import java.util.Random;

public class Main $\{$

public static void main$($String$[]$ args$)\{$

Random rand $=$ new Random$()$;

System.out.print$("$Enter player $1$ name: $")$;

String player$1$name $=$ System.console$().$readLine$()$;

System.out.print$("$Enter player $1$ max steps: $")$;

int player$1$maxsteps $=$ Integer.parseInt$($System$.$console$().$readLine$())$;

System.out.print$("$Enter player $2$ name: $")$;

String player$2$name $=$ System.console$().$readLine$()$;

System.out.print$("$Enter player $2$ max steps: $")$;

int player$2$maxsteps $=$ Integer.parseInt$($System$.$console$().$readLine$())$;

System.out.print$("$Do you want to play a regular $30$ step game or a different number of steps? $(30/$different$)")$;

String choice $=$ System.console$().$readLine$()$;

if $($choice$.$equals$("30"))\{$

PlayGame$($player$1$name, player$1$maxsteps, player$2$name, player$2$maxsteps$)$;

$\}$ else $\{$

System.out.print$("$Enter the number of steps to cross the finish line: $")$;

int finishLine $=$ Integer.parseInt$($System$.$console$().$readLine$())$;

PlayGame$($player$1$name, player$1$maxsteps, player$2$name, player$2$maxsteps, finishLine$)$;

$\}$

$\}$

public static void PlayGame$($String player$1$name, int player$1$maxsteps,

String player$2$name

The class name in the OverLoad should be Overload as Java's source file name should be exact same as its first public class. You should have the $4-$parameter method and $5-$parameter method PlayGame define inside the class Overload.