In the excerpt below , the authors present an ethical dilemma. Explain the possible actions that the
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
In the excerpt below , the authors present an ethical dilemma. Explain the possible actions that the manager can take, depending on the three main theories of ethics (Main Western ethics theories are: Consequentialist, Nonconsequentialist, Virtue).
Transcribed Image Text:
"Managers often rationalize earnings management as being a necessary evil or the "right thing to do" given the circumstances. There could even be situations where managing earnings appears to be the "ethical" choice. For example, imagine you're the CFO of a company who has toiled tirelessly to meet analysts' earnings forecasts for the last few periods, but to no avail. Furthermore, you have had difficulty motivating your hardworking employees because results have consistently failed to reach the level necessary for employees to receive bonuses. Your company's current period earnings are finally on track to beat expectations and trigger employee bonuses, but an important sale falls through just before the end of the period. As the CFO, you know that yet another failure to meet earnings expectations and pay employees bonuses will further damage shareholder value as well as employee morale. Such a situation provides the perfect environment to argue the ethicality of managing company earnings. After all, isn't it the CFO's job to protect the interests of both shareholders and employees? Perhaps a more aggressive interpretation of GAAP would allow more revenue to be recognized in the current period, or perhaps a sale of obsolete equipment planned for the current period could be delayed to avoid the loss on sale that would result." "Managers often rationalize earnings management as being a necessary evil or the "right thing to do" given the circumstances. There could even be situations where managing earnings appears to be the "ethical" choice. For example, imagine you're the CFO of a company who has toiled tirelessly to meet analysts' earnings forecasts for the last few periods, but to no avail. Furthermore, you have had difficulty motivating your hardworking employees because results have consistently failed to reach the level necessary for employees to receive bonuses. Your company's current period earnings are finally on track to beat expectations and trigger employee bonuses, but an important sale falls through just before the end of the period. As the CFO, you know that yet another failure to meet earnings expectations and pay employees bonuses will further damage shareholder value as well as employee morale. Such a situation provides the perfect environment to argue the ethicality of managing company earnings. After all, isn't it the CFO's job to protect the interests of both shareholders and employees? Perhaps a more aggressive interpretation of GAAP would allow more revenue to be recognized in the current period, or perhaps a sale of obsolete equipment planned for the current period could be delayed to avoid the loss on sale that would result."
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
The ethical dilemma presented in the above case is whether or not to practice earnings management EM EM is a technique that is used to manipulate fina... View the full answer
Related Book For
International Business The New Realities
ISBN: 978-0134324838
4th edition
Authors: Tamer Cavusgil, Gary Knight, John Riesenberger
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
Ethical Dilemma Steven Sanchez is the export manager at Leon Industries, a manufacturer of office furnishings. He has identified Russia as a promising market and decides to attend a furniture trade...
-
Explain why lags make it possible that policy actions intended to stabilize the economy will actually destabilize it.
-
Explain how it can be possible for a portfolio manager to outperform a benchmark but still fail to meet the investment objective of a client.
-
1. What is Anthropology, Sociology, and Political Science in your own understanding? 2. What is the nature of Anthropology, Sociology, and Political Science? 3. How are they similar with one another?
-
An operation has a 10 percent s crap rate. As a result, only 82 good pieces per hour are produced. What is the potential increase in labour productivity that could be achieved by eliminating the...
-
On January 1, 2011, Allan Company bought a 15 percent interest in Sysinger Company. The acquisition price of $184,500 reflected an assessment that all of Sysingers accounts were fairly valued within...
-
Crush Autosmashers can purchase a new electromagnet for moving cars at a cost of \($20,000.\) At the end of its useful life, the electromagnet will be worth \($1,000.\) If Crushs MARR is 12...
-
Schultz Electronics manufactures two large-screen television models: the Royale which sells for $1,600, and a new model, the Majestic, which sells for $1,300. The production cost computed per unit...
-
Should court fines for offenses (i.e. traffic, quality of life, shoplifting, property damage, etc.) be the same for the poor and the wealthy? Should it be dollar for dollar equal, or should it be a...
-
Consider the 2013 declined loan data from LendingClub titled RejectStatsB2013 from the Connect website. Similar to the analysis done in the chapter, lets scrub the risk score data. First, because our...
-
now what if we change variables to: Scenario Probability Market Return Aggressive Stock Defensive Stock 1 0.5 6% 2.8% 4.6% 2 0.5 15 28 10
-
Your client invested $10,000 in an interest bearing promissory note earning an 11% annual rate of interest, compounded monthly. How much will the note be worth at the end of 7 years, assuming that...
-
Exhibit 14.4 The current stock price of ABC Corporation is $53.50. ABC Corporation has the following put and call option prices that expire six months from today. The risk-free rate of return is 5...
-
The flaw of averages refers to 1 the average of a measure (e.g., profit) only provides a small indication of system behavior. 2 setting random input values to their average or best guess values can...
-
The IRS examines the 20X5 tax return of Sam Short. His return reported tax due in the amount of $60,000. The revenue agent has determined that Sam understated his tax for 20X5 by $22,000 and is...
-
Find the power consumed by a 120-V device that draws 2.0 A of current?
-
As the Quality Improvement Supervisor, you check the hospital's social media pages for patient comments and reviews on hospital services. In the past six months, you have noticed more comments and...
-
Find the volume of the described solid S. A frustum of a right circular cone with height h, lower base radius R, and top radius r -r- --R
-
How can Harley effectively compete with rivals from Japan and Europe? What strategies should management apply to grow the firm's sales in those regions?
-
What is your view of Sony's efforts at corporate social responsibility (CSR) in international operations? What steps can Sony take to improve CSR in organizing and managing its operations around the...
-
Increasingly, H&M targets emerging markets like China, Russia, and Saudi Arabia, which are often characterized by distinctive cultures, lower incomes, and inexperience with leading-edge fashion. In...
-
Name and briefly explain the three key components of a modern financial system.
-
What are non-banking financial intermediaries? List the different types and briefly explain their role in connecting savers with borrowers in the financial system.
-
Briefly explain the process of asset securitization in the financial system.
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App