Mr. A is a psychotherapist who has worked at a community mental health clinic for the past
Question:
- Mr. A is a psychotherapist who has worked at a community mental health clinic for the past 10 years serving adults with a wide range of presenting problems. He has been treating Patient M for the past 6 months. Patient M is a highly educated, married woman, 35 years of age, from a country in Latin America and has been in the United States for the past 2 years. She was referred to the mental health clinic by her primary care doctor because of her severe and frequent panic attacks, nightmares, seeing and hearing dead people talking to her, and severe depression. Over the course of the first several months of treatment, Patient M has shared bits and pieces of her story with Mr. A. He has learned that the patient was working as a teacher in her community and was active in one of the opposition political groups in her country. She fled her country after soldiers killed opposition party supporters and their families in her town one night, including her husband and child. She was at a distant neighbor's house when the massacre took place, tending to a sick friend, and she believes that is why the soldiers did not find her. She tells Mr. A that she is too afraid to return to her country and is seeking asylum in the United States.
Mr. A finds himself flooded with many painful emotions in and after sessions with Patient M. He often feels horrified and has desires for revenge as she discusses her memories of finding her dead husband and child when she returned home that night. He feels terrified by the thought that Patient M may be deported to her native country where her life may be in danger. Mr. A has not experienced much trauma in his own life and definitely does not identify with Patient M's experiences. Mr. A finds it extremely difficult to tolerate the intensity of his feelings when working with this patient. In order to avoid the pain associated with these feelings, he unconsciously develops empathic withdrawal toward Patient M. Mr. A's countertransference reactions alternate between intellectualizing, blank-screen faade, and misconception of the dynamics with his client. For example, Mr. A has unconsciously distanced himself from Patient M and often blankly stares at her when she brings up anything related to her traumas. Mr. A's reactions have led him to neglect to thoroughly assess the patient's traumatic experiences and the origins of her current symptoms. This, in turn, has led him to inaccurately assume and interpret Patient M's experiences of seeing and hearing of dead people talking to her as psychotic symptoms rather than as possibly part of her post-traumatic stress reaction. Patient M has not experienced any significant relief of symptoms.(NetCe Continuing Education, 2019)
- What are the factors that appear to have made Mr. A at risk for developing vicarious trauma?
- What signs and/or symptoms of vicarious trauma is Mr. A experiencing?
- Do you feel it is emotionally safe for Patient M to continue to work with Mr. A? Why or why not?
- What is Mr. A at risk to develop should he continue working with Patient M?
- What are some supports that Mr. A's place of work could incorporate into their policies and procedures?