Question: Instrumental variable only works if the only connection between the instrumental variable and the outcomes is through the treatment. For an instrumental variable to be

Instrumental variable only works if the only connection between the instrumental variable and the outcomes is through the treatment. For an instrumental variable to be effective it must be 1. Relevant (i.e., it must be directly related to treatment) and 2. Exogenous (i.e., it must be related to the outcome only through the treatment). Failure of either condition is a problem.Exogeneity is difficult to prove and requires theoretical justification. Can you think of an example where an instrumental variable might be appropriate for estimating causal effect?

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

1 Expert Approved Answer

Step: 1 Unlock blur-text-image

Question Has Been Solved by an Expert!

Get step-by-step solutions from verified subject matter experts

Step: 2 Unlock

Step: 3 Unlock

Students Have Also Explored These Related Mathematics Questions!

4. In many US states, high school students are offered scholarships are given to students to students who remain in-state for university or college. For example, Kansan high school students can...

1 Empirical Exercise In this problem, you will use data from the UK to study the impact of education on earnings and health. To do so, you are going to exploit a change in compulsory schooling age...

Three Examples Where does one find something that affects incarceration but has no direct We now turn to three empirical applications of IV regression that provide exam- effect on the crime rate? One...

What is the methodology of the research, the hypothesis, the type of researchqualitative, quantitative, statistical, case study, etc, and the way the research was conductedsurveys, interviews,...

read this article and describe research style of this article by own word. 300 words. Impact of Effective Implementation of HR Practices on Employee Performance in Pharmacy Business in Thailand...

Recall the Bleemer and Mehta (2022) paper we discussed in Lecture Slides 5. The two main figures are reproduced below: students scoring just above the cutoff were much more likely to major in...

1. Teddy wants to evaluate the impact of a skills training intervention on participants. He collects baseline data of both treated and control group and recorded outcomes of 150 and 100 for the...

You are interested in the effect of military service on wages: does serving in the military cause people to have higher or lower wages after they exit the service? You collect data on wages from a...

2. Huntington-Klein and Gill (2020) are interested in whether taking 15 credits per semester versus 12 credits per semester harms student performance, where performance is measured as standardized...

Theories of Motivation 1 Theories of Motivation Importance The explanation behind requiring some serious energy learning on this is because to understand the part of the inspiration in deciding...

During an audit, an audit is required to establish performance materiality for several balance sheet accounts. Explain/justify how you would choose the performance materiality amounts for each of the...

1. Marilyn has worked in insurable employment for 36 weeks prior to her termination. Her employer produces paper Records of Employment. What is her employer encouraged to do to reduce the need for...

Madoff's scheme looked like a smart, lowclaimed to use a strategy involving stocks and options to generate steady returns. But none of it was real. Which of the following was true: a . Instead of...

Una empresa debe fijar el precio de su producto para cubrir sus costos y obtener una utilidad razonable en sus primeros aos todos los casos el corto plazo el largo plazo