Mr. Wu has been employed by Animation Movie Limited as an art director in movie production...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Mr. Wu has been employed by Animation Movie Limited as an art director in movie production for five years and his income has been assessed under Hong Kong Salaries Tax. On 1 April 2012 Mr. Wu established a limited company. Wu Limited, owned by him and his wife and re-arranged his relationship with Animation Movie Limited ("the arrangement") in the following manner: (i) Animation Movie Limited will pay Wu Limited an annual fee of $1,440,000 which is equal to Mr. Wu's annual salary. This annual fee is to be paid in the following manner - $120,000 to be paid monthly to Wu Limited over a 12- month period (ii) both parties may terminate the contract by giving the other party one month's prior notice. (iii) Despite Wu Limited will provide "art director-related" services to Animation Movie Limited, there is no change on supervision and reporting duties between Mr. Wu and Animation Movie Limited. (iv) Wu Limited will employ Mr. Wu in order to provide the services as described in (iii) above to Animation Movie Limited. (v) Apart from monthly salaries, Wu Limited will generously provide Mr. Wu with employment/ fringe benefits. The Inland Revenue Department (IRD) came to know about the arrangement and sent letters to Mr. Wu and ABC Animation Limited to ask for further information. After 12 months, the IRD sent a letter to Mr. Wu. The IRD letter advised that Mr. Wut should be considered to be an employee of Animation Movie I imited and an additional assessment was raised under salaries tax to include the payments from Animation Movie Limited. Mr. Wu did not raise any objection to that tax assessmen.. months later, the IRD issued a letter in which it proposed raising additional tax on Mr. Wu under section 82A of the Inland Revenue Ordinance on the basis that he did not report the annual salary of $1,440,000 from Animation Movie Limited. Mr. Wu wishes to challenge the IRD's decision that he is an employee of Animation Movie Limited and also wonders what he should do about the letter relating to the proposed additional tax to be issued under section 82A of the Inland Revenue Ordinance by the IRD. Required: (a) Based of the above arrangement: (i) how Animation Movie Limited is assessed for Profits Tax (ii) how Mr. Wu is assessed for Salaries Tax (ignore any anti-avoidance provision in the Inland Revenue Ordinance) (3 marks) (b) Based on your answers in (a)(i), what are the favourable and unfavourable tax implications to Mr. Wu for engaging in the arrangements described above. (ignore any anti-avoidance provision in the Inland Revenue Ordinance) (4 marks) (c) Identify the anti-avoidance provision in the Inland Revenue Ordinance ("the provision") relevant to the arrangement described above and the tax implication if the provision is applied to Mr. Wu. (3 marks) (d) Discuss whether the arrangements described above can withstand challenge from the Inland Revenue Department pursuant to the anti-avoidance provision identified in (c). (6 marks) Mr. Wu has been employed by Animation Movie Limited as an art director in movie production for five years and his income has been assessed under Hong Kong Salaries Tax. On 1 April 2012 Mr. Wu established a limited company. Wu Limited, owned by him and his wife and re-arranged his relationship with Animation Movie Limited ("the arrangement") in the following manner: (i) Animation Movie Limited will pay Wu Limited an annual fee of $1,440,000 which is equal to Mr. Wu's annual salary. This annual fee is to be paid in the following manner - $120,000 to be paid monthly to Wu Limited over a 12- month period (ii) both parties may terminate the contract by giving the other party one month's prior notice. (iii) Despite Wu Limited will provide "art director-related" services to Animation Movie Limited, there is no change on supervision and reporting duties between Mr. Wu and Animation Movie Limited. (iv) Wu Limited will employ Mr. Wu in order to provide the services as described in (iii) above to Animation Movie Limited. (v) Apart from monthly salaries, Wu Limited will generously provide Mr. Wu with employment/ fringe benefits. The Inland Revenue Department (IRD) came to know about the arrangement and sent letters to Mr. Wu and ABC Animation Limited to ask for further information. After 12 months, the IRD sent a letter to Mr. Wu. The IRD letter advised that Mr. Wut should be considered to be an employee of Animation Movie I imited and an additional assessment was raised under salaries tax to include the payments from Animation Movie Limited. Mr. Wu did not raise any objection to that tax assessmen.. months later, the IRD issued a letter in which it proposed raising additional tax on Mr. Wu under section 82A of the Inland Revenue Ordinance on the basis that he did not report the annual salary of $1,440,000 from Animation Movie Limited. Mr. Wu wishes to challenge the IRD's decision that he is an employee of Animation Movie Limited and also wonders what he should do about the letter relating to the proposed additional tax to be issued under section 82A of the Inland Revenue Ordinance by the IRD. Required: (a) Based of the above arrangement: (i) how Animation Movie Limited is assessed for Profits Tax (ii) how Mr. Wu is assessed for Salaries Tax (ignore any anti-avoidance provision in the Inland Revenue Ordinance) (3 marks) (b) Based on your answers in (a)(i), what are the favourable and unfavourable tax implications to Mr. Wu for engaging in the arrangements described above. (ignore any anti-avoidance provision in the Inland Revenue Ordinance) (4 marks) (c) Identify the anti-avoidance provision in the Inland Revenue Ordinance ("the provision") relevant to the arrangement described above and the tax implication if the provision is applied to Mr. Wu. (3 marks) (d) Discuss whether the arrangements described above can withstand challenge from the Inland Revenue Department pursuant to the anti-avoidance provision identified in (c). (6 marks)
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
ai Animation Movie Limited is assessed for Profits Tax based on its income from the services it rece... View the full answer
Related Book For
Introduction To Federal Income Taxation In Canada
ISBN: 9781554965021
33rd Edition
Authors: Robert E. Beam, Stanley N. Laiken, James J. Barnett
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
Michael, an Australian citizen, has been employed by an Australian Bank for the past four years. On 1 December 2020 Michael departed Australia to establish a new branch of his employers bank in the...
-
Julie is a university lecturer who has been employed by a university in Brisbane. On 1 March 2020 she accepts an offer to work at the London School of Economics for three years. On this date she...
-
Carina Cooks has been employed by Realfood Restaurant Group (RRG) for around 3 years. Cooks was first hired as a line cook. After seeing Cooks potential, Cooks was quickly promoted to Sous Chef. At...
-
Oriole Company just began business and made the following four inventory purchases in June: June 1 174 units $ 1044 June 10 232 units 1624 June 15 232 units 1856 June 28 174 units 1566 $ 6090 A...
-
Using Exhibits 3-1 and 3-9 as your guides, graph the inductions and deductions in the following statements. If there are gaps, supply what is needed to make them complete arguments. a. Repeated...
-
Charger Electronics had the following items that require adjusting entries at the end of the year. 1. Charger pays its employees $2,500 every Friday. This year December 31 falls on a Thursday. 2....
-
Abbott Industries is a well-known supplier of pharmaceuticals worldwide. Founded by Dr. Wallace Abbott, the company was incorporated in 1900 after he had been developing and making pharmaceuticals...
-
The following project is at the end of its sixth week. Find the cost and schedule variances. Also find the CPI and SPI. Then find the critical ratio of the project using earned value calculations....
-
Nina has been with Elora Enterprises for 5 years and is a Customer Service Representative. She earns $2000.00 bi-weekly working 35 hours per week. She does not work any overtime. She has not reached...
-
The shaft is supported by a smooth thrust bearing at B and a journal bearing at C. Determine the resultant internal loadings acting on the cross section at E. - 4 ft 4 ft +4 ft- 4 ft- 400 lb 800 lb
-
A store buys 125 cases. Each case contains 15 packages. They take a 6-month simple interest loan at 2.3%. What will the monthly payment be?
-
Which is the correct default route mapping within MVC? a. O b. O C. Controller -> View -> Model Model -> Controller -> View Model -> View -> Controller Od. Controller -> Model -> View
-
can be interpreted as the breakeven financing rate that leads to a profitable project. A. Discounted payback period B. Average accounting return C. Internal rate of return D. Net present value
-
Example.org uses servers on-premise to host its user accounts and rented storag applications. It is an example for akshi. 2024 akshis O Public cloud Private O Hybnakoud.goley N-2024 Reset cloud...
-
The process by which managers establish goals and specify how these goals are to be attained is: a. part of budgeting b. planning c. strategic management d. management by objectives e. organizing
-
Accounting for Asset Retirement Obligations - Comprehensive Information Step 1: Recognition of Asset Retirement Obligations (ARO) Asset Retirement Obligations (ARO) represent legal obligations...
-
Noble plc, a listed company, has for a number of years paid an annual dividend of 90p per share on its 200,000 ordinary shares, which have a total market value of 930,000 cum div. The next annual...
-
Write electron configurations for the following ions, and determine which have noble-gas configurations: (a) Cd2+ (b) p3- (c) Zr4+ (d) Ru3+ (e) As3- (f) Ag+
-
Valerie Borg is a vice-president of Program Management with an equipment leasing company in Calgary. Recently, Valerie was approached by a large public company, Key Equipment Finance Limited ("Key"),...
-
The taxpayer company, a private corporation, owned and operated a small shopping centre from which it received rental income. There were seven separate tenants, only one of them being what is...
-
The following situations deal with a Canadian-controlled private corporation and its shareholders. Each transaction described below is separate and distinct from the other transactions. (a) Capital...
-
Given the four criteria necessary for a sale to be complete, which of the following is not one of those conditions? 1. Delivery has occurred or services rendered. 2. Cash has been collected. 3. The...
-
What is the difference between a business and a pure charity? Between a business and a governmental agency?
-
Will reform have a greater impact on insurers or providers?
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App