Hudson & Broad, Inc. (H&B) designed and manufactured display fixtures for stores. H&B alleged that J.C....
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Hudson & Broad, Inc. (H&B) designed and manufactured display fixtures for stores. H&B alleged that J.C. Penney Corp., Inc. (JCP) hired it to create a light fixture design based on JCP's "Fair and Square" advertising campaign. H&B submitted two designs for the "Squares" fixtures to JCP on January 4, 2012, hoping to win a nationwide contract to manufacture the Squares for JCP stores. Each design consisted of four rectangles forming the border; each rectangle was made from a matte acrylic and lit by an LED whose color could change via remote control. H&B performed services for JCP, such as attending meetings to assess the number and distribution of Squares for stores and providing and installing several finished Squares in JCP's Manhattan Mall location, in the corporate headquarters, and at a JCP beauty salon. The parties did not discuss price terms or a formal contract until JCP's Vice President for Visual Marketing requested a quote to present to JCP's Chief Operating Officer. H&B's representatives attended a meeting with JCP's Procurement Department on February 15, 2012, where production details and deadlines were discussed. H&B learned that other vendors were looking for materials for a square product for JCP. H&B's President contacted Francois, who explained that the JCP Capital Authorization Committee must still review H&B's quote and entertain other bids, and that H&B's quote had not yet been approved. JCP's Visual Graphics Director later informed H&B that another firm had submitted a bid "for a better product at half price!" JCP accepted the other firm's bid. H&B alleged that the accepted product differs from its Squares only by "the use of glossy acrylic in place of the custom-designed matte acrylic for the exterior." H&B did not receive any design fees or orders for the Squares. It had turned down offers for a design fee, and sued JCP for breach of contract, unjust enrichment, and quantum meruit. (In some states unjust enrichment and quantum meruit are different types of quasi contract claims.) 1. Assume that H&B's case has been filed in your court. How will you decide? 2. What could H&B have done differently to protect its interest in this process? 3. Would it have been effective? Why or why not? Hudson & Broad, Inc. (H&B) designed and manufactured display fixtures for stores. H&B alleged that J.C. Penney Corp., Inc. (JCP) hired it to create a light fixture design based on JCP's "Fair and Square" advertising campaign. H&B submitted two designs for the "Squares" fixtures to JCP on January 4, 2012, hoping to win a nationwide contract to manufacture the Squares for JCP stores. Each design consisted of four rectangles forming the border; each rectangle was made from a matte acrylic and lit by an LED whose color could change via remote control. H&B performed services for JCP, such as attending meetings to assess the number and distribution of Squares for stores and providing and installing several finished Squares in JCP's Manhattan Mall location, in the corporate headquarters, and at a JCP beauty salon. The parties did not discuss price terms or a formal contract until JCP's Vice President for Visual Marketing requested a quote to present to JCP's Chief Operating Officer. H&B's representatives attended a meeting with JCP's Procurement Department on February 15, 2012, where production details and deadlines were discussed. H&B learned that other vendors were looking for materials for a square product for JCP. H&B's President contacted Francois, who explained that the JCP Capital Authorization Committee must still review H&B's quote and entertain other bids, and that H&B's quote had not yet been approved. JCP's Visual Graphics Director later informed H&B that another firm had submitted a bid "for a better product at half price!" JCP accepted the other firm's bid. H&B alleged that the accepted product differs from its Squares only by "the use of glossy acrylic in place of the custom-designed matte acrylic for the exterior." H&B did not receive any design fees or orders for the Squares. It had turned down offers for a design fee, and sued JCP for breach of contract, unjust enrichment, and quantum meruit. (In some states unjust enrichment and quantum meruit are different types of quasi contract claims.) 1. Assume that H&B's case has been filed in your court. How will you decide? 2. What could H&B have done differently to protect its interest in this process? 3. Would it have been effective? Why or why not?
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
1 Decision In this case if I were the judge presiding over the matter I would consider the following factors to make a decision Existence of a Contrac... View the full answer
Related Book For
Auditing A Business Risk Approach
ISBN: 978-0538476232
8th edition
Authors: Karla Johnstone, Audrey Gramling, Larry Rittenberg
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these law questions
-
Read the case study and answer the question below with a one page response. What does a SWOT analysis reveal about the overall attractiveness of Under Armours situation? Founded in 1996 by former...
-
Managing Scope Changes Case Study Scope changes on a project can occur regardless of how well the project is planned or executed. Scope changes can be the result of something that was omitted during...
-
Planning is one of the most important management functions in any business. A front office managers first step in planning should involve determine the departments goals. Planning also includes...
-
In the Akerlof example, the individuals are treated as indifferent to risk. What would you expect to see in these markets if individuals wanted to avoid risk? What if there were some risk lovers?
-
An article in the Wall Street Journal notes that "raising productivity in the long run is the most effective way to elevate standards of living." Do you agree? Briefly explain.
-
You are in a game show, and the host gives you the choice of three doors. Behind one door is a car and behind the others are goats. You pick a door, say Door 1. The host who knows what is behind the...
-
What subtle shift in external auditing occurred in the early 1980s?
-
Using financial statements to prepare a statement of cash flows'Indirect method The comparative balance sheets and an income statement for Redwood Corporation follow. Other Information 1. Purchased...
-
Guest Corporation has decided to purchase a new machine that costs $6.3 million. The machine will be depreciated at a CCA rate of 30 percent and will be worthless after four years. The corporate ta...
-
The CyClon project team has started gathering information necessary to develop a project network-predecessor activities and activity time in days. The results of their meeting are found in the...
-
Healthcare report cards and score cards are the best way to guarantee high quality healthcare and excellent customer service.
-
The memo required must be drafted as a professional document, must contain citations for at least two primary legal sources. It is permissible for you to use a form or template as a base for creating...
-
A bridge costs $477,697 to build and $12000 per year to maintain. The bridge is repaved every 10 years for $371,520. Assume that the bridge will last for 60 years and that the interest rate is 10%....
-
In 1971, psychologist Philip Zimbardo and his colleagues set up an experiment to study the impact of group behavior and group processes. This experiment was called the Stanford Prison Experiment. In...
-
A bond is a 4 year 3.1 percent coupon bond with annual coupon payments and a face value of $1,000. A. Assume the yield to maturity is 2.1 percent What is the bond price today? What is the bond price...
-
The Cabinet Secretary for Lands, Public Works, Housing and Urban Development has appointed you as the Chairperson of a task Force to review the legal and policy framework governing land use in Kenya....
-
please help me with this one. At the beginning of the current season on April 1, the ledger of Indigo's Discorama showed Cash $1,800, Inventory $2,600, and Owner's Capital $4,400. The following...
-
Discrete sample spaces: suppose there are N cable cars in San Francisco, numbered sequentially from 1 to N. You see a cable car at random; it is numbered 203. You wish to estimate N. (See Goodman,...
-
The auditor wishes to test the controls around the assertion that all valid transactions are recorded at the correct time and at the correct price. Consider the revenue cycle and identify the types...
-
The text talks about the case of Dell receiving payments from Intel in return for a pledge by Dell that they would not use computer chips from a major Intel competitor (AMD). The payments were large,...
-
On February 28, 2012, Stu & Dent, LLP completed the audit of Shylo Ranch, Inc. (a nonpublic company) for the year ended December 31, 2011. A recent fire destroyed the accounting records concerning...
-
Home prices have been on the rise since 2000, driven by low interest rates that make mortgages affordable.
-
On January 1, 2016, Safetyway Group,a LO1 U.S. company, formed a Swiss subsidiary, TEurope AG. The subsidiary issued all of its currently outstanding common stock on that date. Selected accounts from...
-
Your neighbors are thinking of selling their two-bedroom home in the suburbs and moving to a two-bedroom condominium. Help them make this decision.
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App