Please help with this assignment! The attorney that you work for, Mr. Samuel Cardoza, occasionally takes on small pro bono cases to assist the general public. Mr. Cardozo's solo practice is located at 533 West Jefferson, Phoenix, AZ 85003. Mr. Cardozo has recently taken on a small pro-bono case for a client named Winnie Lightning. Ms. Lightning resides at 3700 North 8th Street, Phoenix, AZ 85014. Ms. Lightning is subject to a civil penalty for a violation of City of Phoenix City Code Chapter 8, Sec. 8.2 Barking or Howling Dogs. Please refer to the following link to the city code in question:https://phoenix.municipal.codes/CC/8-2

The City is charging Ms. Lightning a $2,000 penalty for her barking dog, Fluffy. According to Ms. Lightning, she received a warning letter from the City of Phoenix dated January 3, 2023, concerning her barking dog, Fluffy. Apparently, neighbors are upset that Fluffy barks during the day and night. Ms. Lightning has made some efforts to try to quiet Fluffy, but to no avail. Ms. Lightning states that she cannot afford a $2,000 fine and is seeking advice about how to avoid or reduce the fine. Ms. Lightning doesn't contest that Fluffy does, in fact, bark. Mr. Cardozo doesn't normally handle relatively petty cases such as barking dogs. He has therefore tasked you to do the research concerning this case to determine what Ms. Cardozo's potential legal options are to deal with the fine. Prepare a memorandum regarding this case using the style and format provided by Illustration 19-1 inThe Legal Research and Writing Handbook. Please include at least three quotes and three peer-reviewed sources. The relevant binding case law for this case is State v. Singer, 190 AZ 48State v. Singer, 190 Ariz. 48 | Casetext Search + Citator

The Phoenix Municipal Code concerning appeals is located in 2-93:Chapter 2 Art. III City Court | Phoenix City Code (municipal.codes)