From the seven principles of supply chain management by david L anderson

Methodological Critique (overview of the approach to justify their principles for supply chain management, refer to particular principles as examples of this approach)

Is the approach taken by the writers conceptual (theory) or empirical (experience)?

If empirical: (experience)

a. What type of methodology was used?

b. Criticism of the methodology?

How does this article compare to other scm?

c. What could the authors have done differently?