PART $$A$.$ Discipline and dismissals. Four $(4)$ questions for a total of twenty $(20)$ marks

$1.$ What would you recommend as the course of action in regard to Jimmy Duncan? Explain your reasoning behind this. $(5$ marks$)$

$2.$ What would you recommend as the course of action in regard to Robert Gill? Explain your reasoning behind this. $(5$ marks$)$

$3.$ Can Jimmy file a grievance?$$ Can the union refuse to present Jimmy$$s grievance? What are the legal requirements for unions regarding their representation of workers? $(4$marks$)$

$4.$ If the union files a grievance on Jimmy Duncan$$s behalf, then

a$)$ what factors do you believe an arbitrator would take into account, and

b$)$ what do you believe the arbitrator$$s decision would be$?(6$ marks$)$