Question: In the Week 3 readings and lecture, we compared the cognitive-behavioral based approaches to the treatment of depression described by Alex Lickerman and David

In the Week 3 readings and lecture, we compared the cognitive-behavioral based

In the Week 3 readings and lecture, we compared the cognitive-behavioral based approaches to the treatment of depression described by Alex Lickerman and David Burns with a critique (by Ungar) of CBT's concepts of self-help, resilience, and personal transformation. Please describe in some detail the key differences between these approaches and their respective underlying theories of distress and recovery. To put it another way, imagine that Lickerman (or Burns) and Ungar were having a debate about what causes depression and how best to help people recover. How would each of these theorists answer? How would they each respond to the other?

Step by Step Solution

★★★★★

3.40 Rating (144 Votes )

There are 3 Steps involved in it

1 Expert Approved Answer

Step: 1 Unlock

Part 1 Burns 1996 criticizes the concepts of selfhelp resilience and personal transformation that are a key part of cognitive behavioral therapy CBT Burns argues that these concepts are based on an in... View full answer

Question Has Been Solved by an Expert!

Get step-by-step solutions from verified subject matter experts

Step: 2 Unlock

Step: 3 Unlock

Students Have Also Explored These Related Psychology Questions!

a. Detail the key differences between lytic and nonlytic viral infection and provide an example of each. b. Which of the following processes occurs in both lytic and nonlytic viral infections? (i)...

What is the major difference between behavioral and cognitive theories of learning?

detail how each of the three major social cognitive theorists (Rotter, Bandura and Mishel) would attempt to explain Darth Vaders behaviour in terms of how they view human nature, as well as the...

Review the audit report of Coca-Cola in Panel A of Exhibit 15.1. Obtain a copy of the audit report in the 2011 Annual Report of 3D Diagnostic Imaging plc, which is available at...

The manufacturer of hardness testing equipment uses steel-ball indenters to penetrate metal that is being tested. However, the manufacturer thinks it would be better to use a diamond indenter so that...

What is the primary purpose of the accounts payable function? Describe the procedures used to manage accounts payable. What are the key differences between centralized and decentralized payables and...

Describe the key differences between doing a qualitative risk assessment versus a quantitative risk assessment.

Describe two major differences between the warning bit method and the RED method.

What are the key differences between debt and equity?

Instead of a fixed compensatory share option plan, Wright Company is considering providing its key executives with a plan that involves share appreciation rights (SAR). Required 1. Explain what is...

What is time-based competition?

Verify the Associativity of the Exclusive OR rule ((p)r) (p (qr)) by first converting both sides to ANDs and ORs using the Definition of Exclusive OR rule, then using the distributive law and the...

Use f ( x , y , z ) = x 2 + yz , F ( x , y , z ) = xy , yz , xz , and G ( x , y , z ) = sin ( z ) , exz, y . Compute ( F G ) ( 4 , 1 , 8 ) . ( Your instructors prefer angle bracket notation for...

An X-ray tube operates at 95kV with a current of 25mA and nearly all the electron energy goes into heat. If the specific heat of the 0.085-kg plate is 0.11 kcal/kg Co, what will be the temperature...

A hydrogen atom is in the 6s state. Determine (a) The principal quantum number, (b) The energy of the state, (c) The orbital angular momentum and its quantum number l, and (d) The possible values for...

Use the result of Example 28-6 to estimate the X-ray wavelength emitted when a Co (Z = 27) atom jumps from n = 2 to n = 1.

A laser used to weld detached retinas puts out 28-ms-long pulses of 640-nm light which average 0.68-W output during a pulse. How much energy can be deposited per pulse and how many photons does each...

A 12-g bullet leaves a rifle at a speed of 180m/s. (a) What is the wavelength of this bullet? (b) If the position of the bullet is known to an accuracy of 0.60cm (radius of the barrel), what is the...

s According to the Food Code, proper food labels should NOT contain: The date that frozen preparation-needed foods are to be consumed The date frozen foods should be eaten once removed from the...

This week, you are going to utilize the Cognitive Triangle Worksheet in the Week 3 Readings tab.Using this worksheet, you are going to select a situation in your life (one that you do not mind...

Question 2: Job Satisfaction The variable Jobsat gives an indication of the extent to which employees are satisfied with their job. This variable was scored on a scale that can take values from 0 to...

ACC 205 week 1 Discussion 2 Accounting Equation Discussion 2 Accounts ACC205 Principles of Accounting I Course Guide This course is an introduction to the principles and procedures of general...

Module 9 Assignment: TOC Answer all the questions and submit your answer report to Module 9 Assignment in Dropbox by the deadline . The report should be typed, single spaced, in one MS Word file. You...

nterim Report on Case 3 - Group Project- Home Depot Attached is the syllabus with directions on this project. Please keep in my that the only thing that I'm asking here is just the section below,...

HELP PLEASE COMPLEX EXCEL QUESTION MUST SHOW WORK FOR EACH CELL HOW ALL YOUR SUPPORTING CALCULATIONS! You may do this either within the cell by using formulas, or to the side or below - clearly...