John offers to teach Rose and Carly to waterski at a local lake. They arrive and, before
Question:
John offers to teach Rose and Carly to waterski at a local lake. They arrive and, before they get in the
boat, John drinks three pints of beer at lunch. He then starts up the motorboat, gives them some brief
instructions and they set off across the lake. Neither woman is wearing a life jacket. Carly is the first to
attempt to waterski and Rose is a passenger in the boat. Despite Rose's shouted warnings, John drives so
fast and erratically that he drags Carly into the path of another boat, driven by Harry. The tow rope is
broken and Carly, who is not a strong swimmer, struggles to stay afloat and inhales water. Neesha is an
off-duty lifeguard who sees the accident from the beach and swims out to the scene to assist in rescuing
Carly. Carly suffers severe brain damage due to her near drowning. Rose is now having difficulty sleeping
and has lost her appetite. Harry has begun to drink heavily and feels unable to do his job. Neesha has been
diagnosed with severe depression. Advise the parties
what would your advise be according to the relevant law?