Question: Lucy v. Zehmer 1. Why does the court require objective intention to contract? The contrasting term to objective is subjective, meaning peculiar to a particular

Lucy v. Zehmer

1. Why does the court require objective intention to contract? The contrasting term to objective is subjective, meaning "peculiar to a particular individual." Why isn't subjective intent preferable; after all, if you want to know what someone means, can't you ask them?

2. Can you identify three separate contentions Zehmer makes to defend against Lucy's action? Why were they unsuccessful? Do you agree with the court's ruling?

3. Lucy testified that there had been an oral agreement to buy the farm for $20,000 "seven or eight years ago." Why do you suppose Lucy had not sued to enforce that agreement?

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

1 Expert Approved Answer

Step: 1 Unlock blur-text-image

Question Has Been Solved by an Expert!

Get step-by-step solutions from verified subject matter experts

Step: 2 Unlock

Step: 3 Unlock

Students Have Also Explored These Related Law Questions!

BCE has included service revenue of $22,100 as a result of a number of one year service policies sold late in December as an experiment. These service policies became effective on January 1, 20X4, or...

Chapter 9 from Business Law and the Legal Environment was adapted by The Saylor Foundation under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 license without attribution as requested...

Contractual Intent: Lucy v. Zehmer 60 60 unread replies. 60 60 replies. In order to have a valid and enforceable contract, you have to have an Offer, Acceptance of that Offer, and Consideration. The...

Ryan Leslie (Leslie) is an American recording artist and NextSelection is a company that owns the trademark to Leslie's name and performances. While on tour in Germany, Leslie's laptop computer,...

In Stong v. Lane, the court put great weight on the fact that the parties' misunderstanding was __________________. a deliberate deception by both parties an honest mistake by both parties an honest...

This is the case of Brief: Kolodziej v Mason Question: please summarize and include the following; Fact: Judgment: Issue: Holding: General Analysis Applied Analysis: Kolodziej v. Mason 774 F.3d 736...

This is the case of Kolodziej v. Mason Question: please summarize and include the following; Fact: Judgment: Issue: Holding: General Analysis Applied Analysis: Kolodziej v. Mason 774 F.3d 736 (11th...

Read the article, "John D.R. Leonard, Plaintiff, -against- PepsiCo, Inc., Defendant," found on the website provided in the Reading & Study folder. Watch the presentations (also found in the Reading &...

All relevant information has been provided study case 7.2 . Study case provided. Must answer the questions at the end of the study case and answer the question : what is the consideration exchange in...

in australia 1. Identify and explain the unethical real estate practice that has occured. 2. Explain how the unethical practice relates to consumer protection requirements. 3. Identify and explain...

- Why did the judge decide that intoxication was an inadequate reason for voiding the contract? - To what extent does the objective theory of contracts enter into the judges reasoning in this case?...

What are the requirements for acquiring property by adverse possession?

Doberman Incorporated started selling Ipad with a four-year warranty against factory defects in 2014. Estimated warranty costs related to pesos sales are as follows: 1% of sales in the year of sale,...

Chipotle ( CMG ) is currently trading at $ 1 1 6 7 / share . You heard someone say there was another e . coli outbreak at one of their restaurants. Hoping to make a quick profit you short a 2 - day...

Original activity-based costing, activity-based management (Adapted from CMA, June 1992) Alaire Corporation manufactures several different types of printed-circuit boards; however, two of the boards...

What information does the cash payback period ignore that is included by the net present value method?

Differentiate between a cost center and a profit center.

Why should the factors under the control of the investment center manager (revenues, expenses, and invested assets) be considered in computing the rate of return on investment?

A couple who were new to a community had two young children, aged 5 and 10. Two different friends recommended two different pediatric groups for their children. The couple chose one particular group....

14. Think of a positive experience in your life, once you experienced that you had great creativity, great insight or a very strong concentration around some-thing you focused strongly on achieving....

How will it feel to have achieved this? Describe this briefly to yourself.

What does this look like?