Reading Response: Structure

Read the NYT article

https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2013/01/14/structure

Then, respond to two of the following questions:

1. How does McPhee define "structure" in the context of writing? How does his definition align with or differ from your own understanding of structure in writing?
2. McPhee discusses the concept of "structure" through the analogy of a building. What are the key components of this analogy, and how does it help to clarify the role of structure in writing?
3. McPhee argues that structure is essential for both fiction and nonfiction writing. Do you agree with this assertion? Why or why not? Provide examples from the text or from your own reading experience to support your viewpoint.
4. Throughout the article, McPhee emphasizes the importance of outlining and planning before writing. How does this approach to writing align with or challenge your own writing process? Do you typically outline your writing projects beforehand? Why or why not?
5. McPhee discusses the tension between spontaneity and structure in writing. How does he navigate this tension in his own writing process, according to the article? Do you think striking a balance between spontaneity and structure is important in writing? Why or why not?
6. The article mentions various techniques for creating structure in writing, such as chronology, contrast, and parallelism. Can you identify examples of these techniques in McPhee's own writing, as demonstrated in the article? How do these techniques contribute to the overall effectiveness of his writing?
7. McPhee emphasizes the importance of revising and reorganizing drafts to achieve optimal structure. How does this approach to revision compare to your own revision process? What strategies do you typically employ when revising your writing to improve its structure?
8. McPhee discusses the concept of "cutting and folding" in relation to structure. What does he mean by this term, and how does it relate to the process of refining structure in writing? Can you think of examples from your own writing or from published works where "cutting and folding" might be beneficial?
9. How does McPhee use anecdotes and examples throughout the article to illustrate his points about structure? Which anecdotes or examples stand out to you as particularly effective, and why?
10. Reflecting on your reading of "Structure," how has this article influenced your understanding of the importance of structure in writing? In what ways, if any, do you plan to apply the insights gained from this article to your own writing practice?