Question: Hello, I need help with the following question. A two page position paper for the issue outlined below. So please make sure that the position

Hello, I need help with the following question. A two page position paper for the issue outlined below. So please make sure that the position paper is least two pages for the issue stated below. Your writing can be arguing for either position, for or against. Your score will be determined by how persuasive you are in your analysis, how well you demonstrate your understanding of the particular issues and how clearly your arguments are presented. A brief position paper as if you were submitting written submission for a debate on the topic either supporting or opposing the question, and providing as compelling an argument as possible to support the position that you adopt.

Issue 1: Extension of Liability to Taverns/Servers for Over-Serving Patrons

Background: Canadian tort law has recently evolved to the point where it is placing an affirmative legal obligation on licensed restaurants, taverns and even individual servers to make sure that its patrons don't drink and drive. This has been extended now to ensuring that drunk patrons get safely into cabs and don't pass out and freeze outside in the cold Alberta winters. Failure to comply with this standard essentially is making businesses and servers liable for the bad decisions of others. Even the drunk people have been receiving awards despite the fact that they chose to get drunk. Proponents of this legal development argue that this is the only way to make sure that drunk people don't continue to kill innocent bystanders through drunk driving. Opponents of this legal development argue that this is unfairly placing too much onus and legal risk on small businesses, and eliminating the obligation on the drinkers themselves to exercise proper judgment.

The Question: BE IT RESOLVED that law in Alberta be statutorily reformed to limit the trend of imposing liability for restaurants, taverns and individual servers for all bad decisions made by their drunk patrons, and limit liability to situations where the businesses and servers are guilty of gross negligence in clearly over-serving patrons that they know are in imminent danger to themselves or to others.

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

1 Expert Approved Answer
Step: 1 Unlock blur-text-image
Question Has Been Solved by an Expert!

Get step-by-step solutions from verified subject matter experts

Step: 2 Unlock
Step: 3 Unlock

Students Have Also Explored These Related Law Questions!