Question. Should Smith receive the Job offer. Why or why not? Case: Marita Smith works as a
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
- Question. Should Smith receive the Job offer. Why or why not?
Transcribed Image Text:
Case: Marita Smith works as a data entry clerk in a government department that is undergoing downsizing. Smith, who is severely hearing impaired, has been a productive employee in her department for the last five years. Her performance has always been above average. Smith has received notice that her position is being eliminated as part of the downsizing. Under her union's contract, she must be given preference for any government job that becomes available and for which she is qualified. Smith has been invited to apply for a term position in another government department, which is converting archival data from paper to an electronic database. To qualify for the position, Smith will have to pass an interview, a timed typing test, an accuracy test that involves accuracy in transcribing information from a computer screen, and another accuracy test that involves following written instructions to enter written records into the computer database. These are the same tests that all candidates for the position have had to pass to become eligible for the job. Smith was interviewed one week prior to being administered the three skill tests. The interview protocol followed a standardized form used by all government departments. The three skills tests were administered to groups of nine applicants each. The applicants were seated at desks with computers, which were arranged in three rows of three desks each. The instructions for the tests were given verbally by the test administrator. Smith was provided with the services of a sign language interpreter during the testing and interview sessions. Smith passed the interview but failed the skill tests. Her scores are presented in the table below along with the minimum scores that had to be obtained on each test to receive a job offer. Based on her performance on the tests, Smith did not receive an offer for the job and was laid off when her current job ended. Smith now believes that she was the victim of discrimination based on her physical disability; she claims that during the interview many references were made to her disability and that the interviewer always addressed questions to the sign language interpreter and never made eye contact with her. She feels that she was at a disadvantage in taking the skills tests. Her prospective employer claims that had she passed the tests she would have been hired and her disability would have been accommodated. The employer argues that the testing standards were reasonably necessary for the efficient performance of the work. The standards in the table are being justified as bona fide occupational requirements (BFORS). Smith has now filed a complaint with her provincial Human Rights Commission. Table-Smith's Scores Relative to Standards Needed to Pass Each Test Standards Interview Typing Test Smith 30 out of 50 points 50 words per minute with 5 errors 36 wpm - 5 errors or less Accuracy-Following Instructions 7 out of 10 Accuracy-Transcribing 7 out of 10 36 5,5 5 Case: Marita Smith works as a data entry clerk in a government department that is undergoing downsizing. Smith, who is severely hearing impaired, has been a productive employee in her department for the last five years. Her performance has always been above average. Smith has received notice that her position is being eliminated as part of the downsizing. Under her union's contract, she must be given preference for any government job that becomes available and for which she is qualified. Smith has been invited to apply for a term position in another government department, which is converting archival data from paper to an electronic database. To qualify for the position, Smith will have to pass an interview, a timed typing test, an accuracy test that involves accuracy in transcribing information from a computer screen, and another accuracy test that involves following written instructions to enter written records into the computer database. These are the same tests that all candidates for the position have had to pass to become eligible for the job. Smith was interviewed one week prior to being administered the three skill tests. The interview protocol followed a standardized form used by all government departments. The three skills tests were administered to groups of nine applicants each. The applicants were seated at desks with computers, which were arranged in three rows of three desks each. The instructions for the tests were given verbally by the test administrator. Smith was provided with the services of a sign language interpreter during the testing and interview sessions. Smith passed the interview but failed the skill tests. Her scores are presented in the table below along with the minimum scores that had to be obtained on each test to receive a job offer. Based on her performance on the tests, Smith did not receive an offer for the job and was laid off when her current job ended. Smith now believes that she was the victim of discrimination based on her physical disability; she claims that during the interview many references were made to her disability and that the interviewer always addressed questions to the sign language interpreter and never made eye contact with her. She feels that she was at a disadvantage in taking the skills tests. Her prospective employer claims that had she passed the tests she would have been hired and her disability would have been accommodated. The employer argues that the testing standards were reasonably necessary for the efficient performance of the work. The standards in the table are being justified as bona fide occupational requirements (BFORS). Smith has now filed a complaint with her provincial Human Rights Commission. Table-Smith's Scores Relative to Standards Needed to Pass Each Test Standards Interview Typing Test Smith 30 out of 50 points 50 words per minute with 5 errors 36 wpm - 5 errors or less Accuracy-Following Instructions 7 out of 10 Accuracy-Transcribing 7 out of 10 36 5,5 5
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
The Smith must have offered a job offer because she has fulfilled the criteria of th... View the full answer
Related Book For
Systems analysis and design in a changing world
ISBN: 978-1423902287
5th edition
Authors: John W. Satzinger, Robert B. Jackson, Stephen D. Burd
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
Should Smith receive the Job offer. Why or why not? Case: Marita Smith works as a data entry clerk in a government department that is undergoing downsizing. Smith, who is severely hearing impaired,...
-
Why is job satisfaction not strongly related to job performance?
-
Why is job satisfaction not strongly related to job performance? Discuss.
-
You have been provided the following data about the securities of three firms, the market portfolio, and the riskfree asset: a. Fill in the missing values in the table. b. Is the stock of Firm A...
-
A list of control procedures follows. a. Authorization b. Recording transactions c. Documents and records d. Physical controls e. Periodic independent verification f. Separation of duties g. Sound...
-
a. Construct a table that tabulates category, fees, and risk. b. What conclusions can you reach concerning differences among the categories of mutual funds (large cap, medium cap, and small cap),...
-
The journal entry for the purchase of $900 of inventory on account is as follows: DATE ACCOUNTS POST REF. DR. CR. a. Cost of Goods Sold 900 900 9 b. C. Accounts Payable Inventory Accounts Payable...
-
On April 16, 2014, ColorCo purchased a put option for $800 on Choco common stock. The put option gives ColorCo the option to sell 5,000 shares of Choco at a strike price of $25 per share for a period...
-
Assuming that the ELN offers a Fixed Coupon or Yield of 12.00% act/360, what is the future value in USD of this Fixed Coupon plus the Notional? Show your result to the nearest cent. ii) Note that the...
-
Lopez Company reported the following current-year data for its only product. The company uses a periodic inventory system, and its ending inventory consists of 150 units50 from each of the last three...
-
The Greek word for actor is "hypokrite," the source of the English word "hypocrite." Look the term up in the dictionary. Is role-playing in real life hypocritical? Are actors not to be trusted...
-
How to calculate loss on discontinued operations? Balances are from the adjusted trial balance, they're pre-tax, tax rate is 35%: Loss due to hurricane (unusual, material and infrequent) 600 COGS...
-
3. Describe at least two negative outcomes of having too little money and credit in the economy. ( 4. Describe at least two negative outcomes of having too much money and credit in the economy.
-
The following items were taken from the financial statements of Blue Spruce Manufacturing, Inc., over a three-year period: Item Net Sales 2023 2022 2021 $224,000 $211,000 $200,000 Cost of Goods Sold...
-
Sound source A is located at x = 0, y = 0, and sound source B is located at x = 0, y = 3.10 m. The two sources radiate coherently and in phase. An observer at x = 19.0 m, y = 0 notes that as he takes...
-
a. Chi Han receives all incoming customer cash receipts for her employer and posts the customer payments to their respective accounts. b. Sutton Company has two employees handling acquisitions of...
-
A two-dimensional compressor cascade is tested in air (y = 1.4, Cp = 1004.5 J/kgK) with an inlet stagnation pressure of 1 bar and an inlet stagnation temperature of 300 K. For an inlet Mach number of...
-
You are maintaining a subsidiary ledger account for Police-Training Expenditures for 2013. The following columns are used: Inventory purchases are initially recorded as expenditures. Record the...
-
Describe the process of network design.
-
List and briefly describe the characteristics that an analyst examines when choosing or defining the deployment environment.
-
What is a relationship?
-
Why is the thermodynamic process also called cyclic process? Explain with suitable example.
-
A mercury manometer reads \(40 \mathrm{~cm}\) at \(30^{\circ} \mathrm{C}\) and \(1 \mathrm{~atm}\). Determine the absolute pressure, given that \(ho_{\mathrm{Hg}}=14.02 \mathrm{~g} /...
-
Define isothermal, isochoric and isobaric processes with suitable examples.
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App