Judy is an oil industry executive from Lexington, Michigan, a small town about two hours from...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Judy is an oil industry executive from Lexington, Michigan, a small town about two hours from Detroit. After driving a 2006 Toyota Corolla LE for the past ten years, Judy has decided it is time for a car upgrade. After all, she just received a promotion at work, that came with a small raise from her annual evaluation last week. Judy has always wanted a Lexus GS Turbo. Her hesitation, in the past, has been the added expenses as well as the intimidating negotiation process involved in purchasing a car. Judy has always considered herself to be a fair, honest and trustworthy negotiator. She also believes she has a reputation for these characteristics among her peers and colleagues in Lexington. Her impression of car sales representatives are that they only focus on selling you the car at the best possible price. Her sense is that they do not use ethical tactics in their sales techniques. She recently heard from a reliable friend that they often make up information about the car and will make promises that they have no intentions of meeting. Nonetheless, Judy wants a new Lexus GS Turbo and plans to go to Detroit to purchase the car this weekend. After doing research on Lexus GS Turbos all week, Judy has found that she can expect to pay around $47,615 for a new 2017 Lexus GS in pearl white with the preferred accessory package. She completed her research online. It was a lot of information and she hopes she can remember all the data once she gets into the negotiation. Judy drives the 2 hours to Detroit on Saturday with the intention of buying the car. Judy drives on to the car lot and a salesman approaches her immediately. He asks her what she is looking for today. Judy is following him around looking at all types of cars. Suddenly, she notices that a white 2017 Audi A6 is more attractive to her. It is a little more efficient and has better safety ratings for a midsize car than the Lexus GS. She expresses an interest in the car listed at $48,500. The salesman states that this model is in high demand. He tells her the best he can do is $48,000. Since her research focused on the Lexus GS Turbo, Judy does not know how to support her arguments. She also thinks to herself, I'm in Detroit not Lexington and no one knows me here. I never haggle because I find it demeaning, but I am tired of being taken advantage of by unethical sales people. At this point, she tells the salesman that she saw this exact car for sale for $44,000 from a dealer in Illinois. The salesman tells her that $44,000 is less than they paid for the car and he will talk to his manager. He comes back and says "we can meet you at $46,000." She responds by saying that "I can get the car in Illinois" and starts to walk off of the car lot. He follows her and says, "how about $45,000?" She turns around, walks over to the car, and says that she was looking for a red car not a white one. The car salesman says, "you drive a hard bargain and sells her the car for $44,000." 1. Do you think Judy behaved unethically in this scenario? Why or why not? 2. Did Judy behave illegally? 3. Do you think the car salesman behaved unethically? 4. How do the concepts of relativism and absolutism in ethics inform Judy's decision? Judy is an oil industry executive from Lexington, Michigan, a small town about two hours from Detroit. After driving a 2006 Toyota Corolla LE for the past ten years, Judy has decided it is time for a car upgrade. After all, she just received a promotion at work, that came with a small raise from her annual evaluation last week. Judy has always wanted a Lexus GS Turbo. Her hesitation, in the past, has been the added expenses as well as the intimidating negotiation process involved in purchasing a car. Judy has always considered herself to be a fair, honest and trustworthy negotiator. She also believes she has a reputation for these characteristics among her peers and colleagues in Lexington. Her impression of car sales representatives are that they only focus on selling you the car at the best possible price. Her sense is that they do not use ethical tactics in their sales techniques. She recently heard from a reliable friend that they often make up information about the car and will make promises that they have no intentions of meeting. Nonetheless, Judy wants a new Lexus GS Turbo and plans to go to Detroit to purchase the car this weekend. After doing research on Lexus GS Turbos all week, Judy has found that she can expect to pay around $47,615 for a new 2017 Lexus GS in pearl white with the preferred accessory package. She completed her research online. It was a lot of information and she hopes she can remember all the data once she gets into the negotiation. Judy drives the 2 hours to Detroit on Saturday with the intention of buying the car. Judy drives on to the car lot and a salesman approaches her immediately. He asks her what she is looking for today. Judy is following him around looking at all types of cars. Suddenly, she notices that a white 2017 Audi A6 is more attractive to her. It is a little more efficient and has better safety ratings for a midsize car than the Lexus GS. She expresses an interest in the car listed at $48,500. The salesman states that this model is in high demand. He tells her the best he can do is $48,000. Since her research focused on the Lexus GS Turbo, Judy does not know how to support her arguments. She also thinks to herself, I'm in Detroit not Lexington and no one knows me here. I never haggle because I find it demeaning, but I am tired of being taken advantage of by unethical sales people. At this point, she tells the salesman that she saw this exact car for sale for $44,000 from a dealer in Illinois. The salesman tells her that $44,000 is less than they paid for the car and he will talk to his manager. He comes back and says "we can meet you at $46,000." She responds by saying that "I can get the car in Illinois" and starts to walk off of the car lot. He follows her and says, "how about $45,000?" She turns around, walks over to the car, and says that she was looking for a red car not a white one. The car salesman says, "you drive a hard bargain and sells her the car for $44,000." 1. Do you think Judy behaved unethically in this scenario? Why or why not? 2. Did Judy behave illegally? 3. Do you think the car salesman behaved unethically? 4. How do the concepts of relativism and absolutism in ethics inform Judy's decision?
Expert Answer:
Related Book For
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
Jean has decided it is time to purchase a new battery for her car. Her choices are: Jean believes the batteries can be expected to last only for the guarantee period. She does not want to invest...
-
Jean has decided it is time to purchase a new battery for her car. Her choices are: Jean believes the batteries can be expected to last only for the guarantee period. She does not want to invest...
-
For the past ten years, the Martins lived in a townhouse in Long Island with an adjacent empty lot. In January of the current 2020, Mr. Martin opened three laundromats and moved the family to...
-
A thermocouple Type K is calibrated in lab condition at 50% relative humidity (RH) prior to outdoor operation. After 12-month in outdoor installation, the thermocouple is again tested at 75% RH. Both...
-
In Anglo-Saxon countries, mechanisms are put in place to regulate auditors within the framework of professional self-regulation, whereas in many Continental European countries, quasi-governmental...
-
What is the main difference between IFRS and ASPE for investments in subsidiaries?
-
Let us consider a random linear constraint where a axb,
-
Multiple Choice Questions 1. You are bidding in a second-price auction for a painting that you value at $800. You estimate that other bidders are most likely to value the painting at between $200 and...
-
You invest $174 today at 6.0% compound interest per year. In how many years will you have $292? Round to the nearest hundredth. 2. In 2 years you plan to invest $154. In 17 years from today will you...
-
An automatic machine produces (thousands of) units of a product per day. As increases, the proportion of defectives, p, goes up according to the following probability density function Each...
-
Apple is considering raising 100 million dollars through rights offering. The company currently has 5 million shares outstanding that sell for 50 dollars per share. Its underwriter has set a...
-
Oriole Company had cost of goods sold of $260000. The comparative balance sheet analysis revealed a $15600 decrease in inventory and a $25100 increase in accounts payable. What were Oriole's cash...
-
1. Explain 2-3 fallacies and/or errors of reasoning you hear used most often as supporting evidence for a proposal or argument. 2. Explain 2-3 fallacies and/or errors of reasoning frequently used....
-
At the beginning of the day the balance in the Cash account was $ 4 , 7 5 0 . The ledger entries that day were a debit of $ 1 , 2 5 0 and a credit of $ 7 0 0 . What would be the balance at the end of...
-
Write a Matlab code that uses Simpson's 1/3 Rule to approximate the integral of f(x)=x+x+x+1 over the interval [1,5] using n=10 equal subdivisions.
-
What is tort law? What types of torts are there? What defenses can be used against torts? What are the steps in a civil trial? What are my rights and responsibilities as a consumer? How does the...
-
Presented below is information related to Bramble Corporation for the month of January 2020. Cost of goods sold Delivery expense Insurance expense Rent expense 1. 2. $209,920 Jan. 31 6,480 Jan. 31...
-
In the series connection below, what are the respective power consumptions of R, R2, and R3? R R www 4 V=6V P1-3 W; P2=3W; and P3= 3 W OP10.5 W; P2-1 W; and P3= 1.5 W P1=1.5 W; P2=1 W; and P3= 0.5 W...
-
What steps must the researcher take to ensure the reliability of a regulation?
-
Alice is an AICPA member actively engaged in advising clients on a variety of federal and state tax matters. Recently, she has expanded her practice to provide tax advice to various corporate...
-
Your client wishes to revoke its S Corporation election. Using just the IRC and Treasury regulations, determine what your client needs to do.
-
Explain the importance of establishing credibility for business communications.
-
Describe how competence, caring, and character affect your credibility as a communicator.
-
Define and explain business ethics, corporate values, and personal values.
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App