In 2012, the press information about Enron's bankruptcy mission along with some confusion at Arthur Andersen Company,
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
In 2012, the press information about Enron's bankruptcy mission along with some confusion at Arthur Andersen Company, one of the five largest auditing corporations in the world. How do auditors determine materiality to give an opinion on the financial statements? Are their rules of thumb and professional judgment reasonable ?
Transcribed Image Text:
Panel A: Enron Financial Data (in millions) 1997 + Nonrecurring Loss Net Income Total Assets Sales Revenues Enron Financial Data and Materiality Rules of Thumb 5% of Net Income 10% of Net Income 1% of Total Assets 1%% of Total Assets 1% of Sales Revenues 1%% of Sales Revenues Conservative Blend Non-Conservative Blend 568 23,422 20,273 5% of Net Income + 1997 Nonrecurring Loss 10% of Net Income + 1997 Nonrecurring Loss 1997 5.25 10.50 234.22 351.33 202.73 304.10 Panel B: Common Materiality Rules of Thumb Applied to Enron's Data (in millions) Average 1995-97 147.40 221.98 1997 105 23,422 20,273 28.4 20.15 40.30 175.99 263.99 56.8 142.50 213.76 112.88 172.68 1996 584 16,137 13,289 27.86 55.73 Average 1994-97 20.78 41.55 161.91 242.87 129.34 194.01 104.01 159.48 Average 1994-97 1995 520 13,239 9,189 26.56 53.13 Average 1995-96 Panel C: Income Materiality Rules of Thumb: Deleting Effect of 1997 Nonrecurring Loss (in millions) Average Average 1997 1995-97 1994-96 27.60 55.20 146.88 220.32 112.39 168.59 95.62 148.04 Average 1995-96 27.60 55.20 Bold numbers represent materiality thresholds that are higher than the proposed $51 million 1997 adjustment. That is, relying only upon the rule of thumb, the amount is considered immaterial. 1994 *(5 percent of Net Income + 1 percent of Total Assets + 1 percent of Sales Revenues)/3. (10 percent of Net Income + 1.5 percent of Total Assets +1.5 percent of Sales Revenues)/3. 453 11,966 8984 Average 1994-96 25.95 51.90 137.81 206.71 104.87 157.31 89.54 138.64 25.95 51.90 Panel A: Enron Financial Data (in millions) 1997 + Nonrecurring Loss Net Income Total Assets Sales Revenues Enron Financial Data and Materiality Rules of Thumb 5% of Net Income 10% of Net Income 1% of Total Assets 1%% of Total Assets 1% of Sales Revenues 1%% of Sales Revenues Conservative Blend Non-Conservative Blend 568 23,422 20,273 5% of Net Income + 1997 Nonrecurring Loss 10% of Net Income + 1997 Nonrecurring Loss 1997 5.25 10.50 234.22 351.33 202.73 304.10 Panel B: Common Materiality Rules of Thumb Applied to Enron's Data (in millions) Average 1995-97 147.40 221.98 1997 105 23,422 20,273 28.4 20.15 40.30 175.99 263.99 56.8 142.50 213.76 112.88 172.68 1996 584 16,137 13,289 27.86 55.73 Average 1994-97 20.78 41.55 161.91 242.87 129.34 194.01 104.01 159.48 Average 1994-97 1995 520 13,239 9,189 26.56 53.13 Average 1995-96 Panel C: Income Materiality Rules of Thumb: Deleting Effect of 1997 Nonrecurring Loss (in millions) Average Average 1997 1995-97 1994-96 27.60 55.20 146.88 220.32 112.39 168.59 95.62 148.04 Average 1995-96 27.60 55.20 Bold numbers represent materiality thresholds that are higher than the proposed $51 million 1997 adjustment. That is, relying only upon the rule of thumb, the amount is considered immaterial. 1994 *(5 percent of Net Income + 1 percent of Total Assets + 1 percent of Sales Revenues)/3. (10 percent of Net Income + 1.5 percent of Total Assets +1.5 percent of Sales Revenues)/3. 453 11,966 8984 Average 1994-96 25.95 51.90 137.81 206.71 104.87 157.31 89.54 138.64 25.95 51.90
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Solution Auditors determine materiality by assessing the significance of a transaction or event in r... View the full answer
Related Book For
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
Use the Following metrics to perform the operation, if possible. A = F2-12 1 3 0 1 2 3 B 1 1 2 3 5 3-3 L0323 Find 2A-3B
-
The following additional information is available for the Dr. Ivan and Irene Incisor family from Chapters 1-5. Ivan's grandfather died and left a portfolio of municipal bonds. In 2012, they pay Ivan...
-
Managing Scope Changes Case Study Scope changes on a project can occur regardless of how well the project is planned or executed. Scope changes can be the result of something that was omitted during...
-
400 KVA 34000/400 V transformer has copper losses is 5000 W and iron losses is 1000 W under nominal load and nominal voltage. A) Calculate the efficiency of the transformer when the nominal load is...
-
A cereal manufacturer makes two different kinds of cereal, Senior Citizen's Feast and Kids Go. Each pound of Senior Citizen's Feast requires 0.6 lb of wheat and 0.2 lb of vitamin-enriched syrup, and...
-
Southern Sporting Goods Company makes basketballs and footballs. Each product is produced from two resourcesrubber and leather. The resource requirements for each product and the total resources...
-
A spontaneous reaction is defined as one which (a) Proceeds by itself (b) Proceeds only when heated (c) Proceeds on heating at high pressure and in presence of catalyst (d) Proceeds by itself or when...
-
The following information about the payroll for the week ended July 17 was obtained from the records of Anaconda Mining Co.: Instructions 1. For the July 17 payroll, determine the employee FICA tax...
-
Factor by grouping. 2w uw 6+3u
-
3. Consider the time function x(t) shown in the figure below 12 (1) X 10 00 6 st 4 2 2 x(t) = at, ts 3 mom 4 5 Time t (seconds) x(t) = 10, t > 5 6 9 10 Suppose this signal is sampled every T = 0.5...
-
You have a sample of uranium, which has a mix of uranium-235 atoms and uranium-238 atoms. U-235 atoms each have a mass of 3.90 x10-25 kg, while U-238 atoms each have a mass of 3.95 x10-25 kg. You're...
-
How did the Bill of Rights come to be applied to the individual states?
-
Visit www.standardandpoors.com. What kind of information does it provide about organizations?
-
Would you choose to live under a brutal dictator such as Hitler, Stalin, or Saddam Hussein or suffer the chaos of a society without any kind of law?
-
How are qualitative research procedures classified?
-
What would be an integral part of a skillful moderator's process of conducting a depth interview? Why?
-
how do you get contribution margin Sales Revenue Variable Costs Contribution Margin Fixed Costs Operating Income [($4.00/dz. [($1.60/dz. 12,000 dz.) + ($8.00/dz. x 3,000 dz.)] 12,000 dz.) +...
-
Suppose the S&P 500 futures price is 1000, = 30%, r = 5%, = 5%, T = 1, and n = 3. a. What are the prices of European calls and puts for K = $1000? Why do you find the prices to be equal? b. What...
-
On April 11, 2017, KPMG LLP announced that five partners and one employee of the firm had been dismissed for failing to disclose confidential information obtained illicitly from the Public Company...
-
Richard Grimes glanced at his wristwatch as he pulled into the nearly deserted parking lot of the corporate headquarters of McCaleb Medical Corporation (MMC).1 It was 6:25 a.m. on a cold and overcast...
-
Aaron Elrod spent the early years of his professional career in a large Sun Belt city working on the staff of a major accounting firm and then serving as an assistant controller for a municipal...
-
Fill in the Blank. For a shaft carrying masses \(m_{1}, m_{2}, \ldots\), Rayleigh's method gives the natural frequency as \[\omega=\left\{\frac{g\left(m_{1} w_{1}+m_{2} w_{2}+\cdots ight)}{m_{1}...
-
True or False. In the matrix iteration method, any computational error will not yield incorrect results.
-
Rayleigh's method a. Finds the natural frequencies and mode shapes of the system, one at a time, using several trial values for each frequency. b. Finds all the natural frequencies using trial...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App