work- ers to ensure 500 cows a day were slaughtered and processed so the plant could meet its quota and make the high profits the meatpacking business provides and that he and other workers had no say in the matter: They were just "following orders from the supervisor. These unethical and illegal work practices led investiga- tors to fear that over the years, thousands of sick cows had been allowed to enter the food chain. Most of the 143 million pounds of beef recalled had already been consumed anyway. Not only customers, and especially schoolchildren, have been harmed by the company's illegal actions, however. It seems likely that the plant will be permanently shut down and all 220 workers will lose their jobs. Indeed, the employees directly implicated by the video have already been prosecuted and one, who pleaded guilty to animal abuse, was convicted and sentenced to six months of imprisonment in 2008.43 Whether or not the company's managers will experi- ence the same fate remains to be seen, but clearly all stake- holders have been hurt by the unethical, inhumane, and ille- gal actions by managers that, as the Humane Society had suspected for years, were commonplace in the plant. n to - Discussion Questions 1. In your opinion, why did the managers and em- ployees of the meat packing plant behave in the way they did? 2. Outline a series of steps the plant's managers should have taken to prevent this problem from occurring.
Expert Answer:
Related Book For
An Introduction To Statistical Methods And Data Analysis
ISBN: 9781305465527
7th Edition
Authors: R. Lyman Ott, Micheal T. Longnecker
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these general management questions
-
Planning is one of the most important management functions in any business. A front office managers first step in planning should involve determine the departments goals. Planning also includes...
-
Read the case study "Southwest Airlines," found in Part 2 of your textbook. Review the "Guide to Case Analysis" found on pp. CA1 - CA11 of your textbook. (This guide follows the last case in the...
-
Abhishek Ltd. is manufacturing cotton clothes. It has been consistently earning good profits for many years. This year too, it has been able to generate enough profits. There is availability of...
-
Consider the following matter with the perspective of Human resource management 1) Discuss the role and importance of HR Policy in strategy. 2) Identify one HR challenge you face either personally or...
-
Routine road maintenance can be done at intervals of 1, 2, 3, 4, or 5 years, but the longer the interval, the higher the cost. Maintenance costs per mile are estimated as $80,000, $170,000, $285,000,...
-
11 P 2 Perform the indicated calculation.
-
Howrley-David, Inc., manufactures two models of motorcycles: the Fatboy and the Screamer. Both models are assembled in the same plant and require the same assembling operations. The difference...
-
Question 1: Assume the following: Units / year = 10 = Tenure new builder Business and technical skills = New builder / Average skill Financial = High risk o Ignore the equity calculations. Carry out...
-
Atlantic Airlines issued $100 million in bonds in 2008. Because of the firm's low credit rating (B3), the bonds were considered to be junk bonds. At the time of issue, the 20 year bonds were paying a...
-
Golf Python code (Assignment repost due to incorrect code!) Below is the newest code because the previous had some indentation issues but this one is still having the same syntax issue on line 7...
-
ABC Optical began 20X1 with accounts receivable of \(\$ 44800\) and inventory of \(\$ 56000\). During \(20 \mathrm{X} 1\) the business made total net sales of \(\$ 840000\), of which 70 per cent were...
-
Among other items, the Andy's Business' income statement for the year shows sales revenue of \(\$ 156000\), cost of goods sold of \(\$ 92600\) and salaries expense of \(\$ 24400\). An analysis of its...
-
A friend of yours makes this statement: 'Accumulated depreciation and depreciation expense are the same thing, since they both measure the portion of the cost of an asset that has been 'used up' to...
-
Which of the following statements, often made by prospects, would you interpret as buying signals? a. How much would the payments be? b. Tell me about your service department. c. Our company already...
-
Pete Pole has just discontinued its lowest line of high-quality clotheslines. In its inventory, Pete has 60000 lines that cost \(\$ 40\) per line to manufacture. At the current selling price of \(\$...
-
You plan to buy a property five years from today You estimate you will need save $100,000 for a deposit. To achieve this target you would like to plan to direct equal annual payments into your...
-
Before the 1973 oil embargo and subsequent increases in the price of crude oil, gasoline usage in the United States had grown at a seasonally adjusted rate of 0.57 percent per month, with a standard...
-
A university in a large urban area is having a major problem with traffic congestion. A study was funded to determine the volume of traffic on campus streets by cars that are not associated with...
-
A large advertising firm specializes in creating television commercials for childrens products. The firm wants to design a study to investigate factors that may affect the lengths of time a...
-
Refer to Exercise 11.40. Conduct a test for lack of fit of the linear regression model. In exercise Dose level Response 73 101 15,17 20,21,19 23,29 28,31,30 16 32 64
-
The United States brought a lawsuit requesting forfeiture of a \($38.5\) million jet purchased by Teodoro Nguema Obiang Mangue (Nguema) because the government believed the jet had been purchased with...
-
Jose Medellin participated in the rape and murder of two teenage girls in Houston, Texas. He was arrested and read his Miranda rights, and he confessed. At the time, he was not informed that he could...
-
OBB Personenverkehr (OBB), the Austrian state-owned railway, carries about 235 million passengers a year on routes within wholly owned by OBB Holding Group, which in turn, is wholly owned by the...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App