How should we evaluate TGT compared to Canadian Tire in analyzing their BF P/E ratios from...

Transcribed Image Text:

How should we evaluate TGT compared to Canadian Tire in analyzing their BF P/E ratios from a relative value and historical average perspective? TGT has a lower P/E multiple, but it is trading at a larger historical premium than it usually does so it is considered relatively overvalued when evaluating its P/E premium/discount level from a historical perspective. Canadian Tire has a lower P/E multiple, but it is trading at a smaller historical discount than it usually does, so it is considered relatively overvalued when evaluating its P/E premium/discount level from a historical perspective. Canadian Tire has a lower P/E multiple, and it is trading at a larger historical premium than it usually does, so it is considered relatively undervalued when evaluating its P/E premium/discount level from a historical perspective. Metric BF P/E Name Peer Group Average Peers Benchmarked Against Group Average Current Current vs 2Y Average Historical Premium Metric Prem Hist Avg Diff #SD 3M Trend 19.9x 3M 6M 1Y 2Y 5Y 2Y Historical Premium Range Low Range High Current Hist Avg 1) Dollar General Corp 2 Dollar Tree Inc 3) Target Corp 4 Five Below Inc 13.1x -34% -13% 15.7x -21% -11% 13.3x -33% -26% 24.0x 21% -21% -2.6 -34% 5% -10% -1.3 -39% 4% -7% -1.3 -37% -12% 37% -16% -1.0 1% 64% 5) Canadian Tire Corp Ltd 9.5x -52% -56% 49% 1.0 -63% -49% BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings I 18.2x -9% -15% 7% 1.1 -29% -2% 7) Costco Wholesale Corp 36.0x 81% 65% 16% Dollarama Inc 25.6x 29% 18% 11% 9 Walmart Inc 23.5x 18% 1% 18% 10) Big Lots Inc 1316.7x 2281 40% 88% -5% 39% -12% 18% -72% 97% How should we evaluate TGT compared to Canadian Tire in analyzing their BF P/E ratios from a relative value and historical average perspective? TGT has a lower P/E multiple, but it is trading at a larger historical premium than it usually does so it is considered relatively overvalued when evaluating its P/E premium/discount level from a historical perspective. Canadian Tire has a lower P/E multiple, but it is trading at a smaller historical discount than it usually does, so it is considered relatively overvalued when evaluating its P/E premium/discount level from a historical perspective. Canadian Tire has a lower P/E multiple, and it is trading at a larger historical premium than it usually does, so it is considered relatively undervalued when evaluating its P/E premium/discount level from a historical perspective. Metric BF P/E Name Peer Group Average Peers Benchmarked Against Group Average Current Current vs 2Y Average Historical Premium Metric Prem Hist Avg Diff #SD 3M Trend 19.9x 3M 6M 1Y 2Y 5Y 2Y Historical Premium Range Low Range High Current Hist Avg 1) Dollar General Corp 2 Dollar Tree Inc 3) Target Corp 4 Five Below Inc 13.1x -34% -13% 15.7x -21% -11% 13.3x -33% -26% 24.0x 21% -21% -2.6 -34% 5% -10% -1.3 -39% 4% -7% -1.3 -37% -12% 37% -16% -1.0 1% 64% 5) Canadian Tire Corp Ltd 9.5x -52% -56% 49% 1.0 -63% -49% BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings I 18.2x -9% -15% 7% 1.1 -29% -2% 7) Costco Wholesale Corp 36.0x 81% 65% 16% Dollarama Inc 25.6x 29% 18% 11% 9 Walmart Inc 23.5x 18% 1% 18% 10) Big Lots Inc 1316.7x 2281 40% 88% -5% 39% -12% 18% -72% 97%