Make a valid make a valid contract of for your customer who wants to book a trip to japan with your agency . To scenario is you are the manager of a and a travel and tours .

Facts: on march 28 , 1958 , air france through its authorized agent philippine airlines , issued to mr. Smith a first class round trip airplane ticket from manila to canada . from manila to south korea , mr smith traveled in first class but at south korea , the manager of air france airline force him to became the first class seat that he was occupying because there was a white man who has a better right To the seat . When asked to vacate his first class seat , mr smith refused and a commotion and ensued. He was pacified by some filipino passengers . Mr smith reluctantly gave his first class seat in the plane.

Issue: is air france liable for contravention of tenor of the obligation ?