CASE 2: STAFFING: CHRISTIAN CORPORATION The department manager hold a regular staff meeting with her four...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
CASE 2: STAFFING: CHRISTIAN CORPORATION The department manager hold a regular staff meeting with her four sections heads confining each meeting to one chief problem. On this day, the subject was the poor quality of the twenty supervisor reporting to the sections heads. "We have a rather poor record in selecting good supervisor." She began, "We may have five or six who are outstanding, but there were too many who are not. What do you people consider when you recommend candidates to me?" I think my best technical people make the best supervisors, said one section head. They have the respect of their associates and subordinates, who rate their technical competence highly. They can train new staff members very effectively and pitch in to do the most demanding jobs themselves. Maybe that is just the trouble, said the department manager. People like them may never learn to manage because they spend their time on technical work. Another section head said, I made my recommendation on the basis of seniority. It has popular appeal because everyone expects to be along this line. Do you think, said the manager, that age is the only or most important criterion for supervision? Such a practice conveniently ignores everything learned about managing, or it assumes that the candidate has the capability to become proficient in management after getting the job. Is this realistic? In the course of the meeting, other factors such as getting along with people, making good impression, having the capability for further promotion, and being able to exact responsibility were also considered. The department manager was clearly frustrated and, as she ended the meeting, she remarked, no wonder we have 40% failure rate in selecting supervisor. Follow the format below in solving your choice cases. I. Background: Provide background information on the case, including relevant context, history, and key players. II. Problem statement: Clearly articulate the problem faced by the organization. III. Analysis: Analyze the situation using relevant frameworks, theories, and concepts. Consider the internal and external factors that are contributing to the problem. IV. Alternative Courses of Actions (ACA): Identify and evaluate potential solutions to the problem. V. Recommendation: Select the best course of action based on the analysis and evaluation of alternatives. VI. Implementation plan: Outline the steps required to implement the recommended solution. This should include details on resources, timelines, and key stakeholders. VII. Evaluation and control: Discuss how the effectiveness of the solution will be monitored and evaluated. This may include key performance indicators, ongoing evaluations, and contingency plans. VIII. Conclusion: Summarize the key takeaways from the case solution and highlight its importance to Human Resource Management. CASE 2: STAFFING: CHRISTIAN CORPORATION The department manager hold a regular staff meeting with her four sections heads confining each meeting to one chief problem. On this day, the subject was the poor quality of the twenty supervisor reporting to the sections heads. "We have a rather poor record in selecting good supervisor." She began, "We may have five or six who are outstanding, but there were too many who are not. What do you people consider when you recommend candidates to me?" I think my best technical people make the best supervisors, said one section head. They have the respect of their associates and subordinates, who rate their technical competence highly. They can train new staff members very effectively and pitch in to do the most demanding jobs themselves. Maybe that is just the trouble, said the department manager. People like them may never learn to manage because they spend their time on technical work. Another section head said, I made my recommendation on the basis of seniority. It has popular appeal because everyone expects to be along this line. Do you think, said the manager, that age is the only or most important criterion for supervision? Such a practice conveniently ignores everything learned about managing, or it assumes that the candidate has the capability to become proficient in management after getting the job. Is this realistic? In the course of the meeting, other factors such as getting along with people, making good impression, having the capability for further promotion, and being able to exact responsibility were also considered. The department manager was clearly frustrated and, as she ended the meeting, she remarked, no wonder we have 40% failure rate in selecting supervisor. Follow the format below in solving your choice cases. I. Background: Provide background information on the case, including relevant context, history, and key players. II. Problem statement: Clearly articulate the problem faced by the organization. III. Analysis: Analyze the situation using relevant frameworks, theories, and concepts. Consider the internal and external factors that are contributing to the problem. IV. Alternative Courses of Actions (ACA): Identify and evaluate potential solutions to the problem. V. Recommendation: Select the best course of action based on the analysis and evaluation of alternatives. VI. Implementation plan: Outline the steps required to implement the recommended solution. This should include details on resources, timelines, and key stakeholders. VII. Evaluation and control: Discuss how the effectiveness of the solution will be monitored and evaluated. This may include key performance indicators, ongoing evaluations, and contingency plans. VIII. Conclusion: Summarize the key takeaways from the case solution and highlight its importance to Human Resource Management.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
I Background Christian Corporation is facing a challenge in selecting suitable supervisors for its departments The department manager holds regular staff meetings with section heads to address various ... View the full answer
Related Book For
Smith and Roberson Business Law
ISBN: 978-0538473637
15th Edition
Authors: Richard A. Mann, Barry S. Roberts
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these human resource management questions
-
Read the article below and answer the questions posed, the compose response should be two to three pages in length. 1. What are 2 major planning failures pre-event at Memorial that led to it becoming...
-
The Crazy Eddie fraud may appear smaller and gentler than the massive billion-dollar frauds exposed in recent times, such as Bernie Madoffs Ponzi scheme, frauds in the subprime mortgage market, the...
-
Is the State of Michigan justified in advertising the prize amount as $1.586 billion? Explain.
-
Would the task environment for a wireless provider such as U.S. Cellular contain the same elements as that for a government welfare agency? Discuss the similarities and differences.
-
Determine the power required for a 1150-kg car to climb a 100-m-long uphill road with a slope of 308 (from horizontal) in 12 s (a) at a constant velocity, (b) from rest to a final velocity of 30 m/s,...
-
Use the all-possible-regressions method to select a subset regression model for the Belle Ayr liquefaction data in Table B.5. Evaluate the subset models using the \(C_{p}\) criterion. Justify your...
-
Jills Job Shop buys two parts (Tegdiws and Widgets) for use in its production system from two different suppliers. The parts are needed throughout the entire 52-week year. Tegdiws are used at a...
-
The following information pertains to ABC Corporation: Beginning raw materials inventory $37,000 Ending raw materials inventory $45,000 Beginning work-in-process inventory $18,000 Ending...
-
Mark Collins, luthier and businessman, builds and sells custom-made acoustic and electric stringed instruments. Although located in Maryville, Tennessee, he purchases raw materials from around the...
-
Question 2: (25 points) (3D rotations) Three points P, P2 and P3 are given. Pi is at (10, 15, 20). Point P2 is at (10+cos0, 15-sin0, 20). Point P3 is at (10+sin, 15+cose, 20). Here is arbitrary....
-
What is the meaning of probable cause?
-
If so, is it similar to one of the three formats illustrated in this chapter? If not, how is it different?
-
Is jury nullification always a bad thing? When might it be a correct outcome?
-
If a jury serves as the conscience of the community, what can jurors do if they feel that applying the law would bring about injustice? Should they simply disregard the law and vote based on their...
-
Do you know about the chart of accounts in your organization as it pertains to information you receive?
-
2. A post office requires different numbers of full-time employees on different days of the week. The number of full-time employees required on each day is given in the table below. Union rules state...
-
Where are the olfactory sensory neurons, and why is that site poorly suited for their job?
-
Johnson Enterprises, Inc., contracted with the accounting firm of P, A & E to perform an audit of Johnson. The accounting firm performed its duty in a non-negligent, competent manner but failed to...
-
The articles of partnership of the firm of Wilson and Company provide the following: William Smith to contribute $50,000; to receive interest thereon at 13 percent per annum and to devote such time...
-
Compare briefly the traditional and modern theories of definiteness of acceptance of an offer as shown by the common law mirror image rule and by the rule of the Uniform Commercial Code.
-
Describe how partial and circular reasoning can be helpful or harmful in resolving ethical dilemmas.
-
Describe the various legal risks for nurses.
-
Describe the various roles of advanced practice nurses.
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App